This player or that player?

[holdzy]

Thought it would be fun to play this game. Answer which player you prefer and why if you like and then ask your own question.

(Try not to quote the same post if you can, keep it flowing)


Brett Kimmorley or Stacey Jones?

 

[Kimlo]

Stacey Jones.

Are we sticking with retired players only?

Anthony Minichiello or Brett Stewart?

 

[holdzy]

Stacey Jones.

Are we sticking with retired players only?

Anthony Minichiello or Brett Stewart?

Nah any player.

That's a tough one, pretty even. Probably just go Mini.

Preston Campbell or Scott Prince?

 

[Renegade]

Jones, Mini, Prince

Older one, Ettinghausen or Renouf?

 

[holdzy]

Jones, Mini, Prince

Older one, Ettinghausen or Renouf?

Renouf.

Ryan Girdler or Mat Rogers?

 

[Nashy]

Renouf.

Ryan Girdler or Mat Rogers?

Girdler

Alf or Johns

 

[holdzy]

Girdler

Alf or Johns

Alf. More consistent for longer, but Joey was more skillful overall. Still, Alf.

Thurston or Brett Kenny?

 

[theshed]

Thurston

Willy Tonga or Nathan Merritt ?

 

[holdzy]

Tonga.

Matty Johns or Jason Taylor?

 

[Nashy]

Johns

Gordy or Mick Crocker?

 

[pennywisealfie]

Mick Crocker because he's gonna play Survivor

Palmer Wapau or Kaine Manihera?

 

[holdzy]

Palmer.

Priddis or Farah?

 

[Blindside Bronco]

Priddis.

Matt Cooper or Matt Sears

 

[mrslong]

Priddis.

Matt Cooper or Matt Sears

Matt Cooper

Justin Hodges or Greg Inglis

 

[ningnangnong]

I'd be interested to read each poster's justification for their selection, would make the thread more engaging. Or am I on my own here?

 

[holdzy]

I'd be interested to read each poster's justification for their selection, would make the thread more engaging. Or am I on my own here?

Everyone can give reasons or just say a name, sometimes it's just a personal preference.

Prefer Hodges but Inglis was the more gifted player.

Matt Sing or Brian To'o

 

[tommy]

I'd be interested to read each poster's justification for their selection, would make the thread more engaging. Or am I on my own here?

No. This thread is stupid so far.

 

[Blindside Bronco]

Matt Sing. To' is overrated

Nathan Hindmarsh or Brian Fletcher?