VOTE Does it matter to you where a coach is from?

[Renegade]

Pure and simple - does it matter to you?

Personally I think it's a bunch of shit, I think the idea is outdated nonsense that means absolutely nothing.

Your thoughts?

 

[ChewThePhatt]

Just win for **** sake

 

[Foordy]

I couldn't give two shits if our coach is from QLD, NSW or Mars.

I also couldn't give two shits if our coach has previously coached the NSW State of Origin side.

The only thing I care about is them being the best coach for our squad

 

[Big Pete]

It depends on the context.

For instance when it came down to Paul Green and Kevin Walters, I always thought Kevie was the better option since he'd be given more leeway by the fans and the media since he was a club legend and you could trust him to put the interests of the club before anything else.

The only thing that counts against Madge in this instance is the way the Blues went after Walsh in the Origin series. It was pretty scum Cobra Kai esque coaching and something he ought to address.

 

[Mr Fourex]

QLD's premier NRL club is coached by the NSW state of origin coach.

Pass.

 

[Bucking Beads]

It doesn't matter where the coach comes from. We'd take Bellamy with open arms and he is a former NSW coach. We just want the best. We want the right guy. I hope that is Maguire but I have grave fears we will be back to square 1 in a few years.

 

[Renegade]

QLD's premier NRL club is coached by the NSW state of origin coach.

Pass.

so in theory, you would prefer to not make the finals with a qld coach over making the finals or winning a premiership with a nsw coach?

 

[Super Freak]

Not even a little bit.

 

[Mr Fourex]

so in theory, you would prefer to not make the finals with a qld coach over making the finals or winning a premiership with a nsw coach?

We're not talking about "a" NSW coach. We're talking about "the" NSW coach.

If he wasn't the NSW coach....I'd care a whole lot less.

 

[Broncosgirl]

Madge is a grub, so no, I don't want him anywhere near the Broncos. When he is desperate for the win .. is he going to coach and instruct our team to play like dirty scum dogs, and take out the opposition's best player .. like he did to Walshy?

Will Madge give a genuine apology to Walsh? I don't think he will .. too busy revelling in his victory.

Madge is a dog.

 

[bert_lifts]

The only thing that counts against Madge in this instance is the way the Blues went after Walsh in the Origin series. It was pretty scum Cobra Kai esque coaching and something he ought to address.

Was no different to the previous year. They went after him then too. Suali'i is just a mongoloid and got it wrong.

is he going to coach our team to play like dirty scum dogs, and take out the opposition's best player ..

Well yeah if you want to win you need to abuse the rules like scum/penref do. Unfortunately you can't win anymore by playing fair. Today's game is all about how you can manipulate the ref, milk penalties and bend the rules.

 

[MrTickyMcG]

Well yeah if you want to win you need to abuse the rules like scum/penref do. We play fair way too much. Unfortunately you can't win anymore by playing fair. Today's game is all about how you can manipulate the ref end bend the rules.

I'm also sick of Broncos coaches/management toeing the line with refs. I want our team to push the limits and I want our coaches and admin to call out the refs and NRL admin when necessary.

 

[Midean]

Yep. 100% matters to me.
Loyalty, honor, and comradery all stem from this mindset.

Im not a mercenary, win at all costs type.
I'd rather get the spoon as a united QLD outfit than win the premiership under the rule of the enemy.
But each to their own.

Seems im an old boy at heart.