Luke Patten

Discussion in 'State of Origin 2015' started by uptheguts, Mar 29, 2015.

  1. CaptainHook

    CaptainHook NRL Player

    2,843
    1,157
    Excellent points, Organix. Origin 2 last year was the worst I've ever seen. It wasn't because the Maroons lost and the streak ended - let's be honest it was bound to happen sooner or later. It was because there was sooo much grubby stuff and foul play in it and the match officials were seemingly oblivious to it. I think it was Phil Gould who said the comment 'hopefully a game of rugby league breaks out soon.'

    Truly disgraceful. If this series is a repeat - and I have a strong feeling it might - then I'm going to lose interest in it fast. I suspect the Blues know they can't win in a fair contest and they are counting on the referees to put the whistle away. With no Gallen or Bird surely it must be a cleaner contest by default, right?
     
  2. 1910

    1910 State of Origin Rep

    6,811
    3,378
    You do have to be a qualified referee in the video box- there is two of them not just Patten. Patten was also the video ref in game three last year- Queensland won.

    In fact he was video ref with Clarke and Sutton in all three games.
     
  3. They also had two tries denied.

    One could have easily been ruled a rake against the Blues defence and a goal line drop-out, deemed a loose carry instead.

    The other saw Cronk taken out late by Scott which prevented Cooper from putting JT onside.

    Not saying they were good or bad calls, just that his performance didn't help him in the eyes of the Queensland public.

    EDIT: Plus the one try the Blues scored came off a penalty that the video referees recommended.
     
    Last edited: May 23, 2015
    CaptainHook likes this.
  4. Organix

    Organix NRL Player

    1,109
    442
    Yeah Hook,

    I have always been of the opinion that (whether I am watching or playing) that if it is a fair contest then it doesn't matter whether I win or lose. But when there are dirty tactics or really blatantly bad refereeing (I don't mind the odd mistake, we are all human) then it just sours the taste so much that I really just want to turn my back on the game.

    Why have laws of the game if we don't abide by them? It just doesn't make any sense to me. I don't know whether it is my biased opinion but there are some teams that play fairly (Brisbane - without Carl Webb, New Zealand, Cowboys - without Carl Webb) and others that do not (Manly - all the time no joke, Bulldogs - wtf Reynolds?, Melbourne - wrestle).

    If the competition was played with honour and to the letter the skill of the game would shine through. One of my main problems with AFL is all that BS push and shove they do, it just seems thuggish and in bad form.

    Really milking my 2 cents now.
     
  5. gordjw

    gordjw NRL Player

    [MENTION=1899]Big Pete[/MENTION], also when they declined to intervene after Woods knocked the ball dead in goal from the kickoff.

    I don't mind if they want VR to overturn decisions, but nobody (including themselves) knows when they can or should.
     
    subsbligh and Big Pete like this.
  6. Don't remind me.

    I was just talking about Game III. I already whinged about that crooked piece of reffing.
     
    gordjw likes this.
  7. Splinter

    Splinter NRL Player

    2,733
    953
    I am firmly of the belief they need a fan in the new bunker when it is established to give a quick common sense opinion to the video refs. Mostly it only takes one or two looks at the replay.
    I am willing to put up my hand for the job:takdir:
     
    gordjw likes this.
  8. ivanhungryjak

    ivanhungryjak NRL Captain

    Why can't they just put an old Warrior in the box to take away the perception of bias. Someone like that died in the wool kiwi Steve Price would do good.
     
    Cult3 and CaptainHook like this.
  9. Cult3

    Cult3 State of Origin Captain

    8,345
    5,137
    A Kiwi rugby union player would definitely lack bias. What is Brad Thorn doing now that he has retired?
     
    Nashy and Morkel like this.
  10. subsbligh

    subsbligh NRL Captain

    3,268
    884
    So long as they properly administer the burden of proof, I can live with that.

    Sufficient evidence imports a pretty high degree of certainty.

    More than 2 or 3 looks at it means that it there is probably a high degree of uncertainty in the footage you are looking at, therefore you should default to the on-field referee's decision.

    That's the whole point - the on field refs need to make a good decision first.
     
  11. This entire setup doesn't work, because they are forcing the refs to make a call, even if it's 100% a guess.
     
  12. Bucking Beads

    Bucking Beads International Captain

    [​IMG]
     
    Harry Sack likes this.
  13. ivanhungryjak

    ivanhungryjak NRL Captain

    See, this is another fault of the NRL. Gus Gould and his ilk were complaining about the refs. "Make a decision", they said, "then send it up for confirmation".

    So that's what they changed it to.

    Now they are whinging, "The refs have no idea so they have a guess and send it up".

    That fool will never be happy until he makes 100% of decisions relating to the entire NRL operations.
     
    gordjw likes this.
  14. [​IMG]
     
  15. Another howler from The General tonight.
     
    LittleDavey83 likes this.
  16. LittleDavey83

    LittleDavey83 NRL Player

    1,111
    622
    Bundy
    Subs, you're a prophet :D
     
    subsbligh likes this.
  17. Bernard Sutton was the video ref last night, at least according to NRLstats.
     
  18. Yep, Bernard was one of them but Patten was with him according to the official program.
     
    Harry Sack and QUEENSLANDER like this.
  19. Ah, so he did have an influence then. I wonder if they release audio from the video ref box?

    "Bernie, push the no try button or ‚ÄčI will give you SUCH a pinch"
     
    Harry Sack likes this.
  20. uptheguts

    uptheguts QCup Player

    347
    129
    Qld will never get any of these 50:50 decisions with Patten in the box. That's a given. These contests are so close that there is always a good chance the result will hinge on a video ref decision. Patten will come back to hurt us again and again and again.
     
    Bucking Beads likes this.

Share This Page

Loading...