Broncos Roster, Signings and Rumours Discussion 2021

Status
Not open for further replies.
On the Fullback note I'd be giving Cobbo and Herbie a crack before we throw nearly a million at Manu even a couple games each to end the year off to know if what they lack can be developed.
A full pre season with Reynolds and Gamble running the show telling them what lines they want them to run on sweep plays and the positions they want them in attack.
Alot more can be learnt this preseason than previous ones with croft Milford and deardon.
But if we're buying someone Hammer should be considered aswell will be half the price of Manu
 
Not privy to all the antics of Macguire but he would be a far better signing than Napa or James. Get it done at a good price and happy days. Sometimes you need a bit of grub and grit - he would provide that.
 
007 said:
Not privy to all the antics of Macguire but he would be a far better signing than Napa or James. Get it done at a good price and happy days. Sometimes you need a bit of grub and grit - he would provide that.
Click to expand...
Yeah, if they are all roughly the same cheap price, I'd take McGuire back over the other 2.
 
McGuire didn't win a game this year at the Cows and since he went to the Dragons they went to shit too
 
McHunt said:
The Broncos have knocked back extending Danny Levi. Looks like he'll be headed to the ESL after all. They've also passed on giving Will Chambers a last hurrah.
Click to expand...
I think that is a good decision... we've got 3 hookers on the books already in Turps, Paix and Walters, with Kobe able to chip in if things get really dire... having a 4th in the top 30 just starts to be over kill.

Regardless of the perception on skill for our current hooking rotation we have effectively made our bed on who is contracted to the club and we have to live with it... Levi is a bit of a journeyman hooker, so whilst he's proving to be better than Turps at the moment, no team seems to want to commit to him in the long term, which probably says something.

I tend to think it's his inability to follow a game plan and a propensity to go it alone too often. You can see those hookers where it gets close to the try line and you think "he's going to have a run here"... or they go with 3 crash plays in a row... but they pick the wrong time to do it and it can stifle the attack and waste tackles.

That's probably how I've viewed Levi across the bulk of his career and it probably starts to impact on a coach's ability to trust him.
 
Matheos said:
I also haven't forgotten our need for a genuine fullback either. Interesting to see how it plays out at Parra with Gutherson. I'd definitely put him ahead of Manu and surely we'd have the $1M available in 2023...
Click to expand...
I dunno... I think Gutho benefits from the players around him, where he can finish off backline movements and always be in support, etc. but he's not really the chief that sparks the attack in the first place.... Parra at the moment is not getting much from their spine and even though Gutho is trying his guts out, his efforts aren't really improving their attack.

On the other hand Manu just seems to make things happen... when he's played fullback this year he's done it with a spine of kids (Teddy is not there to help) and just makes things happen through his running game.

The only concern I would have of Manu is that he hasn't shown any ball playing.... his running is usually so good that ball playing isn't required, but you still want that guy who can pick the right play on a sweep and not always be looking to run through the goal line defence.
 
I will be over the moon if we get Mo. Him and Haas are a top 4 front row combo.
Would love if we got Api too. Reuniting him and Reynolds would be mint.
 
I think Mcguire out of all the front options rumoured would be the best pick. He adds aggression and niggle but isn't a complete suspension magnet. Has a little bit of footwork before the line and he's build suits the current rules. Smaller and more mobile forwards are the future of the game with the new rule changes. Why not be ahead of the time?
 
Jayarcie said:
I think Mcguire out of all the front options rumoured would be the best pick. He adds aggression and niggle but isn't a complete suspension magnet. Has a little bit of footwork before the line and he's build suits the current rules. Smaller and more mobile forwards are the future of the game with the new rule changes. Why not be ahead of the time?
Click to expand...
The consideration would be price.

- McGuire is the best option but he's also the most expensive.
- Napa is probably next given he's slightly younger and isn't carrying the injury record that James does.
- James probably comes in at bottom dollar

It could be something like
McGuire @ $400k-$450k,
Napa @ $200k-$250k, or
James @ $150k

and then it comes down to the intended role... are we looking for experienced or are we looking for being able to contribute every game every week ie. a regular in the 17, +100m and 30 tackles a game

I think all can be a regular, but Moose provides the most (50mins a game and 100m etc... Napa and James bring equal amounts but will require the rest of the pack to step up).


For me McGuire would be the preference pending cost, otherwise I'm going James
 
BroncsFan said:
I dunno... I think Gutho benefits from the players around him, where he can finish off backline movements and always be in support, etc. but he's not really the chief that sparks the attack in the first place.... Parra at the moment is not getting much from their spine and even though Gutho is trying his guts out, his efforts aren't really improving their attack.

On the other hand Manu just seems to make things happen... when he's played fullback this year he's done it with a spine of kids (Teddy is not there to help) and just makes things happen through his running game.

The only concern I would have of Manu is that he hasn't shown any ball playing.... his running is usually so good that ball playing isn't required, but you still want that guy who can pick the right play on a sweep and not always be looking to run through the goal line defence.
Click to expand...

Manu sounds a lot like...Farnworth. The difference is, Manu is more experienced, has played as part of a FAR better team even with the injuries and has been given a run at the back. This is why I really want to see what Herbie / Cobbo have before we run out and sign a million dollar semi-tested player. I rate Manu a LOT, I just don't want to get into a bidding war for a player who could turn out to be the next Teddy or could out to be the next Cory Alan.
 
Sproj said:
Manu sounds a lot like...Farnworth. The difference is, Manu is more experienced, has played as part of a FAR better team even with the injuries and has been given a run at the back. This is why I really want to see what Herbie / Cobbo have before we run out and sign a million dollar semi-tested player. I rate Manu a LOT, I just don't want to get into a bidding war for a player who could turn out to be the next Teddy or could out to be the next Cory Alan.
Click to expand...
Manu already isn’t the next Allan. Manu’s average over the last few years isn’t even within kooee of Allan’s absolute best performance.

How dare you!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
New Posts

Unread

Watch

YouTube
0 0 944
1:34:16
NRL Round 1, 2001 - North Queensland Cowboys vs Brisbane Broncos
View full media list »

Active Now

  • Mustafur
  • IceWorks
  • Xzei
  • ChewThePhatt
  • BooKhaki
  • Financeguy
  • TwoLeftFeet
  • broncsgoat
  • RolledOates
  • Mighty Bronx
Total: 122 (members: 13, guests: 109)
Robots: 277
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.