VOTE Darius Boyd vs Billy Slater

Who should be the Maroons fullback for Game II

  • Billy Slater

  • Darius Boyd

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.
OXY-351

OXY-351

NRL Player
Oct 1, 2008
Threads
10
2,058
609
as Bennett said "the QLD selectors thought Boyd was the best option at fullback 3 weeks ago, and he hasn't done anything wrong to lose his spot"

The QLD selectors also thought Myles, Thaiday and O'niell were the best options too. Maybe the selectors were wrong.
 
Foordy

Foordy

International Captain
Mar 4, 2008
Threads
797
27,624
27,188
The QLD selectors also thought Myles, Thaiday and O'niell were the best options too. Maybe the selectors were wrong.
Yeah, but unlike Myles, Infill and Thaiday ... Boyd did nothing wrong to lose his position.
 
B

Broncs_Fan

NRL Player
Jun 5, 2015
Threads
4
2,473
1,129
Yeah, but unlike Myles, Infill and Thaiday ... Boyd did nothing wrong to lose his position.

Slater is a bigger threat at breaking the line on kick return. I'm happy for Slater to be back tbh.
 
OXY-351

OXY-351

NRL Player
Oct 1, 2008
Threads
10
2,058
609
Yeah, but unlike Myles, Infill and Thaiday ... Boyd did nothing wrong to lose his position.

True, but I also don't think he did anything spectacular to keep it either.

I feel a bit sorry for Boyd though. Only a great game and a QLD win was going to put the Slater-Boyd argument to bed. With a QLD loss, it seemed inevtiable that Slater would be back (assuming he is).
 
B

Broncs_Fan

NRL Player
Jun 5, 2015
Threads
4
2,473
1,129
Walters still isn't being totally ruthless though. Oates is a better option than Boyd on the wing imo. Especially for those hard carries out of Qld's own end. But he did not want to drop him completely after bringing back Slater it seems.

Boyd should be fullback or not in the team I think.
 
Foordy

Foordy

International Captain
Mar 4, 2008
Threads
797
27,624
27,188
Walters still isn't being totally ruthless though. Oates is a better option than Boyd on the wing imo. Especially for those hard carries out of Qld's own end. But he did not want to drop him completely after bringing back Slater it seems.

Boyd should be fullback or not in the team I think.

you realise Boyd has the second most tries in state of origin history ... the majority (if not all) were scored on the wing
 
Foordy

Foordy

International Captain
Mar 4, 2008
Threads
797
27,624
27,188
Only a great game and a QLD win was going to put the Slater-Boyd argument to bed

here's a question what if QLD lose game 2 and Slater is not the magician everyone thinks he will be?
 
OXY-351

OXY-351

NRL Player
Oct 1, 2008
Threads
10
2,058
609
you realise Boyd has the second most tries in state of origin history ... the majority (if not all) were scored on the wing

How many do you think any other player would not have scored?
 
OXY-351

OXY-351

NRL Player
Oct 1, 2008
Threads
10
2,058
609
here's a question what if QLD lose game 2 and Slater is not the magician everyone thinks he will be?

Don't get me wrong. I don't think Slater being in the team automatically means QLD wins. I don't think it changes the result in game 1 at all. The QLD backline didn't lose that game. I do however think Slater offers more at FB than Boyd does.

But in saying that, I do find it very un-QLD like what has happened. With all this talk of loyalty, I think Slater deserved the loyalty to be extended to him in game 1. If Slater doesn't get injured in 2015 and again in 2016, I doubt Boyd is the FB today. But QLD chose to stick with Boyd, which while I don't fully agree with, I can understand and accept it. But if the selectors now turn around and select Slater again, it seems like they are now being disloyal to Boyd a little.
 
Big Pete

Big Pete

International Captain
Mar 12, 2008
Threads
1,372
29,221
17,762
The Boyd v Slater argument was weird, at least from the loyalty perspective.

Who do you go for?

The guy who is arguably the greatest fullback ever to come out of the state but hadn't really made an impact at this level since 2013?

Or one of your greatest try scorers who happened to be the best player from the last series?

In hindsight it's easy to say Slater because the team didn't win, but shoe on the other foot we're probably saying the other thing.

Regardless, Billy has his spot back, it's a wonderful achievement and I'm hoping we see his best in the coming days.
 
Horseheadsup

Horseheadsup

NRL Player
Mar 21, 2016
Threads
3
2,539
1,209
The Boyd v Slater argument was weird, at least from the loyalty perspective.

Who do you go for?

The guy who is arguably the greatest fullback ever to come out of the state but hadn't really made an impact at this level since 2013?

