Winterstein, Kemp and Yow Yeh - Who would you let go?

[Charmamba]

Ok since the admin are upset about our Wing debates popping up everywhere. Here is the thread to argue over who you think is better.

Lets just say 1 needs to go, who would you release?

For mine it would be Winter, when fit imo Yow and Kemp have the speed needed to finish Locky plays and both look to have abit of Football smarts about them.

Winter is a very solid winger for sure and total credit to him, I just think he would be better suited with another teams style.

 

[Coxy]

If I HAD to choose one of them to go then yes it would be Summerpot. But I don't see why we can't retain all 3.

 

[tkday]

I agree. Under different circumstances we could've found a different spot for him.

 

[Bucking Beads]

If I HAD to choose one of them to go then yes it would be Summerpot. But I don't see why we can't retain all 3.

 

[Foordy]

If I HAD to choose one of them to go then yes it would be Summerpot. But I don't see why we can't retain all 3.

we should have the money to retain all 3 an i think that is the best idea to have some depth in that position

 

[Nashy]

Winter.

 

[azza79]

But I don't see why we can't retain all 3.

I don't see why either. Do we need to get rid of one of them? How does Winterstein play in the centres? I could be wrong, but for some reason I thought that was his position when he was with the Roosters NYC team. And with Izzy gone there will be a spot to fill in the centres...

 

[Fozz]

Yeah, I'm sure Winterstein played in the centres for the Chicks.

If we seriously aren't going for Inglis then there is another spot open so I can't see why Winterstein can't have a shot at it.

It's not just about money though, Cowboys may be offering him a certain starters spot. It's not like Bani or Williams are brilliant wingers.

 

[PETERN]

Kemp.

 

[pennywisealfie]

Kemp

 

[Alec]

It's tough. Probably Yow Yeh, but only because I think he'll demand more money than the other 2. Wingers aren't that important to a team anyway, and Kemp and Winter would both do a good enough job.

 

[dandan]

LOL, you guys are grasping straws, Yoh Yeh will be a origin player in the short future and will be one of our strike players in years to come.
His played this year injured once he gets back to full fitness its game over.
Kemp people love kemp because of 2008, get over it thats the past he hasnt done anything since & Winter well his a good average player isnt that quick & gets caught out in defence.

So its yippio Yoh Yeh for me cause i believe... [icon_drun [icon_drun [icon_drun

 

[Black Philip]

Probably Winterstein.

 

[Coxy]

LOL, you guys are grasping straws, Yoh Yeh will be a origin player in the short future and will be one of our strike players in years to come.
His played this year injured once he gets back to full fitness its game over.
Kemp people love kemp because of 2008, get over it thats the past he hasnt done anything since & Winter well his a good average player isnt that quick & gets caught out in defence.

So its yippio Yoh Yeh for me cause i believe... [icon_drun [icon_drun [icon_drun

LOLZ topic understanding FAIL!

 

[PETERN]

LOL, you guys are grasping straws, Yoh Yeh will be a origin player in the short future and will be one of our strike players in years to come.
His played this year injured once he gets back to full fitness its game over.
Kemp people love kemp because of 2008, get over it thats the past he hasnt done anything since & Winter well his a good average player isnt that quick & gets caught out in defence.

So its yippio Yoh Yeh for me cause i believe... [icon_drun [icon_drun [icon_drun

LOLZ topic understanding FAIL!

+1 BAHAHAHA

 

[ningnangnong]

But I don't see why we can't retain all 3.

I don't see why either. Do we need to get rid of one of them? How does Winterstein play in the centres? I could be wrong, but for some reason I thought that was his position when he was with the Roosters NYC team. And with Izzy gone there will be a spot to fill in the centres...

Exactly.

We should do our best to keep all three.

Kemp and Yow Yeh probably have a bit more potential than Winterstein, and they have a certain 'x-factor' (I hate using that term) about them.

Winterstein's still a bloody good player though and wouldn't look out of place in the centres IMO.

 

[Coxy]

Kemp and Yow Yeh probably have a bit more potential than Winterstein, and they have a certain 'x-factor' (I hate using that term) about them.

 

[Bucking Beads]

Yow Yeh is some what of a myth at the moment IMO. He has more potential than Winter and Kemp but has shown very little IMO.