Greatest Coaches (1908-2013)

Super Freak

Super Freak

International Captain
Forum Staff
Jan 25, 2014
44,120
33,258
1. Wayne Bennett

Coach of the Queensland Team of the Century and the coach with the most wins in premiership history (87 clear of second-placed Tim Sheens at the start of the 2014 season), Wayne Bennett has won seven premierships and coached in eight Grand Finals as well as mentoring the Maroons to five series victories and Australia to a 12-3-1 international record. Making his start in the BRL (winning a title with Brisbane Souths) before joining Canberra as co-coach in 1987 and leading the Raiders to their first Grand Final, he was appointed as the Broncos' inaugural coach in 1988 and stayed with the club for 21 seasons, winning six premierships and taking the Broncos to the finals in his last 17 years. After leaving the Broncos, Bennett spent three years with St George Illawarra, bringing the club its long-awaited first premiership in 2010. He signed with the Knights in 2012, and guided the club to a preliminary final in his second year. Bennett's win percentage of 62.4 ranks fourth among coaches with 100 games, and he ranks second in premierships won as a coach. His foray into rep football was equally successful: he guided Queensland on three separate occasions, winning series during each tenure, and Australia maintained its dominance with him at the helm.

2. Craig Bellamy

Appointed Melbourne coach in 2003 after serving as an assistant to Wayne Bennett at Brisbane, Craig Bellamy built a premiership force that dominated for close to a decade in spite of the League's ongoing and unfettered pursuit of parity. A solid utility player with the Raiders in 149 games from 1989 to 1992, Bellamy found his true calling as a coach. The Storm have won three Grand Finals and played in five deciders in their 11 seasons under Bellamy, and missed the playoffs just once - when the club was tossed out of the 2010 premiership for salary cap breaches. Arguably his finest coaching effort came in that ill-fated season, when he got 14 wins out of a team that had no tangible prize to play for. The Storm won the minor premiership the following season and the NRL title in 2012. Bellamy's 67.6 per cent win rate leads all non-playing coaches with 100-plus games, but perhaps the greatest indicator of his ability is the improvement of players who join the Storm and decline of those who leave. Bellamy's only foray into representative coaching was as NSW coach; he lost three series during Queensland's incredible run through the late 2000's.

3. Jack Gibson

Revered by many as the greatest innovator in the annals of Rugby League coaching, Jack Gibson added professionalism and open thought in his anything-to-win approach to mentoring. Named coach of the Australian Team of the Century, he had seven spells at six clubs, and won five premierships. Gibson started out with Eastern Suburbs in 1967-68, taking a winless wooden spoon team to back-to-back finals before moving to St George and leading the Dragons to Grand Finals in all three grades in 1971. In his one season with Newtown he claimed the Bluebags' only club championship while guiding them to a pre-season cup win and a preliminary final. Gibson rejoined Easts in 1974, and mentored one of the great Rugby League teams to back-to-back premierships in 1974-75. After an unsuccessful stint at South Sydney, he joined Parramatta in 1981 and became the last coach to win three straight premierships - in the process guiding the Eels to their maiden first grade title after 34 years in the League. Gibson moved to the Sharks after the Eels but even he couldn't weave his magic, declaring that waiting for Cronulla to win a premiership was akin to "leaving the porch light on for Harold Holt". His two-season stint as NSW coach (1989-90) saw the Blues reclaim the shield in the latter years after three straight series losses.

4. Bob Fulton

A Manly legend on the field who was anointed one of Rugby League's inaugural Immortals, Bob Fulton also left his mark as one of the top coaches on the premiership and international scenes. He was appointed captain-coach of Eastern Suburbs in 1979 but a knee injury forced his playing retirement midway through the season; he remained the Roosters' coach, leading them to consecutive minor premierships and the 1980 Grand Final. Fulton returned to Manly in 1983 for the first of two spells as Sea Eagles boss. The club went to the Grand Final in his first year and broke through for a premiership triumph in 1987. Fulton stepped aside after the 1988 season to take up the Australian coaching job, a position he held for seven seasons and two World Cup victories, building a 30-6-1 record. He returned to Manly in 1993 and led the Sea Eagles to three straight deciders (1995-97), winning in 1996 before quitting in the wake of a slow start to the 1999 season. Fulton's 64.4 per cent strike rate ranks second among coaches with 200-plus games, and he is the only coach to win two premierships and two World Cups as both a player and a coach.

