CROSS FORUM NRL 2023 Round 5 Discussion

[NZWarriors.com]

	Dixpat - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .February 3, 2014 MESSAGES: 2,748 REACTIONS: 6,210

---

	BroncsFan - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .July 28, 2016 MESSAGES: 14,069 Reaction Score: 20,784

---

Only if it's ruled a Cat 1 I think

---

Following a review of the data and the expert advice we have received, the Commission have enhanced these protocols even further by providing a mandatory 11 day stand down period following a diagnosed concussion.”

In exceptional circumstances, Clubs will have the ability to apply for exemption to the 11-day stand-down period, through a review by an independent neurological expert appointed by the NRL. This application will only be allowable where the following set criteria are met:

Category 1 signs/symptoms are not observed
The player is asymptomatic the day following the concussion
Cognitive testing has returned to normal
The player has suffered fewer than five previous career concussions
The player has no previously diagnosed concussions within the previous three months
The player has no history of a previous concussion with prolonged recovery

---

 

[Foordy]

	Dixpat - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .February 3, 2014 MESSAGES: 2,747 REACTIONS: 6,210

---

Since Tedesco failed his HIA does that mean he is subject to the 11 day stand down

---

well that really depends on if failing a HIA is classed as a concussion diagnosis.

being a cat 2 does mean he can apply for an exemption

 

[GCBRONCO]

Too easy

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Defence - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 9, 2012 MESSAGES: 8,032 REACTIONS: 25,534

---

Who has the best halfback out of our clubs? Have to be Reynolds wouldn't it? Or is there a case for DCE? SJ too hot and cold I reckon but his defence might be the best of the three

I’ve been thinking about this during the first half and it’s a tough one because Reynolds has sorta got better as he’s gone on where as Sj peaked early (or did he?) that season before he broke his leg he was unbelievable, while dce has been the most consistent- won a gf in his debut year (beating Sj) and is still going strong.
So I would say…
On recent form (the last couple of years) Reynolds, dce, Sj.
In their prime Sj, dce, Reynolds.
Over the course of their career dce, Sj, Reynolds.

---

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Mr Dragon - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .July 25, 2015 MESSAGES: 2,844 REACTIONS: 4,184

---

I’ve been thinking about this during the first half and it’s a tough one because Reynolds has sorta got better as he’s gone on where as Sj peaked early (or did he?) that season before he broke his leg he was unbelievable, while dce has been the most consistent- won a gf in his debut year (beating Sj) and is still going strong.
So I would say…
On recent form (the last couple of years) Reynolds, dce, Sj.
In their prime Sj, dce, Reynolds.
Over the course of their career dce, Sj, Reynolds.

Young SJ and Walsh are very similar!

---

 

[Foordy]

	Defence - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 9, 2012 MESSAGES: 8,032 REACTIONS: 25,534

---

I’ve been thinking about this during the first half and it’s a tough one because Reynolds has sorta got better as he’s gone on where as Sj peaked early (or did he?) that season before he broke his leg he was unbelievable, while dce has been the most consistent- won a gf in his debut year (beating Sj) and is still going strong.
So I would say…
On recent form (the last couple of years) Reynolds, dce, Sj.
In their prime Sj, dce, Reynolds.
Over the course of their career dce, Sj, Reynolds.

---

I'd easily have Reynolds ahead of SJ. he's played in 2 GF's winning one and been far more consistent than SJ

 

[Aldo]

Why the **** are Channel 9 letting Sonny Bill anywhere near a microphone. **** he is a punish.

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Defence - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 9, 2012 MESSAGES: 8,033 REACTIONS: 25,534

---

	Foordy - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .March 3, 2008 MESSAGES: 30,359 Reaction Score: 32,550

---

I'd easily have Reynolds ahead of SJ. he's played in 2 GF's winning one and been far more consistent than SJ

---

JOIN THE #KEVOLUTION

Played his whole career in stacked teams though- never had to carry a team like Sj.
Has Reynolds ever even been the best player in his team?

---

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Bangbros 2023 - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 20, 2019 MESSAGES: 3,531 REACTIONS: 8,700

---

	Nashy - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .March 5, 2008 MESSAGES: 48,956 Reaction Score: 25,801

---

You may have noticed.... we're trying to get Cross Forum with NZWarriors.com and Silvertails.net running. Won't be long.

---

My dog and I take full responsibility for annoying Mr Fourex.

Can't think of anything worse!

---

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Beastmode - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .March 7, 2015 MESSAGES: 11,658 REACTIONS: 23,306

---

Can't think of anything worse!

It does beg the question WHY???????

---

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Bangbros 2023 - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 20, 2019 MESSAGES: 3,532 REACTIONS: 8,701

---

	Aldo - broncoshq.com
	JOINED: .July 7, 2013 MESSAGES: 2,987 Reaction Score: 5,553

---

Why the **** are Channel 9 letting Sonny Bill anywhere near a microphone. **** he is a punish.

---

You obviously haven't seen sky sports commentary!

---

 

[Aldo]

	Bangbros 2023 - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .May 20, 2019 MESSAGES: 3,532 REACTIONS: 8,701

---

You obviously haven't seen sky sports commentary!

---

That's what it reminds me of

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Mr Dragon - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .July 25, 2015 MESSAGES: 2,845 REACTIONS: 4,186

---

These late night games, It's gone 11pm NRL

---

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Mr Dragon - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .July 25, 2015 MESSAGES: 2,846 REACTIONS: 4,186

---

What a pass!

---

 

[Fernando]

Doorey is tank

 

[Kimlo]

I haven't been watching Parra too closely this year, do they just suck now or have they been unlucky.

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Mr Dragon - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .July 25, 2015 MESSAGES: 2,847 REACTIONS: 4,186

---

Looks like a Wiremu!

---

 

[NZWarriors.com]

	Dixpat - nzwarriors.com
	JOINED: .February 3, 2014 MESSAGES: 2,749 REACTIONS: 6,210

---

The stripping rule is a joke as you have no idea which way it is going to go

---