- Jan 25, 2014
- 44,374
- 33,596
PRE-GAME Round 24 - Roosters vs Broncos
- Thread starter theshed
- Start date
M.B.88
NRL Captain
- Oct 23, 2013
- 3,511
- 3,080
This shoulder charge business is ridiculous :(
There should be a differentiation between a defender "bracing themselves" and an obvious dog shot from a defender.
The situation where a man with 30+ kilos on you charging your way and getting caught out (naturally protecting yourself as anyone would do as an automatic reaction), should be treated with common sense and not just a black and white definition of "shoulder charge" when compared to the sort of stuff karmichael or Inglis used to do on defenders. When there's an opportunity to make a regulated tackle, you should.
The issue is, how do you make it as black and white as possible to account for poor interpretation like the old obstruction rule had last year and the year before
There should be a differentiation between a defender "bracing themselves" and an obvious dog shot from a defender.
The situation where a man with 30+ kilos on you charging your way and getting caught out (naturally protecting yourself as anyone would do as an automatic reaction), should be treated with common sense and not just a black and white definition of "shoulder charge" when compared to the sort of stuff karmichael or Inglis used to do on defenders. When there's an opportunity to make a regulated tackle, you should.
The issue is, how do you make it as black and white as possible to account for poor interpretation like the old obstruction rule had last year and the year before
Stix
NRL Player
- Mar 28, 2014
- 1,641
- 1,483
the new rules are going to make smaller guys trying to defend against bigger guys more prone to head knocks, they don't want to miss the tackle so their only option is to go in low which as we see all time Leeds to players heads getting collected by hips and knees. Or they brace themselves for impact and then have a second attempt at the tackle which I'm pretty sure is what Milf did the other night.
GCBRONCO
International Captain
- Mar 4, 2008
- 22,561
- 21,013
Knowing our luck two of our forwards will be charged.
GCBRONCO
International Captain
- Mar 4, 2008
- 22,561
- 21,013
Geuerra and Ferguson to fight their charges apparently.
https://twitter.com/SteveHartFOX/status/633498980526108672
- Feb 27, 2010
- 29,889
- 12,205
Do they have a foot to stand on? I haven't seen the game or offences in question...
- Jan 25, 2014
- 44,374
- 33,596
If Guerra is successful, then the judiciary is a complete joke.
That was a shoulder charge.
He had the upper arm tucked in, he led in with the shoulder and made contact with the shoulder.
It's not like he was bracing for impact. He came across to put the hit on.. That's why Eels were able to score so easily. It left Pearce to defend against two players.
That was a shoulder charge.
He had the upper arm tucked in, he led in with the shoulder and made contact with the shoulder.
It's not like he was bracing for impact. He came across to put the hit on.. That's why Eels were able to score so easily. It left Pearce to defend against two players.
Last edited:
- Oct 17, 2013
- 12,841
- 14,848
If anyone is worried about JWH this weekend, you should know that instead of running through the amazing Parramatta defensive line (like the media would have you believe), he actually just ran through De Gois and a bloke with a broken neck.
Financeguy
NRL Player
- Apr 24, 2013
- 2,093
- 3,323
Regardless, he is still an important player in the Roosters success and will be out for a big one against us after being out pointed by Thaiday last game.
Stopping JWH's impact will go a long way to help us winning this game.
I will be really interested to see our defensive tactics this Sat night. Should be a cracker of a game, semi finals come early really.
BRONCOS
1. Darius Boyd
2. Lachlan Maranta
3. Jack Reed
4. Justin Hodges ©
5. Jordan Kahu
6. Anthony Milford
7. Ben Hunt
8. Sam Thaiday
9. Andrew McCullough
10. Adam Blair
11. Alex Glenn
12. Matt Gillett
13. Corey Parker
Interchange:
14. Jarrod Wallace
15. Mitchell Dodds
16. Joe Ofahengaue
17. Kodi Nikorima
1. Darius Boyd
2. Lachlan Maranta
3. Jack Reed
4. Justin Hodges ©
5. Jordan Kahu
6. Anthony Milford
7. Ben Hunt
8. Sam Thaiday
9. Andrew McCullough
10. Adam Blair
11. Alex Glenn
12. Matt Gillett
13. Corey Parker
Interchange:
14. Jarrod Wallace
15. Mitchell Dodds
16. Joe Ofahengaue
17. Kodi Nikorima
austin71
NRL Player
- Apr 21, 2013
- 1,325
- 368
Yeah especially after Reed missed 8 tackles and played ordinary. See how he goes this week i guess.
- Sep 28, 2012
- 13,165
- 11,346
Yeah they went a bit overboard. Sure it was a great front-rower's try, but they were basically just 3 or 4 speedhumps being hit one at a time. Obviously can only play what's in front of him, but it wasn't something that say Fifita doesn't do at least once a season. Sammy owned him earlier this year and hopefully will do again this week
I bleed Maroon
International Rep
- Apr 17, 2013
- 15,933
- 20,831
Pretty much as expected. Is that knee still troubling Oates? I can't imagine for a second that he's out of favor.
GCBRONCO
International Captain
- Mar 4, 2008
- 22,561
- 21,013
I'd say so and nearing the finals the club is probably reluctant to rush him back.
Had a quick look on the Broncos injury list on their website, not listed so perhaps could be a late inclusion?
Either way I wouldn't read too much into it.
Had a quick look on the Broncos injury list on their website, not listed so perhaps could be a late inclusion?
Either way I wouldn't read too much into it.
Last edited:
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,213
- 25,962
Sounds like Oates was due back for this clash, but Bennett has opted for Ofahengaue after his impressive display against the Dragons.
Ofahengaue Preferred On The Bench - Broncos
Ofahengaue Preferred On The Bench - Broncos
