- Jul 28, 2016
- 35,418
- 51,858
Hypothetical question with Reyno and Mam going down, but mostly Reyno.
If we had Duffy here this year would you prefer / be more confident in him or Madden with us trying to make finals?
It's an interesting question because the reaction to his signing has been mixed, but we are effectively replacing Madden with him... we could end up in the same situation next year with Reyno and Bhunt ageing
I haven't really seen enough of Duffy, but he seems to be a genuine halfback, whereas Madden looked like someone we were trying to develop into a halfback.
I'm guessing Madden will be playing 6 with Bhunt at 7 for the next 4 weeks, but I'm just not sure where the points are going to come from across those two... unless Bhunt is given a license... which means it will fall on Walsh.
Duffy from his Qcup highlights at least appears to have an elite short kicking game, similar to Sam Walker... so he would potentially be able to contribute and ease some pressure on Walsh
If we had Duffy here this year would you prefer / be more confident in him or Madden with us trying to make finals?
It's an interesting question because the reaction to his signing has been mixed, but we are effectively replacing Madden with him... we could end up in the same situation next year with Reyno and Bhunt ageing
I haven't really seen enough of Duffy, but he seems to be a genuine halfback, whereas Madden looked like someone we were trying to develop into a halfback.
I'm guessing Madden will be playing 6 with Bhunt at 7 for the next 4 weeks, but I'm just not sure where the points are going to come from across those two... unless Bhunt is given a license... which means it will fall on Walsh.
Duffy from his Qcup highlights at least appears to have an elite short kicking game, similar to Sam Walker... so he would potentially be able to contribute and ease some pressure on Walsh