GRAND FINAL WEEK Brisbane Broncos vs Melbourne Storm

Status
Not open for further replies.
Smoothy on the Bench Talty out and Capn Pat in.
So how do we see Smoothy getting in the game? Paix off Hunt to 9 Ezra to 6.
Smoothy comes on for who and when?

Thoughts.
The Qld use of Bhunt used to be start for 30 and then Harry plays out the game, but in the last 15-20 Bhunt would come back on at lock.

I think Madge is probably playing tricks by naming Ezra on the bench, because I can see a late switch to him starting, but it at least puts thoughts into the mind of storm and can get them wasting time on it.

If Bhunt starts at 9 then he plays near 50mins, but they won't want to finish the game with Paix... could be a late move to drop Paix... or Bhunt from the bench and he comes on at 30mins to close out the game.

I daresay Smoothy plays the minutes when Patty is off, so only 10-15mins, but they could also shift him into 9 and Bhunt to lock to close out the game... and he's contingency for Patty, because no one else can really do that role for a large portion of the game.

Smoothy probably has the best pass across our hookers, so he will give them nice clean ball if they want that to close out the game.

Also allows Madge to go balls to the wall if he wants to go all out attack.

1. Walsh
6. Ezra
7. Reynolds
8. Patty
9. Smoothy
10. Haas
13. Bhunt

That's a lot of weapons across the field... it's unfortunate that we haven't had a lot of games with Walsh, Ezra, Bhunt and Reynolds to really smooth out how that can work on the field... but it can be a break glass in case of emergency.
 
On face value I would agree with you...although 11 minutes of game time isn't really valuable use of a middle forward.
Would rather Smoothy for 11 minutes (if that is all he gets) for the sole reason of versatility cover.

It's clear Payne and Patty will be getting 140+ minutes combined.
Yeah 11mins isn't great, but he came halfway through the year so he hasn't had to go through the full preseason. I expect him to have a far bigger role next year given they just gave him a 2yr deal.

I'd probably drop Paix... Smoothy to start at 9, Bhunt onto the field at 30mins and play out the game... Smoothy back on when Patty goes off.

I'd then bring in Jhunt or Gos as backrow cover, because I'd prefer Willison spend his time in middle rather than shifting to the edge when Piaks gets a break.

9. Smoothy

14. Bhunt
15. Kobe
16. Willison
17. Jhunt/Gos

18. Arthars/Cobbo
 
Paix shouldn’t be in there. Mam should be 6, Hunt 9, Smoothy on the bench to cover 9 or lock. Shiba has been shit the last two finals games, so Arthurs should be in instead, with Shiba on the bench in case we lose a back.
 

Two utilities on the bench

Not good, just play Talty
Talty played 11 minutes and did SFA last week .
Smoothy tackled like Macca and acted as a link man . Can play hooker or lock effectively . Has been to a GF before .

Talty has had a great year, and next year he’ll get a real crack but I don’t think he brings what Smoothey can.

Smoothey has been unreal with his versatility

Agreed .
 
Yeah 11mins isn't great, but he came halfway through the year so he hasn't had to go through the full preseason. I expect him to have a far bigger role next year given they just gave him a 2yr deal.

I'd probably drop Paix... Smoothy to start at 9, Bhunt onto the field at 30mins and play out the game... Smoothy back on when Patty goes off.

I'd then bring in Jhunt or Gos as backrow cover, because I'd prefer Willison spend his time in middle rather than shifting to the edge when Piaks gets a break.

9. Smoothy

14. Bhunt
15. Kobe
16. Willison
17. Jhunt/Gos

18. Arthars/Cobbo

I like it.

Arthurs over Cobbo.

Did you see that pony tail Selwyn's rockin?

Jesus.....
lucious lyon wtf GIF
 
I think Talty has hit the wall a little bit; his minutes are coming down, and he just looks like the guy that's waited 26 years for his debut and slowly he's come down from that and is now done for 2025.

It's always a danger with older debutant players.
 
Piaks has been looking like a mad man ready to kill lately. I think Hughes is gonna get a hurt real bad.
I can’t believe he’s lasted this season considering how tough he hits these boys! (Let me not jinx it) but I’m excited to see him go full throttle again!!! One last time!
 
I can’t believe he’s lasted this season considering how tough he hits these boys! (Let me not jinx it) but I’m excited to see him go full throttle again!!! One last time!
Madge is gonna execute the origin order 66 to kill their play makers. Our opening defensive hits have been aggressive and this one will be next level.
 
I noticed last night that Buzz is starting to get the shakes bad too. Surely its time to give it away.

He was twitchy wasn`t he ?
I think part of it was he was furious he was being shown he was wrong - 1st on the Cleary tackle, then the spew buckets .
But then he pulled the crisis manager ace out of his arse .To try to fight back against the bullies . LOL .
 
Talty will replace Kobe next year you'd think unless BTK can stop getting injured.
I just hope Talty has the ability to play some edge... he runs a great line and looks to have nice footwork through the middle, so hopefully it's something he can pick up.

If he can pick that up over the off season then he's my 17 jersey every week that he's fit.
 
Talty will replace Kobe next year you'd think unless BTK can stop getting injured.

Nah ,
Kobe has the footwork to disrupt a defence line and his attack behind the ruck is unique in the squad . He is also a tough defender .
What has Talty done to make you think he can replace that ?
 
I don't think the choice was ever to drop Smoothy. The last spot was between Paix, Talty or a recognised 2nd row option. Picking Paix suggests some apprehension over Mam still

Or Reynolds.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top