Yep its ridiculous that you have umpires deliberately giving both teams different rule interpretations.
But man, that was a great win. We still need to defend better through the middle but I think Cluggs weirdly might help with that and unfortunately, both Reville and Tunstill didn't have great games and given how important they are defensively, this isn't great.
But the big worry is Bailey's hammy, hopefully it was just precautionary. Gardiner's looked far worse but he likely goes out for Zorks anyway.