Religion and Politics

Unbreakable

International Rep
Staff
16,001
12,928
🌏
Mate, I’m no SJW. I just stand up for people I know who have real struggles.
I know they have real struggles, people cuddling them and saying "It's ok, it's society's fault you feel like an outsider" really aren't helping them.

So you are saying intersex people are not valid humans?
Another thing the left is phenomenal at, putting words in your mouth.

You said gender (sex) is non-binary, I asked you to elaborate. I mentioned people who were born Intersex because that's a common argument on the left, but it's actually not, it's a statistical anomaly that is incredibly rare, it doesn't add anything to the argument that sex is biologically non-binary.

And further to that, the vast majority of people who are born Intersex have features predominantly leaning one way or the other in terms of sex (brain size, bone structure, genitalia, etc.)

Edit: I actually need to do some work now so I can spend the weekend watching the Nines, but happy to continue the convo at a later date if anyone wants to add their 2 cents. I don't think this discussion should be anywhere as near as hostile as it's portrayed to be, it's a discussion about science at it's core.
 
Last edited:

soup

State of Origin Rep
7,894
5,667
T’ba
I know they have real struggles, people cuddling them and saying "It's ok, it's society's fault you feel like an outsider" really aren't helping them.



Another thing the left is phenomenal at, putting words in your mouth.

You said gender (sex) is non-binary, I asked you to elaborate. I mentioned people who were born Intersex because that's a common argument on the left, but it's actually not, it's a statistical anomaly that is incredibly rare, it doesn't add anything to the argument that sex is biologically non-binary.

And further to that, the vast majority of people who are born Intersex have features predominantly leaning one way or the other in terms of sex (brain size, bone structure, genitalia, etc.)

Edit: I actually need to do some work now so I can spend the weekend watching the Nines, but happy to continue the convo at a later date if anyone wants to add their 2 cents. I don't think this discussion should be anywhere as near as hostile as it's portrayed to be, it's a discussion about science at it's core.
Rubbish, it’s a self-satisfying generalisation that you are stroking your ego with at the cost of others. Nothing to do with science.

Speaking of facts, as almost one in every two Australians experience mental illness in their life, it’s pretty convenient to apportion mental illness to be the primary factor in causation of social or sexual ‘deviations’ from the historic norm.
 
Last edited:

Unbreakable

International Rep
Staff
16,001
12,928
🌏
Last reply for tonight, I need to stop procrastinating :L

Rubbish, it’s a self-satisfying generalisation that you are stroking your ego with at the cost of others. Nothing to do with science.
It has quite literally everything to do with science, the entire basis of my side of the argument is science, biology & biological psychology. Your side of the argument is the one that throws all of that out the window.

Speaking of facts, as almost one in every two Australians experience mental illness in their life, it’s pretty convenient to apportion mental illness to be the primary factor in causation of social or sexual ‘deviations’ from the historic norm.
Transgenderism & Gender Dysphoria aren't 'social' or 'sexual' deviations...
 

soup

State of Origin Rep
7,894
5,667
T’ba
Last reply for tonight, I need to stop procrastinating :L



It has quite literally everything to do with science, the entire basis of my side of the argument is science, biology & biological psychology. Your side of the argument is the one that throws all of that out the window.



Transgenderism & Gender Dysphoria aren't 'social' or 'sexual' deviations...
My brain is absolute mush from this flu mate. I’m actually embarrassed at how poorly I’m arguing this tbh. Time to have a lay down and leave this for another day when 90% of my brain cells haven’t been blown out my nose.
 

soup

State of Origin Rep
7,894
5,667
T’ba
My main point here is that we should see the person, value them for their intentions, not the packaging.

As for all the political correctness garbage, I agree. It should be sent out to sea and set on fire.
 

Dash

NRL Captain
3,128
2,321
Brisbane
Oh really?.. Please elaborate.

And don't bother mentioning obvious outliers, like people born Intersex.

Edit: Also, gender is what the left calls the "societal construct", you must be thinking of sex. Might need to dust up on your terminology if you want to be a true SJW. 😂
If it's possible for someone to be born physically intersex, why can't it be possible for someone to be born psychologically intersex?
 

Porthoz

International Captain
Staff
My main point here is that we should see the person, value them for their intentions, not the packaging.

