THE COACH Poll: Should Kevin Walters be sacked?

Should the Broncos replace the coach?

  • Yes

  • No

  • Undecided

Results are only viewable after voting.
Big Pete said:
The issue is they develop a lot of marquee talent.

Just about every player you've named is a rep. player who eat up a huge chunk of the salary cap.

For a development club, they don't develop enough solid first graders to help balance the cap so they're either getting fleeced by managers to pay top dollar or they're letting those players walk out the door.

If you look at Penrith, they lose a lot of marquee players but they can easily plug and play somebody else. The Broncos don't have that luxury and they're relying too heavily on their affiliates to bail them out.
Click to expand...
Very interesting concept. How do you develop talent and predict it will be mediocre enough to not demand a competitive contract?

A lot of broncos players are actually just solid first graders but get hyped so much that Tesi Niu is seen as the next Lockyer. Jarred Wallace’s want a pay bump, Fleglers become marque signings. Staggs get 800k a year offers.

Who are some of examples at other clubs to help me understand? Mark Nichols?
 
theshed said:
Very interesting concept. How do you develop talent and predict it will be mediocre to not demand a competitive contract?

A lot of broncos players are actually just solid first graders but get hyped so much that Tesi Niu is seen as the next Lockyer. Jarred Wallace’s want a pay bump, Fleglers become marque signings. Staggs get 800k a year offers.

Who are some of examples at other clubs to help me understand? Mark Nichols?
Click to expand...
You don't, you develop a squad of players from U/17s - U/21s so when one player goes it isn't the end of the world.

Liam Henry was the example I used. The Panthers have lost Spencer Leniu, J'maine Hopgood, Hohepa Puru, Eddie Blacker, Ativalu Lisati, Ryley Smith, Mason Teague etc. etc. and it's not the end of the world for their forward pack because they had somebody else to call on.

Crichton gets offered captaincy to leave, the Panthers roll on. Staggs gets offered 800,000K and Brisbane start justifying the price tag.
 
Big Pete said:
You don't, you develop a squad of players from U/17s - U/21s so when one player goes it isn't the end of the world.

Liam Henry was the example I used. The Panthers have lost Spencer Leniu, J'maine Hopgood, Hohepa Puru, Eddie Blacker, Ativalu Lisati, Ryley Smith, Mason Teague etc. etc. and it's not the end of the world for their forward pack because they had somebody else to call on.

Crichton gets offered captaincy to leave, the Panthers roll on. Staggs gets offered 800,000K and Brisbane start justifying the price tag.
Click to expand...
Would you say part of the challenge for us is the Q Cup system rather than a specific streamlined broncos pathway?
 
Broncapz said:
Kevies press conference was not a great start - "It's not happening for us at the moment.. and yeah it's dissapointing but what do you do?"

My confidence in the team is leaving me faster than a space travelling flat earther.
Click to expand...
lol what exactly do you want him to say?
 
Its an issue i've always had, we dont sign enough hard working, low maintenance players, and i think we panic and sign young guys who have proved nothing on big contracts because we are scared of losing them. Our squad balance is wrong.
 
Wolfie said:
Its an issue i've always had, we dont sign enough hard working, low maintenance players, and i think we panic and sign young guys who have proved nothing on big contracts because we are scared of losing them. Our squad balance is wrong.
Click to expand...
Yea kind of like jensen, smoothy, arthars etc. Nobody can seem to answer me whe
i say, what players that were available last season should we have signed?

I mean, we could have let haas go and keep flelger and maybe palasia? That's a $300k player and an $800k player which makes up Paynes salary. Or maybe we could have let payne and flegler go and kept herbie, capewell and palasia?

Either way i don't think it stops Cobbo dropping 4 balls last night.. the biggest issue i see out there is with our handling and our halves. Many handling.

We have the cattle to do it. They just need to catch the ball
 
Wolfie said:
Its an issue i've always had, we dont sign enough hard working, low maintenance players, and i think we panic and sign young guys who have proved nothing on big contracts because we are scared of losing them. Our squad balance is wrong.
Click to expand...

