If you really want to list some examples of five eighths and their tiers that would be helpful...
OK freestyling here but I'd roughly say: (lets just use 1-4 for the ease of it)
1
Munster
Ezra
2
Luai
C walker
Burton (in between 2 and 3 IMO)
3
Sharpe
Trindall
Brooks
4
Ilias
Atkinson
As a reference you get the idea, I assume you disagree about Burton.
Never the less, my point is that Luai is up there with the 'current' 6s going around... we aren't in a blessed era of Lockyers/Fittlers/Daleys etc.
I'm not a big fan of Luai, I'm just calling it objectively for what it is.
Sexton is good no frills player that is very likeable does his job and is a hell of a lot cheaper.
He might not attract as much attention or certain other players... but he won't drive others away though.
Furthermore, this is where I'm really on the other side of the coin.
Not sure if you place much emphasis on the 'business' side of rugby league.
But if you are a CEO of a club, you will get MUCH more praise for signing Luai than Sexton.
(and really, its what we are actually seeing in reality)
Luai has basically paid for himself.
Think like Beckham signing for MLS, JS Park signing for MAN U back in the day (literally every Korean was suddenly a MAN U fan)
---
Just my 2 cents, I just thought the whole "he's over-rated , he's a grub" sorta vibes is not thinking big picture.
And I personally disagree about his impact at Penrith, I think you downplay it a bit, He wasn't the main man of course, but he played a massive 'Robin' role, esp with the connection between bizza/critta and co. No one really went on a free ride at the panthers IMO, as much as I hate them, you don't win 4 titles in a row in today's game by having freeloaders. No team has come close to even winning 3 I believe.
GF LOSS, WIN WIN WIN WIN, PRELIM LOSS
As much as I hate to admit it, I gotta tip my hat off to it.
Purely from PNG's POV, I think its a massive signing.