Or one of your greatest try scorers who happened to be the best player from the last series?

In hindsight it's easy to say Slater because the team didn't win, but shoe on the other foot we're probably saying the other thing.

Regardless, Billy has his spot back, it's a wonderful achievement and I'm hoping we see his best in the coming days.
Guess their going with the so called big 3, Slater, Cronk, and Smith.
 
OXY-351

OXY-351

NRL Player
Oct 1, 2008
Threads
10
2,058
609
The Boyd v Slater argument was weird, at least from the loyalty perspective.

Who do you go for?

The guy who is arguably the greatest fullback ever to come out of the state but hadn't really made an impact at this level since 2013?

Or one of your greatest try scorers who happened to be the best player from the last series?

It's easy. You put the greatest fullback at fullback, and the greatest origin try scoring winger on the wing :D
 
Big Pete

Big Pete

International Captain
Mar 12, 2008
Threads
1,372
29,221
17,762
Like I said, it's easy to say now in hindsight, but Billy hadn't lived up to that reputation in a long long time and Boyd was not only great for Queensland, he was great for Australia too.

If Billy was to play, the only room for Darius was in the centres.
 
OXY-351

OXY-351

NRL Player
Oct 1, 2008
Threads
10
2,058
609
Like I said, it's easy to say now in hindsight, but Billy hadn't lived up to that reputation in a long long time and Boyd was not only great for Queensland, he was great for Australia too.

Only because he'd been injured for so long imo. Given some of the other nuffies in the QLD team that have been riding on past glory over the past couple of years, I would have thought Slater deserved a bit of it as well.

I just think the QLD team is stronger with them both in it. I don't see why they both couldn't have been in game 1. Even if QLD had won in game 1, I'd still think the team is better for having Boyd and Slater in it.
 
Big Pete

Big Pete

International Captain
Mar 12, 2008
Threads
1,372
29,221
17,762
Even before his long lay-offs OXY, Slater looked like a spent force in Origin. When he went down in Origin II 2015, the Maroons looked drastically better with two different fullbacks in his stead.

I can understand wanting Slater in the team for what he offers as a player, but can you see why the loyalty argument is odd?
 
Nashy

Nashy

International Captain
Senior Staff
Mar 5, 2008
Threads
1,455
47,415
23,497
Only because he'd been injured for so long imo. Given some of the other nuffies in the QLD team that have been riding on past glory over the past couple of years, I would have thought Slater deserved a bit of it as well.

I just think the QLD team is stronger with them both in it. I don't see why they both couldn't have been in game 1. Even if QLD had won in game 1, I'd still think the team is better for having Boyd and Slater in it.

You realise how old he is yeah? He shouldn't be there, we should be moving on from the old guard, not embracing it.
 
broncsgoat

broncsgoat

Banned User
Oct 28, 2013
Threads
27
10,196
11,417
The counter argument to that is Slater's club form is on another planet compared to what it was in 14/15 so there's no reason it would carry through to the origin arena.

I would still rather the back 3 from Origin one and finding a centre from somewhere.
 

Tipping Ladder

  • tommy
    92.00 pts

    tommy

    • Correct picks
      92 out of 124
  • Waynesaurus
    89.00 pts

    Waynesaurus

    • Correct picks
      89 out of 124
  • ivanhungryjak
    87.00 pts

    ivanhungryjak

    • Correct picks
      87 out of 124
  • morethenjack
    87.00 pts

    morethenjack

    • Correct picks
      87 out of 124
  • RolledOates
    87.00 pts

    RolledOates

    • Correct picks
      87 out of 124

Forum statistics

Threads
19,400
Messages
1,235,673
Members
1,661
Latest member
Footy fan

Members online

  • Aldo
  • Allo
  • theshed
  • Dreaglor
  • eggstar10
  • I bleed Maroon
  • Gaz
  • McHunt
  • Johnny92
  • Spoon
  • LockyersLeftBoot
  • Alec
  • johnny plath
  • Volvo Driver
  • Skyblues87
  • broncos4life
  • Xzei
  • Galah
  • Dee
  • Hurrijo
... and 13 more.
Team P W L PD Pts
16 15 1 306 30
15 11 4 203 24
16 12 4 195 24
15 10 5 80 22
15 9 6 43 20
15 9 6 18 20
15 8 7 39 18
15 8 7 -70 18
16 8 8 2 16
16 7 9 21 14
16 7 9 -41 14
15 5 10 -152 12
16 5 11 -165 10
16 4 12 -119 8
15 3 12 -188 8
16 3 13 -172 6
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.