VOTE BHQ Player of Round 4

[Johnny92]

1 point for Piakuras hit on Herbie

 

[McHunt]

Only player you would not be happy with is Arthars but other than that, everyone else was pretty good and most of the time so to is Arthars.

I was about to say Jensen, but I looked up his stats: 36 tackles in 48 minutes. That flew under the radar.

 

[Sproj]

I was about to say Jensen, but I looked up his stats: 36 tackles in 48 minutes. That flew under the radar.

Yeah good call and he played more minutes than he probably expected as well. He has stepped up the last two weeks well.

 

[davidp]

Haas
Reynolds
Shiba

Loved aggression of Staggs and Riki had a very solid game

Also impressed with Walsh - excellent defensive structure so talked and organised well and was safe but dangerous with the ball

 

[Mustafur]

Shiba, Reyno and haas.

 

[Super Freak]

3 - Gem
2 - Reyno
1 - Haas

Special mention - Patty for that hit on Gilbert.

 

[McHunt]

CM Player Ratings:

1 REECE WALSH: 7
2 SELWYN COBBO: 7
3 KOTONI STAGGS: 8.5
4 GEHAMAT SHIBASAKI: 9
5 JESSE ARTHARS: 7
6 BEN HUNT: 6
7 ADAM REYNOLDS: 6.5
8 PAT CARRIGAN: 7
9 CORY PAIX: 7
10 PAYNE HAAS: 8
11 JACK GOSIEWSKI: 6.5
12 JORDAN RIKI: 8
13 KOBE HETHERINGTON: 5
14 BILLY WALTERS: 6
15 COREY JENSEN: 6
16 XAVIER WILLISON: 6
17 BRENDAN PIAKURA: 4

I don't know where Badel gets his stats (tackles, for example) but what's cited in this piece doesn't line up with NRL.com. Not the first time I've noticed this.

 

[Sproj]

CM Player Ratings:

1 REECE WALSH: 7
2 SELWYN COBBO: 7
3 KOTONI STAGGS: 8.5
4 GEHAMAT SHIBASAKI: 9
5 JESSE ARTHARS: 7
6 BEN HUNT: 6
7 ADAM REYNOLDS: 6.5
8 PAT CARRIGAN: 7
9 CORY PAIX: 7
10 PAYNE HAAS: 8
11 JACK GOSIEWSKI: 6.5
12 JORDAN RIKI: 8
13 KOBE HETHERINGTON: 5
14 BILLY WALTERS: 6
15 COREY JENSEN: 6
16 XAVIER WILLISON: 6
17 BRENDAN PIAKURA: 4

I don't know where Badel gets his stats (tackles, for example) but what's cited in this piece doesn't line up with NRL.com. Not the first time I've noticed this.

Sprojy will do these ratings properly later.

 

[BroncsFan]

CM Player Ratings:

1 REECE WALSH: 7
2 SELWYN COBBO: 7
3 KOTONI STAGGS: 8.5
4 GEHAMAT SHIBASAKI: 9
5 JESSE ARTHARS: 7
6 BEN HUNT: 6
7 ADAM REYNOLDS: 6.5
8 PAT CARRIGAN: 7
9 CORY PAIX: 7
10 PAYNE HAAS: 8
11 JACK GOSIEWSKI: 6.5
12 JORDAN RIKI: 8
13 KOBE HETHERINGTON: 5
14 BILLY WALTERS: 6
15 COREY JENSEN: 6
16 XAVIER WILLISON: 6
17 BRENDAN PIAKURA: 4

I don't know where Badel gets his stats (tackles, for example) but what's cited in this piece doesn't line up with NRL.com. Not the first time I've noticed this.

Reynolds 6.5... what fucking game were they watching... or were they just 17 schooners deep at the Caxton.

In what world was Arthars better than Reynolds last night... craziness

 

[Super Freak]

Voting is closed and with a total of 38 votes (90.5%), BHQ's Man of the Match for Round 4 is Gehamat Shibasaki.

Adam Reynolds coming second with 27 votes (64.3%), and Payne Haas coming third with 25 votes (59.5%).

 

[pennywisealfie]

In the BHQ NFL fantasy leagues over the years, most of the league names, division names, championship games and theoretical championship trophies are named after historically bad Broncos players. (for example, Stuart Kelly division and the Mintobowl). One league was called the Shibasaki. Amazing how far he has come.

 

[BroncsFan]

Dally M votes for the game: Gehamat Shibasaki 5, Ben Hunt 3, Adam Reynolds 2, Daniel Saifiti 1, Payne Haas 1.

I love Benny, but I don't know how someone watches that game and has him the best player over any of Shiba, Reynolds, Haas, Staggs, etc. He didn't even register a vote from whoever the other judge was.

I'm guessing the Bhunt voter also put Saifiti in there for 1 vote as well... but also never watched the game.

 

[Sproj]

Dally M votes for the game: Gehamat Shibasaki 5, Ben Hunt 3, Adam Reynolds 2, Daniel Saifiti 1, Payne Haas 1.

I love Benny, but I don't know how someone watches that game and has him the best player over any of Shiba, Reynolds, Haas, Staggs, etc. He didn't even register a vote from whoever the other judge was.

I'm guessing the Bhunt voter also put Saifiti in there for 1 vote as well... but also never watched the game.

How the heck does anyone watch that game and think, hey Saifiti was the best Dolphin out there AND the equivalent of Haas?

Herbie was the best Dolphin by a country mile. This kind of rubbish just continues to make the Dally M award a laughing stock.

 

[McHunt]

How the heck does anyone watch that game and think, hey Saifiti was the best Dolphin out there AND the equivalent of Haas?

Herbie was the best Dolphin by a country mile. This kind of rubbish just continues to make the Dally M award a laughing stock.

Herbie was great for us.

 

[Sproj]

Herbie was great for us.

View attachment 32346

Fair enough and it still would be more fitting too because no Dolphin should have been getting points over Broncs. Hunt even getting 3 points is bit of a joke. He did two dumb kicks that put us under pressure and was lucky not to get penalised for a spear tackle.

 

[McHunt]

Fair enough and it still would be more fitting too because no Dolphin should have been getting points over Broncs. Hunt even getting 3 points is bit of a joke. He did two dumb kicks that put us under pressure and was lucky not to get penalised for a spear tackle.

I probably would not have given Hunt points in that match, but - from memory - he was instrumental in a couple of tries. His short kicking game lacks polish.

 

[Super Freak]

For now I'll stick with the current system.

 

[ningnangnong]

The Greg Eden Player Of The Year