The romantically delusional answer is "both."
The brutal, more realistic, answer is "neither."
We've seen both choke grand finals in our jersey, and Adam choke grand finals in different jerseys outplayed by the same opposite number. They're both match winners on their day. But a whole season? I don't know anymore.
Since leaving the Broncos, Hunt has been terrific off the bench (usually) in rep games, but his history at the Dragons is largely forgettable. Would he put in a full season at 7 that would win us that elusive premiership? There's not much evidence of it at club level. And then we have to rebuild. Again.
I would love Reyno to rekindle his youth, and take us one further than 2023, but I'm afraid I've become pessimistic about that. I saw little in 2024 to suggest we can get another full season out him. Not at premiership winning level. His kicking game seems to have gone to shit, and he should never be allowed to take a short kick-off ever again. I can't tell whether he has support of the team, but there has to be a question-mark over that given the series of events that led us to a new coach. Something happened that involved him. I don't know if we'll ever find that out.
So TL;DR: my hard answer is neither. I would rather build the next generation. That would be a spine of Mozer, Black, Mam and Walsh, as soon as Black is deemed "ready enough." Hopefully, sooner than later this season. I would like to see Reynolds transition out of the team over the course of the season, perhaps even coming off the bench rather than a hooker.