This player or that player?

[holdzy]

Matt Sing. To' is overrated

Nathan Hindmarsh or Brian Fletcher?

Hindmarsh.

Jason Smith or Darren Smith?

 

[Blindside Bronco]

Hindmarsh.

Jason Smith or Darren Smith?

Darren Smith.

Michael Ennis or Tyson Gamble?

 

[Galah]

Darren Smith.

Michael Ennis or Tyson Gamble?

Ennis

Inglis or maninga

 

[holdzy]

Ennis

Inglis or maninga

Tough one.

I'd go Inglis - could cover any position 1-6, probably play second row in a pinch in his Souths days.


Matt Bowen or David Peachey?

 

[BroncsFan]

I thought there was meant to be a "why?" component to this

 

[ningnangnong]

Matt Bowen or David Peachey?

Another tough one, both entertainers in their own right.

I'll give it to Matty Bowen. Despite his small size, he was an absolute weapon with his elusiveness and electrifying pace. Always used to love watching the little fella pin the ears back.

Special mention to Peach for his knack of putting down the ball for a try right before the deadball line.

Ben Kennedy or Trent Waterhouse?

 

[pennywisealfie]

Ben Kennedy was better for longer

Jason Taylor or Trent Hodkinson

 

[holdzy]

Ben Kennedy was better for longer

Jason Taylor or Trent Hodkinson

Jason Taylor.

Peter Sterling or Cooper Cronk?

 

[Blindside Bronco]

Jason Taylor.

Peter Sterling or Cooper Cronk?

Sterling

Matt Bowen or David Mead

 

[holdzy]

Sterling

Matt Bowen or David Mead

I wonder if Sterling over Cronk would be considered controversial by most?

Bowen easily.

Lazarus or Haas?

 

[Wolfie]

I wonder if Sterling over Cronk would be considered controversial by most?

Bowen easily.

Lazarus or Haas?

Haas

Slater or Lockyer ( at fullback )

 

[Blindside Bronco]

Lockyer!!!

Steven Menzies or Billy Moore

 

[Blindside Bronco]

Lockyer!!!

Steven Menzies or Billy Moore

I like Billy More!

Sorry I'll see myself our!

 

[holdzy]

Menzies, such a great line runner and a prolific try scorer.

Steve Walters or Kerrod Walters?

 

[Foordy]

Steve Walters ... second best hooker to play the game IMO

Anthony Milford or Ash Taylor

 

[Kimlo]

Milford, he actually was one of the best at one stage, Taylor has been a flop the whole way through.

Brent Tate or Justin Hodges

 

[ZTop]

Steve Walters ... second best hooker to play the game IMO

Anthony Milford or Ash Taylor

Milford. At least he was elite for a couple seasons unlike Taylor.

Willie Mason or George Rose

 

[Blindside Bronco]

Menzies, such a great line runner and a prolific try scorer.

Steve Walters or Kerrod Walters?

You son of of bitch that was going to be my next one!
I think I love you.