Now I understand where Gus is coming from with the Broncos junior model. I was under the impression the Broncos were still signing 30 U/20 players but they happened to be with Norths, Souths and Wynum.
The article is not completely accurate. It paints the picture that the Broncos only have three U/20s players in TC Robati, Selwyn Cobbo and Xavier Willison on deals outside the NRL when we know that Josh James is also a part of that group and I'd imagine there'd be a few others. Either way, I doubt it's more than a dozen and if that's the case then it's a huge issue.
Scanlen tries to argue that the Broncos have an impressive strike record but a lot of those talents he's trumped up were can't miss players. There still needs to be room for players like a Nick Kenny type who may not be a stand out but eventually becomes a valuable squad player.
I hope this is an area Donaghy address' right away. It's honestly an area where the Broncos should have been a lot better in. I agree with 1910's assessment that Brisbane's junior recruitment has always been strong, but their ability to turn them into quality U/20s and then into quality NRL players has been lacking ever since Hook was promoted. Brisbane should have been among the strongest NYC teams year in year out during the 10 years the competition existed, instead they really only had two good groups. To me it suggests they don't have the right people looking after that system.
I don't think Brisbane are the type of club that can just get by on NRL recruitment either. It's too expensive to up-root a bunch of Sydney players and get them to perform to a satisfactory standard. They need to bring these players through and make sure they're getting a better Rugby League education than any other team to really prosper. Signing good talent is only one piece of that puzzle, they have to be educated and they can't just be thrown into the deep end like Tom Dearden, Tesi Niu and Xavier Coates were.
The scary thing is, Brisbane are only just starting to feel the ramifications of this. We're just starting to get into that generation where the post-NYC players are coming of age.