Tiebreaker - Judges Choice

[ningnangnong]

Lockyer.............3 first, 3 second, 3 third..............18 points
Thaiday.............3 first, 3 second, 3 third..............18 points

Darren Lockyer and Sam Thaiday are completely equal in the inaugural BHQ POTS competition.

You guys decide what to do next.

Shall we have one more round of voting to decide who is the overall winner, or settle for a draw between the two?

Vote.

 

[The Brizz]

Have a vote off IMO, you can't have a tie!

 

[schmix]

Have a vote off IMO, you can't have a tie!

Nooo that's what the NRL want you to believe! A tie is ok, really! If they've both been equally good throughout the year, with the exact same number of 1sts, 2nds and 3rds, then they both deserve it.

My main worry is that people's votes will be affected by who played better more recently, rather than judging the season as a whole.

 

[Foordy]

I say we call it a tie for first. since they are equal in all placings.

 

[Fozz]

Let's have them compete in a series of gruelling challenges.

And then follow it up with a Zeppelin race!

I know I'm not a judge, just thought the option should be out there.

 

[Kimlo]

We can't really judge a winner because this is based on football through out the season and they've been decided equal. I say call it a tie because there's no really way to fairly choose a winner now.

 

[Coxy]

Call it the Luke Skywalker award. A tie is like kissing your sister.

 

[ningnangnong]

This will go down to the wire.

 

[Nashy]

The winner is the bloke who looked the best bringing the trophy to the Grand Final.

Deadset. I woulda turned.

 

[Russo]

Tie is a fair result, they both get an equal share of the prize.............................nothing

 

[ddd]

Have a vote off IMO, you can't have a tie!

Nooo that's what the NRL want you to believe! A tie is ok, really! If they've both been equally good throughout the year, with the exact same number of 1sts, 2nds and 3rds, then they both deserve it.

Tie is fair - they're both topps and deserve this incredibly honourable accolade

 

[Beale]

Tie is a fair result