CROSS FORUM NRL 2023 Round 18 Discussion

[jonesy101]

You warriors fans still think you’re hard done by? Curren gets two weeks for punching a minor and Walsh got three weeks for swearing near a ref!

We won't feel hard done by the day they let us host magic round in Invercargill.

 

[Mustafur]

Well the Mark Hughes foundation would have been very happy with this round.

1k for every try. 72 tries all up.

Don't know why the Dogs fans were booing their team, they were doing their part.

 

[Worried2Death]

And as far as we know no swearing was reported in the vicinity, a discount for that

He's a good boy. Thank God he didn't call Dave Fifita as his star witness, he'd be doing a ten year stretch.

 

[Sproj]

He's a good boy. Thank God he didn't call Dave Fifita as his star witness, he'd be doing a ten year stretch.

Fifita: Yeah when he belted that obviously a kid kid, I mean man not kid and he didn’t belt him, just gave a really hard slap, I mean soft movement of arm in that direction. I mean allegedly but I didn’t see it.

 

[bruce]

You warriors fans still think you’re hard done by? Curren gets two weeks for punching a minor and Walsh got three weeks for swearing near a ref!

The kid asked for it and we don't care about Walsh. Have a good day. :D

 

[Juju]

Some seriously deep statistical analysis of where clubs are at & a break down of the Bunnies impressive victory

https://www.rugbyleagueeyetest.com/...-most-impressive-part-of-the-bunnies-victory/

 

[wizards rage]

You warriors fans still think you’re hard done by? Curren gets two weeks for punching a minor and Walsh got three weeks for swearing near a ref!

How does 4 weeks for Montoya calling another player a f@ggot - with discounting for early guilty plea and remorse, compare to Walsh getting 3 weeks for abusing the ref despite lack of guilt or remorse?

The Warriors penalty is still harder than the Broncos penalty

 

[Cult]

How does 4 weeks for Montoya calling another player a f@ggot - with discounting for early guilty plea and remorse, compare to Walsh getting 3 weeks for abusing the ref despite lack of guilt or remorse?

The Warriors penalty is still harder than the Broncos penalty

Lack of proof of guilt too, don't forget that.

 

[ivanhungryjak]

How does 4 weeks for Montoya calling another player a f@ggot - with discounting for early guilty plea and remorse, compare to Walsh getting 3 weeks for abusing the ref despite lack of guilt or remorse?

The Warriors penalty is still harder than the Broncos penalty

Come on Wiz, it’s 2023, we don’t need to explain that one, do we?

 

[Worried2Death]

Come on Wiz, it’s 2023, we don’t need to explain that one, do we?

Wiz is a disgrace to the transgender electricians community, always getting they/their wires crossed smh.

 

[Mustafur]

How does 4 weeks for Montoya calling another player a f@ggot - with discounting for early guilty plea and remorse, compare to Walsh getting 3 weeks for abusing the ref despite lack of guilt or remorse?

The Warriors penalty is still harder than the Broncos penalty

They could actually prove that Montoya said it at a player, they just Assumed with Walsh and the Panel couldn't even come to a decision, it required the chairman to make him Guilty which he then proceeds with nearly the max penalty.

Kangaroo Court at it's finest.

 

[Worried2Death]

They could actually prove that Montoya said it at a player, they just Assumed with Walsh and the Panel couldn't even come to a decision, it required the chairman to make hik Guilty which he then proceeds with nearly the max penalty.

I think we all agree 3 weeks was excessive given the doubt, pretty riduliculous penalty for speaking the Australian language.

 

[StuBoot]

I think we all agree 3 weeks was excessive given the doubt, pretty riduliculous penalty for speaking the Australian language.

Okay, so change it around a bit.

He said he called Carrigan a c@nt not the ref.
So Montoya gets 4 for calling a player a derogatory name but Walsh gets 3 because it's directed at the ref.

Both words can be interpreted as an insult but one is deemed more powerful by itself (Montoya's) whereas the other is generally preceded by another descriptive term ( Walsh's).
Said adjective is generally what makes it more direct and offensive.

Walsh got lucky in a way that he just used the simple version, but that also went against him too because there was no specific indicator of who it was directed at plus most teammates wouldn't use that word to each other in a game, might call an opponent one but not a teammate.

 

[Mustafur]

Okay, so change it around a bit.

He said he called Carrigan a c@nt not the ref.
So Montoya gets 4 for calling a player a derogatory name but Walsh gets 3 because it's directed at the ref.

Both words can be interpreted as an insult but one is deemed more powerful by itself (Montoya's) whereas the other is generally preceded by another descriptive term ( Walsh's).
Said adjective is generally what makes it more direct and offensive.

Walsh got lucky in a way that he just used the simple version, but that also went against him too because there was no specific indicator of who it was directed at plus most teammates wouldn't use that word to each other in a game, might call an opponent one but not a teammate.

One is a homophobic slur and the other isn't.

Unless you think calling someone the N word is the same as calling them a C?

Ofcourse imo Montoya probably just said the first thing out of his mouth to insult the guy and just happened to choose wrongly, it wasn't that long ago people said it and no one batted an eye but times have changed.

I don't think Footy players are above not calling their own team mates c*nts, I do that with my mates all the time it's not even an insult, only in the way you frame the sentence you use it in.

 

[Stalefish540]

Let's all just come together, forum with forum and agree Curran and Montoya were hard done by. Whilst Walsh on the other hand should be walking the green mile.

 

[Galah]

Let's all just come together, forum with forum and agree Curran and Montoya were hard done by. Whilst Walsh on the other hand should be walking the green mile.

 

[Ref]

OMG there was some absolutely poor, non committed tackle attempts by certain St George, Canterbury and Wests Tigers players.
On my day the points table never mattered.
You just left it all out there game to game.
Their respective seasons are over so they might as well give the whole squad and the Dev players a run.

 

[jonesy101]

Is this some sort of reference to Reece Walsh and his 30 seconds of fast brain?