VOTE GI No Try

Should Inglis' try have stood?


  • Total voters
    32
Big Pete

Big Pete

International Captain
Mar 12, 2008
Threads
1,372
29,097
17,440
It's the call that defined the game and I turn it over to BroncosHQ, did the video referees get the call right?
 
Big Pete

Big Pete

International Captain
Mar 12, 2008
Threads
1,372
29,097
17,440
Did the video referees get the call right?

No.

Should GI's try have stood?

No.

Here's the thing, the on-field referee deemed that Morgan did not play at the ball so that call should absolutely stand ala Hayne from last year. However, what was clear was that Myles came in and propelled the ball in the tackle. Unfortunately that's a knock on so the call should have been a double knock on to Queensland.

Still would have had a huge impact on the game.

But not as much as we thought.
 
Cult

Cult

State of Origin Captain
Oct 17, 2013
Threads
128
11,378
11,137
But if Morgan didn't play at it and it did hit Myles, which direction did it go off Pearce and into Myles? Forward. Queensland ball. Not NSW ball 15 out.
 
I bleed Maroon

I bleed Maroon

International Rep
Apr 17, 2013
Threads
290
13,015
13,898
Absolute dogshit decision. On field decision should have stood.
 
Culhwch

Culhwch

NRL Player
Mar 28, 2008
Threads
10
1,875
3,419
I honestly thought Morgan played at it. Even if not, Myles gets a touch and Inglis recovers in an offside position. Would have hated if the teams were reversed and it stood - that's my usual yardstick.
 
Ari Gold

Ari Gold

Master Baiter
Mar 13, 2008
Threads
145
6,522
2,807
Video ref made the wrong decision as there wasn't conclusive evidence. So in that sense the on field decision absolutely should have stood.

I'm not convinced the on field decision was right though. I don't think Morgan knocked on but I'm not convinced Inglis is onside when Morgan touches it.
 
Super Freak

Super Freak

International Captain
Forum Staff
Jan 25, 2014
Threads
1,064
31,387
18,890
Video ref made the wrong decision as there wasn't conclusive evidence. So in that sense the on field decision absolutely should have stood.

I'm not convinced the on field decision was right though. I don't think Morgan knocked on but I'm not convinced Inglis is onside when Morgan touches it.

It comes off Pearce, though.

That would have put Inglis onside.

I think the decision should have stood. You couldn't say for sure that it came off Myles.
 
Cult

Cult

State of Origin Captain
Oct 17, 2013
Threads
128
11,378
11,137
Video ref made the wrong decision as there wasn't conclusive evidence. So in that sense the on field decision absolutely should have stood.

I'm not convinced the on field decision was right though. I don't think Morgan knocked on but I'm not convinced Inglis is onside when Morgan touches it.

It goes backwards off Morgans hand, Pearce knocks it forward into Myles and Inglis picks it up in an offside position. No try but where is the first error?
 
Super Freak

Super Freak

International Captain
Forum Staff
Jan 25, 2014
Threads
1,064
31,387
18,890
Either way, the call should have gone QLD's way.

If it wasn't a try, scrum feed for QLD because the first infringements were the knock ons.

But I think it should have been a try.
 
Last edited:
Ari Gold

Ari Gold

Master Baiter
Mar 13, 2008
Threads
145
6,522
2,807
It goes backwards off Morgans hand, Pearce knocks it forward into Myles and Inglis picks it up in an offside position. No try but where is the first error?

I'm not saying NSW should have got the ball. Clearly they shouldn't have. I just don't know if it was correct to rule it a try on field.

However, I'm convinced that it should have stood as a try upstairs as nothing about what I saw was conclusive.
 
Porthoz

Porthoz

International Captain
Forum Staff
Feb 27, 2010
Threads
1,477
27,581
10,950
My only doubt is whether Myles touched the ball, which would've made it a double knock on, and Qld feed. I could've lived with it, if that was the original decision, but there is absolutely no way that the fuckwit video ref could conclude with certainty the onfield ref's decision was wrong.
That is exactly why the try should have stood, but that was never going to happen with Qld already 1 game up.
 
broncsgoat

broncsgoat

Banned User
Oct 28, 2013
Threads
27
10,196
11,417
Can a mod please edit the thread title to 'GI Try' please... Because blind Freddie with aids could see that was a fucking try...
 
vertigo

vertigo

State of Origin Rep
Mar 2, 2010
Threads
40
5,147
3,088
I said to my Dad watching it "they will take this off him".

Never, ever think a try is safe when it goes to the video ref - even if it looks fine.
 
Super Freak

Super Freak

International Captain
Forum Staff
Jan 25, 2014
Threads
1,064
31,387
18,890
I think if that wasn't at such a crucial stage of the game, it would have been awarded..
 
vertigo

vertigo

State of Origin Rep
Mar 2, 2010
Threads
40
5,147
3,088
Next time something similar happens I hope the QLD player pulls up 5 from the line and allows themself to be tackled. Then it won't get called back, play on.

Genius, it's the only way to escape a video ref referral.
 
Super Freak

Super Freak

International Captain
Forum Staff
Jan 25, 2014
Threads
1,064
31,387
18,890
Well, it appears I was wrong.

I've been watching the replay and slowed it down to frame by frame, and Myles does touch it. It's clear as day on the picture I'm looking at.

The no try ruling is correct, but it should have been QLD's ball.

I can't add it because once again, BHQ won't work in my browser. When I can, I will.
 
Last edited:

Tipping Ladder

  • tommy
    71.00 pts

    tommy

    • Correct picks
      71 out of 96
  • Waynesaurus
    69.00 pts

    Waynesaurus

    • Correct picks
      69 out of 96
  • morethenjack
    66.00 pts

    morethenjack

    • Correct picks
      66 out of 96
  • ivanhungryjak
    65.00 pts

    ivanhungryjak

    • Correct picks
      65 out of 96
  • RolledOates
    65.00 pts

    RolledOates

    • Correct picks
      65 out of 96

Forum statistics

Threads
19,341
Messages
1,223,540
Members
1,645
Latest member
Cobbo01

Members online

  • MrMoore
  • lynx000
  • Aldo
  • Morkel
  • GKDonkey
  • jarro65
  • pagey
  • Strop
  • Hurrijo
  • ChewThePhatt
  • Manofoneway
  • LockyersLeftBoot
  • McHunt
  • Astro
  • Culhwch
  • Morepudding
  • riptaker
  • rnabokov
  • easybreezy
  • Dash
... and 14 more.
Team P W L PD Pts
12 11 1 216 22
12 9 3 189 18
12 8 4 134 16
12 8 4 63 16
12 7 5 53 14
11 7 4 48 14
12 7 5 38 14
12 6 6 27 12
11 5 6 -33 10
12 5 7 -60 10
11 5 6 -83 10
12 4 8 -97 8
12 4 8 -140 8
12 3 9 -98 6
12 3 9 -118 6
11 2 9 -139 4
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.