5. Phil Gould

A controversial and outspoken figure, Phil Gould won a premiership in his first season as a premiership head coach and soon became respected as NSW's greatest State of Origin mentor. A skilled but unspectacular player with Penrith, Newtown, Canterbury and South Sydney, in 1988 Gould replaced Warren Ryan as Bulldogs coach at just 30 years of age and guided the club to an unlikely premiership. Falling out with the club patriarch Peter Moore the year after, Gould moved to Penrith and in his first year took the perennially battling club to a maiden Grand Final; his skilled mentorship and unparalleled motivational speeches then helped the club to its first premiership in 1991. The sad death of Ben Alexander tore the Panthers apart soon after, and Gould left for the Sydney City Roosters, where he reached four finals series - including two preliminary finals - in his five-year stint. It is in the Origin arena, though, that Gould is most renowed: the NSW coach for eight series (1992-96, 2002-04) guided the Blues to six series wins. His only losing Origin series was the infamous 1995 triumph of Paul Vautin's Queensland battlers. A master psychologist and motivator, Gould took his talents to the Nine commentary team upon retirement, also helping to rebuild Penrith as general manager from 2011 onwards.

6. Arthur 'Pony' Halloway

A coaching giant during Rugby League's first four decades, Arthur Halloway made his mark as captain-coach of Balmain during the clubs' glory period, spanning World War I, and was non-playing coach of four other clubs from 1923 to 1948. A champion halfback with Glebe, Balmain and Eastern Suburbs from the game's first season through to 1920, Halloway captain-coached the 'Watersiders' of Balmain to four premierships in five seasons (1916-17 and 1919-20) before retiring. His first foray into non-playing coaching was a failure, with Newtown struggling in 1923, but four spells with Eastern Suburbs in the 1930s and '40s were a triumph. He led the great Easts teams of 1935-37 to three straight titles as well as a host of records that stand to this day. Halloway left for a disappointing stint with Norths, but returned to the Tricolours in 1945 and steered Easts to another title. His eight premierships as a coach remains a record, while his combined 12 titles as a player and a coach is yet to be neared.

7. Charlie Lynch

One of the great pre-war coaches, Charlie Lynch etched himself into South Sydney folklore with four premierships in his first five seasons at the helm of the Bunnies. A student of the great Ash Hennessy, Lynch was a master attacking technician who brought the most out of a magnificent Rabbitohs outfit that included Benny Wearing, George Treweek, Eddie Root and Frank O'Connor. He joined Souths in 1928, and mentored the club until 1934, and again between 1937 and 1940. During his time Souths won four premierships and finished worse than fourth just twice. Lynch made a shock return with St George in 1947, but had little success.

8. Warren Ryan

A pricky figure who often clashed with the front office and star players of the clubs he worked for, Warren Ryan was the coach of the 1980s and brought success to every team he mentored. An honest but limited lock forward during his playing career, he was one of the game's great thinkers and forged a coaching career that spanned 21 seasons and five clubs. Ryan got his start in 1979 with a Newtown team that had won three straight wooden spoons - and within three years the Jets were in the Grand Final. He moved to Canterbury in 1984 and, on the back of a gritty, defensive style known as 'Wazza Ball', helped the Bulldogs to three straight Grand Finals and titles in 1984 and '85. Internal dramas saw him leave for Balmain in 1988, and he presided over two heartbreaking Grand Final losses in his first two years at the Tigers. Throughout the decade, Ryan's teams played in six of the 10 deciders. A shift to Wests in 1991 saw back-to-back finals appearances for the first time in 12 years. He retired after quitting the Magpies in 1994 but made a shock comeback in 1999 with Newcastle, leading the Knights to consecutive finals series. Ryan sits fourth in games coached and sixth in total wins.

9. Ken Kearney

One of the key drivers behind St George's incredible run of 11 straight premierships, Ken Kearney was short in stature but a giant of the game during the 1950s and early '60s. A former Rugby Union international, Kearney returned to Australia after a spell with Leeds in Britain and brought with him a professionalism in training and preparation that the Australian game had never seen. In his third year with the club he was appointed captain-coach, leading the team to back-to-back prelims. Persistent troubles with referees saw him relegated in 1956, but he was reappointed captain-coach in 1957 and led the Saints to six straight premierships. St George's policy of only having captain-coaches saw Kearney move on to Parramatta in 1962, where he took the club to its first three finals series in his three years after it had won eight of the last nine wooden spoons. Disappointing results at Wests and Cronulla took little away from Kearney's coaching legacy.

10. Chris Anderson

One of Rugby League's most underrated coaches, Chris Anderson is among Australia's most successful national bosses and one of the few mentors to win premierships at two separate clubs. A Canterbury great as a player, he got his start in coaching in 1986-87, leading Halifax to an unlikely Challenge Cup win as captain-coach. Anderson returned to Australia in 1990 to take the reins at Canterbury, and after a rebuild led the Bulldogs to back-to-back minor premierships in 1993-94. He was instrumental in keeping together a team that was being torn asunder by the Super League War in 1995, giving the Bulldogs the self-belief to win their first title in seven years from sixth place. After two disappointing seasons, he announced he was quitting to become Melbourne's inaugural coach. Thanks primarily to Anderson, the Storm were an immediate on-field success, running third in their debut season before winning the title in just their second year. He took over the Australian job in 1999 and built a 21-3 record that included victory in the 2000 World Cup. A spell at Cronulla ended after two years and an ill-advised comeback at the Roosters didn't last a season.
 
