Depends how you look into it.
Madden and Smoothy need another trial to show what they can do, whereas maybe Madge has seen enough from Mozer to give him 1 game straight into Round 1.
I think Paix would probably play if 100% this weekend, but I don't mind it.
I'd still rather these trials being used having players on the fringe a chance to show something rather than playing guaranteed first 17 players.
Yes match fitness is a thing, but if they are fit and firing at training, it'll come in due time. 1 trial against a non NRL standard team isn't going to suddenly make you match fit.