Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,097
- 25,710
They probably want a prop, not an average second row.
Can't believe the Raiders threw good money at him.
Can't believe the Raiders threw good money at him.
well youre wrong on pretty much all counts there. also, this:AP...you appear to have a modicum of intelligence but you must be very young. Only the the very young or dumb could hold the multitude of views you seem to have but you can defend yourself when writing and expressing your point so I'll assume you are very young. Give up on the WB bashing. Those of us who have lived a long time have gained some wisdom, WB even more so.
It appears your angry and it impairs your thinking. The word jealous springs to mind reading your condemnation of WB. No, not every decision made by WB is right or perfect but the overwhelming majority are well reasoned and well considered. Despite your immature accusations, we are not all blind to WBs(and others) failings. It's just that we do not simply pigeonhole someone for a single decision.
Sandow didnt go to Parramatta declaring he'll play awesome every match either, so its not a 'fail'......right?WB never went to Newcastle declaring he would win a premiership so it is not a 'fail'.
i didnt expect him to win a premiership at all, because I dont think hes anywhere near as great a coach ANYMORE as everyone on here and the general dumb public think.Societal expectation (and yours apparently !!!) was that he would. WB went there to coach a team to perform to their potential and perhaps, given the circumstances, they did. They may not have been capable of much more I do not know but I'm absolutely certain of this though......you have no clue either.
AP...you appear to have a modicum of intelligence
well youre wrong on pretty much all counts there.
find where i said Bennett declared he'd bring home a premiership. find the tooth fairy while youre there. maybe say hi to bigfoot as well.What annoys most is your insinuation the WB declared he would bring home a premiership. He did no such thing. Rather he declared he would do the best job he could. As you or I do not know what has happened behind the scenes at Newcastle neither you nor I can say whether he 'failed' or not.
I havent seen that from your offerings.I am old but you should be able to deduce from my offerings on this forum that I am hardly senile. Rather I still see myself as an articulate and thoughtful poster. I refrain from knee-jerk responses and keep my expectations of others humble. I do not expect the super human standards so sorely missing in others that you do.
no excuse is needed, correct - hes just not a coach that can take any group of players and turn them into a premiership force. Des Hasler looks like he can. Craig Bellamy looks like he can. Bennett doesnt.I make no excuse for WBs efforts this year as no excuse is needed. Each coach has had varying degrees of success and that simply, is all there is to it.
AP, your childlike simplistic view that success can only be measured by the number of premierships won is why your opinions are so lightly regarded. You are not unintelligent, you are just wrong about so much.
AP, who exactly are the 10+ rep players they had at their disposal this year? Also do not put City Country reps in your list because that is akin to a trial game.
1. Gidley - Current to some extent
2. Mullen - Hasn't played rep footy in years
3. McManus - Played once years ago
4. Costigan - No where near good enough to play rep footy anymore
5. Tahu - Way past his best
6. Uate - Current
7. Buderus - 34 and won't get another go
8. Snowden - Current
9. Boyd - Current
10. Taia - May have played for NZ but hasn't been good for a few years
11. Sau - Same as Taia
Basically they only had 4 genuine current rep standard players in Boyd, Uate, Snowden and Gidley and your argument that they have 10+ is completely stupid because those players are not picked in rep temas for a reason and it is mainly due to ongoing form. It would be like naming Matt Cooper and Ben Hornby as "rep players" when talking about the Dragons this year, they were rep players a long time ago but age and form make them anything but that now. You seriously need to actually think about things before you post them sometimes because these posts do make you look stupid because of how blatantly biased you are.