-NEWS- Anthony Seibold: entire Broncos club needs a review

Renegade

NRL Captain
4,341
3,610
Honestly, I'd be ok with giving him a performance review and telling him we're parting ways.

That was one of the worst showings I've ever seen by a Broncos team, in a finals game no less. Seibold has shown he is unable to make the big calls and there has not been one ounce of improvement from the team this year. What would a review show? All the things he did this year sucked? He was unable to make the tough calls when he needed to?

There are a few on here that are relying on faith that next year we will come good and it will all be worth it. On what basis? There isn't any.
 

Dazza 92

NRL Player
1,241
776
i didn't read any of the content of the original post...the headlines were enough...

I posted recently the idea of a Director of Football (or Technical Director...take your pick) for the Broncos. Should probably make it a thread in and off itself cause i believe its worthy of debate.

I'm not sure if Siebs had his hands tied behind his back due to decisions made before he arrived and whether a internal edict said he cannot bench a number of players who were resigned by the club in 2017 and want to see some return on the investments made...

But listen, Siebs maybe a relative rookie as a head coach but he ISNT a idiot...

If he relys so much on analytics like he says he does it would be extremely obvious to pinpoint the weaknesses in this squad. So again i ask you to think about the above statement...

Cause if the above is true, and Siebs is after all a employee of the club...and he has been told to "make it work"....can anyone be surprised by the results..?

I defy any current coach in the NRL to make "that" spine work...? You cant, its irrevocably broken, the team knows it and our opposition knows it. Dearden cant be the answer to it either cause he is YOUNGER than our 2 best players who are both 19. And how did that experiment end up relying on 2 19 year olds..?
 

rnabokov

State of Origin Rep
6,358
3,416
Bangalow
As I said elsewhere, the only way I can make sense of this disappointing season, and yesterdays loss is that Seibold gave every player, particularly the seniors, a chance to prove they are worthy of the club. We know the result of that, and that has to be shown in the roster for next season.

As well, given Seibold's comments about reviewing the entire club, maybe there is more to the rubbish than just him and the on-field performances. In any case, next season's roster will tell all
 
Last edited:

PerthBrissy987

NRL Player
2,495
929
We missed Bellamy because he didn’t want to sit out a year.
We still end up signing Siebs then sack Bennett.
Tell me why we couldn’t just sack Wayne and sign Bellamy for this year
 

Financeguy

QCup Player
We missed Bellamy because he didn’t want to sit out a year.
We still end up signing Siebs then sack Bennett.
Tell me why we couldn’t just sack Wayne and sign Bellamy for this year
I don't think it was just because Bellamy didn't want to sit out a year, at the end of the day Bellamy didn't want to leave Melbourne.

Not saying the whole thing couldn't have been handled better but i think Bellamy simply picked Melbourne over us, regardless of what year he started.
 

Kimlo

International Captain
Staff
23,876
10,143
Brisbane
All bullshit talk.

You don't need an end of season review to conclude Boyd is cooked and is not a 5/8, Turpin is not a halfback, Macca shouldn't be our first choice 9, Shiba shouldn't be making our bench and I could go on.

If you don't know this shit instinctively then how are you coaching first grade. Honestly, this is fucking empty talk.

It's all absolute bullshit until round 1 next year when we see what team he names. Picking Turpin over SOS showed his cards last week. Moving Milford to fullback to accommodate Boyd showed he doesn't have the guts to make the big calls.

None of that matters now anyway, it's not like we're beyond fixing, surely someone like Lockyer could see t his shit unless he's as dumb as Seibold which wouldn't surprise me. Plenty of excellent footy players have no idea how to coach or make the tough decisions.

He has until halfway of next year, if we're still rolling out a dud team with players all over the 17 in the wrong positions and paper thing defence he's not going to survive the season.

Also - **** off Ben Cross. Why is that useless **** an assistant coach at our great club? Really, Ben Cross?? No wonder the players don't give a ****, is there a single person in that coaching staff who would have the respect of a Broncos fan?

Bring in Justin Hodges, I bet he wouldn't be afraid to call out the players for playing like shit.
 

Fernando

NRL Player
1,541
998
Bris
Hopefully they review the senior players, and why Seibold kept selecting them. This season could’ve been spent getting the pieces together to set the side up moving forward. It likely would’ve meant making an already young roster younger and missing the finals. But imo that’s better than we what we ended up with, with Seibold picking a shambles of a spine because of their “winning record” so they could limp into the finals only to be humiliated.
 

theshed

NRL Captain
3,146
3,957
Luke Keary
Josh Hodgeson
Cam Munster
Adam Reynolds
Mitch Moses
DCE
Luke Brooks
Nathan Cleary
Mitch Pearce
Kieran Foran
Blake Green
Michael Morgan
Gareth Widdop
**** Chad Townsend

**** Boyd and Macca off and I don’t know how but sign one of these players.
 

pagey

NRL Captain
4,539
1,928
Luke Keary
Josh Hodgeson
Cam Munster
Adam Reynolds
Mitch Moses
DCE
Luke Brooks
Nathan Cleary
Mitch Pearce
Kieran Foran
Blake Green
Michael Morgan
Gareth Widdop
**** Chad Townsend

**** Boyd and Macca off and I don’t know how but sign one of these players.
Throw in Oates and milf aswell
 

Broncapz

QCup Player
782
1,255
Seriously. Watch the game with 21:30 in the first half or something to go. Where Boyd has the ball bounce of his BACK!! Like already thats pretty stupid. Then he's walking while players are running past him to defend. That was the try that killed our spirit.

That little play is the end of Boyd for me.
 
Last edited:

john1420

NRL Player
We missed Bellamy because he didn’t want to sit out a year.
We still end up signing Siebs then sack Bennett.
Tell me why we couldn’t just sack Wayne and sign Bellamy for this year
We missed Bellymyth because he didn't want to coach a team without Cam Smith and be proven to be just a normal average coach

And I'm glad of it, I don't want that shit stain cancerous prick anywhere near the club I love
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create free account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Login or Register

Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Register now

Forum statistics

Threads
17,030
Messages
960,185
Members
2,285
Latest member
will.ipu

Members online

Twitter

Top