CROSS FORUM NRL 2023 Round 19 Discussion

[Miket12]

Foran’s argument…. Clark wasn’t penalised the two other times he was offside so why ping him now.

 

[ZTop]

Foran’s argument…. Clark wasn’t penalised the two other times he was offside so why ping him now.

It's fair enough

 

[Beastmode]

Foran’s argument…. Clark wasn’t penalised the two other times he was offside so why ping him now.

Can you imagine if this was the Warriors ?

There was would a total meltdown from us fans

Tough luck Titans

 

[HK_Eagle]

That smacks of a ref who just has to be in the limelight. I mean c'mon... how long have we been playing GP and when is offside ever called? It happens every single FG attempt during GP

 

[Beastmode]

That smacks of a ref who just has to be in the limelight. I mean c'mon... how long have we been playing GP and when is offside ever called? It happens every single FG attempt during GP

I agree

I don’t like games being decided from such pedantic calls

 

[ZTop]

That smacks of a ref who just has to be in the limelight. I mean c'mon... how long have we been playing GP and when is offside ever called? It happens every single FG attempt during GP

Aitkens always want to have the last say

 

[Miket12]

It's fair enough

I think Clark was should have been penalised the other times…. just as Bromwich should have been penalised for the late hot on Boyd when his field goal attempt went astray.

 

[The Don]

Why am I not surprised?

 

[Ever Hopeful]

It shits me that players block field goals by being way offside. Stamp it out for good.

Even better though, stamp out golden point.

 

[HK_Eagle]

I think Clark was should have been penalised the other times…. just as Bromwich should have been penalised for the late hot on Boyd when his field goal attempt went astray.

I just wish the NRL would actually crack down on the looseness of GP. Let teams know that it will be officiated the same as regular time and they will be looking at offside especially down near the line.

 

[Beastmode]

I think Clark was should have been penalised the other times…. just as Bromwich should have been penalised for the late hit on Boyd when his field goal attempt went astray.

If I wanted to watch penalties I ‘d watch rugby

 

[Beastmode]

I just wish the NRL would actually crack down on the looseness of GP. Let teams know that it will be officiated the same as regular time and they will be looking at offside especially down near the line.

Totally ruins the game if a penalty decides GP

This being a classic example. It ended so flat

 

[HK_Eagle]

If I wanted to watch penalties I ‘d watch rugby

Yeah, but they only commit the offences because they know it is highly unlikely to get called. If they started calling them, teams would start pulling their heads in.

 

[Miket12]

If I wanted to watch penalties I ‘d watch rugby

Bye….

 

[Xzei]

mile offside play stupid games win stupid prizes

 

[Brocko]

I get its a shit way to end a game but he was a mile offside and had been warned.

The real problem is that the next 10 times we see players a mile offside to block a game deciding FG nothing will happen.

 

[bruce]

Foran’s argument…. Clark wasn’t penalised the two other times he was offside so why ping him now.

Because Gee called him out...twice...he had to penalise him

 

[Brocko]

What do our Wahs and Silvertails friends think of all the fuss being kicked up about Origin depleted games all of a sudden?

Very convenient that Eels and Rabbits lose one impacted game a piece and now suddenly parts of the media are pushing for change.