It’s very top heavy and it’s only going to get worse once the Walsh contract is locked in.
 
Manofoneway said:
Yea kind of like jensen, smoothy, arthars etc. Nobody can seem to answer me whe
i say, what players that were available last season should we have signed?

I mean, we could have let haas go and keep flelger and maybe palasia? That's a $300k player and an $800k player which makes up Paynes salary. Or maybe we could have let payne and flegler go and kept herbie, capewell and palasia?

Either way i don't think it stops Cobbo dropping 4 balls last night.. the biggest issue i see out there is with our handling and our halves. Many handling.

We have the cattle to do it. They just need to catch the ball
Click to expand...

Are you talking about players we could have signed for 2024? Thing is though, we dont have to limit ourselves to off contract players. There are always deals to be done both here and from Superleague.

I do think letting Payne walk and investing in his salary would be a smart idea even if it means us losing a top level prop.
 
Wolfie said:
Are you talking about players we could have signed for 2024? Thing is though, we dont have to limit ourselves to off contract players. There are always deals to be done both here and from Superleague.

I do think letting Payne walk and investing in his salary would be a smart idea even if it means us losing a top level prop.
Click to expand...
OK so who do you buy and who do you let go? I guarantee it won't stop the likes of cobbo dropping the ball 4 times last night
 
Manofoneway said:
OK so who do you buy and who do you let go? I guarantee it won't stop the likes of cobbo dropping the ball 4 times last night
Click to expand...

You are too fixated on what went wrong last night. It was an extremely bad night at the office, but there is more to our recent poor form than just players dropping the ball.

I'm sure if i thought about it i could rattle off names of players who we could go and get and who we could let go but until you make the deals you dont know if they are realistic. Our problem is currently any room we have in the cap is earmarked for the Reece Walsh upgrade. Add to that in 2025 we have Willison, Cobbo, Hetherington, Staggs, Smoothy and Jensen, as well as youngsters like Leota and Mozer off contract, as well as possibly replacing Reynolds, our management have a lot of cap juggling to work out.
 
Wolfie said:
You are too fixated on what went wrong last night. It was an extremely bad night at the office, but there is more to our recent poor form than just players dropping the ball.

I'm sure if i thought about it i could rattle off names of players who we could go and get and who we could let go but until you make the deals you dont know if they are realistic. Our problem is currently any room we have in the cap is earmarked for the Reece Walsh upgrade. Add to that in 2025 we have Willison, Cobbo, Hetherington, Staggs, Smoothy and Jensen, as well as youngsters like Leota and Mozer off contract, as well as possibly replacing Reynolds, our management have a lot of cap juggling to work out.
Click to expand...
It's very easy to throw out statements like "we have recruited poorly" and "our cap is out if balance". Why don't you substantiate it by saying who we should have signed that was off contract and who we should have let go.
 
We would have the likes of
Marty,
Oates,
Pereria,
Hoeter &
Paix(?) all moved on so, 5 top 30 spots to be filled in.

We can also look at a possible scenario where the likes of
Baker,
Hunt &
Goski could well be shown the door by end of 25.

All in all, we will have 5 vacant spots at the start of 25 & 3 more towards the end of 25.

I’m sure R&R team are well aware of all this and working real hard in the background to bring in some hardworking workaholics.
 
New Posts

Unread

Watch

YouTube
0 0 711
1:34:00
NRL Semi Final, 2001 - Brisbane Broncos vs St George Illawarra Dragons
View full media list »

Active Now

  • Jedhead
  • Fitzy
  • Harry Sack
  • Santa
  • bb_gun
  • Skyblues87
  • Bucking Beads
  • scobie
  • Xzei
  • Dexter
  • broncsgoat
  • broncoscope
  • sooticus
Total: 149 (members: 20, guests: 129)
Robots: 387
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.