As for all the political correctness garbage, I agree. It should be sent out to sea and set on fire.
I think this post sums my thoughts up perfectly.

I guess it depends on one's definition of illness or disease, but I don't consider these gender/sexual deviations a disease anymore than someone one the autism spectrum. They deserve respect and recognition as different human beings, period.

Your second paragraph is what is really being discussed here, and is merely one example of the many shots in the foot from parties in the centre/left pandering to the SJW idiots... which the right is taking advantage of, especially through the well oiled alt right propaganda machine.
 
Last edited:

Broncapz

QCup Player
716
1,135
I guess it depends on one's definition of illness or disease, but I don't consider these gender/sexual deviations a disease anymore than someone one the autism spectrum. They deserve respect and recognition as different human beings, period.
I'm not a fan of how broad the Autism spectrum is. You have people that a perfectly functioning members of society, and then down to people that will never be independent or talk in their life.

I think having the spectrum so broad really diminishes the support that people on the more extreme end of the spectrum get.

Because of this, we get things like 'Autism is a super power' which is great for kids/people on the lighter end of the spectrum, but feels like total bullshit for people struggling caring for someone on the extreme end.
 

Unbreakable

International Rep
Staff
16,001
12,928
🌏
If it's possible for someone to be born physically intersex, why can't it be possible for someone to be born psychologically intersex?
Because doctors have scans and tests they can run to determine the make-up of your brain. There is a discernible difference in the average brain of a male and the average brain of a female, there is no 'middle ground' in regards to the brain, scientifically speaking. Even people born Intersex have one or the other, and develop as such.

Do you want to know the only time where transgenders have been proven to have that of a similar brain to the opposite sex? When they've had hormone replacement therapy prior to puberty. That's right, there's people out there who are willing to give children as young as 6 years old the ability to make that decision, I watched a video the other day of an 8 year old that was given the choice to get the sex change surgery, they allowed it. It's genuinely sickening what they're doing to these kids.

Don't even get me started on the parents raising their children as "Theybies" either. Disgusting.
 

Broncapz

QCup Player
716
1,135
I watched a video the other day of an 8 year old that was given the choice to get the sex change surgery, they allowed it. It's genuinely sickening what they're doing to these kids.
I agree protections must be in place to protect children from engaging in non-reversable plastic surgery.

What Trump/other established candidates have failed to do is protect children in others ways. i.e school lunch debt, crazy medical and student debt. The system is rigged to put as many people in debt as possible, with that money funneled to the very few, while the biggest earners end up avoiding paying the same relative tax that small-medium businesses pay.

For some of these kids, school lunch is the only real meal they'll eat all day.
 
Last edited:

Dash

NRL Captain
3,128
2,321
Brisbane
Because doctors have scans and tests they can run to determine the make-up of your brain. There is a discernible difference in the average brain of a male and the average brain of a female, there is no 'middle ground' in regards to the brain, scientifically speaking. Even people born Intersex have one or the other, and develop as such.
Doesn't the term "average" imply there is variation in each brain? Could there not be outliers closer to the opposite sex, or people who fall half way between?
 

Unbreakable

International Rep
Staff
16,001
12,928
🌏
Doesn't the term "average" imply there is variation in each brain? Could there not be outliers closer to the opposite sex, or people who fall half way between?
There is small variations yeah. But I mean very small, I've never seen anything even remotely suggesting it's possible to have a brain that's 50% male traits and 50% female traits.

Even if there was such a thing, it has no correlation to transgenderism, all the studies have shown that male to female transitioners have a male brain, and vice versa, unless there's hormonal intervention prior to puberty (which also causes a litany of other problems mind you).
 

I bleed Maroon

State of Origin Captain
8,642
6,509
This stuff is all an offshoot of the continuing myth that children are incapable of thinking for themselves, or making well thought out decisions. I've got some news for you parents: There is a very good likelihood that your 13 year old is already smarter than you are, if not as mature. They spend every waking hour glued to some form of technology, not just rotting their brains on social media, but also doing research on serious topics out of nothing but raw curiosity. And by doing so, they discover things about themselves and the world around them that they didn't even know before.

In short, they are adapting themselves to be what they want to be far, far faster than you ever did. And guess what: giving your own child the benefit of the doubt will go a long way for both you and them.
 
Last edited:

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create free account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Login or Register

Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Register now

Twitter

Top