I thought I would add a little more.

Greatest coaching achievements

1. Paul Vautin - The upset of all upsets


Nobody gave Queensland a chance of winning the 1995 State of Origin series. With Super League-aligned players barred from participation, the Maroons had 15 of their squad that had lost the 1994 series unavailable, as well as a new coach who hadn't mentored a single team. Paul Vautin brought a team of youngsters, journeymen and cast-offs together to smoke a star-studded NSW team 3-0 in a boilover that has gone down in Origin folklore.

2. Craig Bellamy - Melbourne thrives playing for nothing

Most teams told they would not be playing for competition points would have folded - but not Craig Bellamy's Melbourne Storm, who in 2010 won an incredible 10 of their last 18 games knowing they would recieve nothing for the victories as punishment for severe breaches of the salary cap. The culture Bellamy created at Melbourne would not allow the Storm to throw in the towel despite a lack of tangible rewards.

3. Chris Anderson - Divided, not conquered

Chris Anderson's ability to bring the 1995 Bulldogs team together not only to make the finals but to win the premiership still sends tingles down the spines of the Canterbury faithful. The Bulldogs were stuck mid-table when four of their biggest stars took the club to court in an effort to break their Super League deals and sign with Parramatta. Canterbury was torn apart, but Anderson, a renowned players' coach, bonded the team together and the Bulldogs limped into the finals before embarking on a memorable month of upsets, with defector Jim Dymock winning the Clive Churchill Medal in his final game for the club.

4. Leo Nosworthy - Giant killer

The architect behind the greatest upset in Grand Final history, Leo Nosworthy holds a special place in the hearts of the Balmain faithful. In his first season as a head coach, the former Tigers centre moulded an unfashionable side into one of the great fairytales. Balmain's 11-2 win in the 1969 Grand Final over Souths, where Tigers players continually feigned injury, is still regarded as the greatest Grand Final upset of all time. On the siren, Tigers players chaired their coach around the ground, such was the respect they had for his role in their achievement.

5. Wayne Bennett - A finals regular

No coach has had more success in the history of the premiership than Wayne Bennett, and his incredible run of consecutive finals appearances is testament to his brilliance. From Brisbane's finals appearance in 1992 through to his last season with St George Illawarra in 2011, Bennett's teams made the playoffs for 20 straight seasons.

6. Jack Gibson - Newtown's only club championship

In Newtown's 76-year existence in the premiership, the club won just a single club championship. That came in 1973 - Jack Gibson's only season in charge. The Bluebags finished fourth in first grade after making the finals just once in the previous 10 years, and a loss to Cronulla in the preliminary final could not sour one of their finest seasons.

7. Craig Bellamy - The Baby Broncos

Craig Bellamy has enjoyed more victories than most coaches in premiership history, but his most unlikely win was surely with the fabled 'Baby Broncos'. Missing 13 starters, predominantly to Origin selection, Broncos assistant Bellamy managed to get his troops to rally under the leadership of Shane Walker to win 28-14 at Campbelltown over the West Tigers.

8. Ken Kearney - Rise of the Eels

Ken Kearney set in motion St George's incredible run of 11 straight premierships as captain-coach, but his ability to drag Parramatta from wooden spooners to contenders is arguably more impressive. The Eels had won 10 wooden spoons - including the six prior to Kearney joining - in their 15-year existence before 'Killer', with minimal recruitment, took them to three straight finals series in his three years in charge.

9. Mal Meninga - Awesome Origin

Before Queensland's incredible run of eight straight Origin series wins, neither the Blues nor the Maroons had won more than three straight series. From 2006 until 2013 Queensland won every series - a generation in football and a lifetime in Origin. Mal Meninga's achievement in the interstate arena is unlikely to ever be matched.

10. Jack Gibson - Hat-trick

The last man to coach three consecutive premierships, Jack Gibson's achievement gets more remarkable with each passing year. Only two coaches - Warren Ryan and Wayne Bennett - have coached back-to-back premierships following Gibson's effort, and no mentor has done it since 1993, two full decades ago.
 
Nice posts, I'd agree with pretty much everything, though I'd put Mal Meningas Origin coaching a bit higher. Sure he had the team of a lifetime, but so often in origin we've seen big name players not show up, and he got them all firing on all cylinders more often than not.
 
How does Bob Bax not make these lists?

Brothers' Premierships in '56 and '59.
Norths' Premierships in '61, '62, '63, '64, '66 and '69.

Queensland Coach '71-'73.

Instrumental in the setting up of the Broncos too.
 
Because the BRL doesn't matter.

At least, that's the narrative the NRL has been rolling with for decades.
 
Yeah, I don't like the fact that they don't include anything to do with BRL. Unfortunately, that's just the way it is.

If it ain't NRL, it means jack shit.

I can't see it ever changing.
 

Unread

Active Now

  • Gaz
  • Justwin
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.