BHQ Countdown: Most Loved/Least Liked Players Reveal thread

[Harry Sack]

 

[pennywisealfie]

BHQ Loved

27. Anthony Milford

2015-2021
Position: Five-Eighth
Games: 151
Tries: 49
Highest Vote: 5 (something)

BHQ Loathed

27. Lachlan Maranta

2012-2016
Position: Wing
Games: 70
Tries: 30
Highest Vote: 6 (ningnangnong)

 

[Harry Sack]

Ahhh, Lachlan. Post the meme if you've still got it @Morkel

 

[kman]

Dam I thought Maranta would be top 10 for sure.

 

[Nashy]

Milford's 2015 was fantastic.

 

[Sproj]

Milford's 2015 was fantastic.

His 2015-mid-2016 were phenomenal. Post-mid 2016 was just pure garbage and he basically dragged the jersey through the mud. In fact, post-2016, he's descent to awful has been astonishing.

 

[mrslong]

BHQ Loved

27. Anthony Milford

2015-2021
Position: Five-Eighth
Games: 151
Tries: 49
Highest Vote: 5 (something)

BHQ Loathed

27. Lachlan Maranta

2012-2016
Position: Wing
Games: 70
Tries: 30
Highest Vote: 6 (ningnangnong)

Ew.

 

[Mr Fourex]

Milford's 2015 was fantastic.

Agreed.....as for the rest of his time with us, well

its been discussed ad nauseam, with pluses and minus from both sides.

 

[Nashy]

Agreed.....as for the rest of his time with us, well

its been discussed ad nauseam, with pluses and minus from both sides.

Mostly minuses though.

 

[Fozz]

I don't like Dearden at all. Not a big Lote guy either TBH.

Sneak peak for tomorrow: In a bit of a shock, a player in the top 10 on one list will appear on the other list.

Has to be Milford. Maranta is to much of a nuffie.

 

[Mustafur]

Agreed.....as for the rest of his time with us, well

its been discussed ad nauseam, with pluses and minus from both sides.

1 plus with 99 minuses.

 

[pennywisealfie]

I found the 2011 list. It was actually a list for the greatest Bronco, not favourite Bronco, but will still be cool to add that ranking from 2011 to each player posted. Thanks to the legend @ningnangnong for compiling the list.

Here are the positions from 2011 for players already posted on the loved list:

Israel Folau 37
Tyson Gamble NA
Alex Glenn 36
Jake Turpin NA
Jordan Riki NA
Payne Haas NA
Denan Kemp 75
Kerrod Walters 15
James Roberts NA
Trevor Gillmeister 27
Greg Eden NA
Paul Hauff 58
Kotoni Staggs NA
Ian Lacey 86
Andrew McCullough 67
Terry Matterson 29
Dave Taylor 53
Luke Priddis 25
Chris Walker 46
Darren Smith 14
John Plath 33
Willie Carne 22
Lote Tuqiri 19
Anthony Milford NA

 

[pennywisealfie]

Tomorrow on the loved list, a former captain.
Tomorrow on the loathed list, a former shit player but seems to be doing alright now.

 

[Sproj]

Tomorrow on the loved list, a former captain.
Tomorrow on the loathed list, a former shit player but seems to be doing alright now.

I’m guessing Boyd or Glenn and Croft.

 

[Kimlo]

Love your work penny. My favourite thing is actually the slow pace. It's just something interesting to look forward to when I check BHQ every day and having mini discussions about all these players is great.

 

[holdzy]

His 2015-mid-2016 were phenomenal. Post-mid 2016 was just pure garbage and he basically dragged the jersey through the mud. In fact, post-2016, he's descent to awful has been astonishing.

He was hardly garbage in 2017-2018. From 2019 on though it was like when Boyd fell off a cliff but in super slow motion.

 

[Morkel]

Ahhh, Lachlan. Post the meme if you've still got it @Morkel

It was in a very old Photobucket, but I know someone saved it, maybe @Fozz ?

 

[Fozz]

It was in a very old Photobucket, but I know someone saved it, maybe @Fozz ?