Intrust Super Cup 2018

Broncs_Fan

NRL Player
2,140
842
I have not watched much Q Cup this year - but Redcliffe look really strong in the forwards. Making big metres.
 

1910

State of Origin Rep
7,141
3,806
The Bulldogs won the NSW Cup and I don't see Redcliffe getting within 20 points of them.
You’re just basing that on number of NRL games because Dogs weren’t that great today.

They beat the Jets with a comeback and a controversial try and played alright.
 

1910

State of Origin Rep
7,141
3,806
Thought the Tigers just weren’t smart today, every time they seemed to be getting a move on they’d commit a stupid error. Big Sam was guilty of it over and over again. Losing your hooker and half doesn’t help but gee they failed to get a chance to play.

Dolphins will have to stop Harper, he was sensational. 196m of just blistering running.

Woolford was strong too, beautiful pass.
 
Last edited:

Morkel

International Captain
20,416
16,649
You’re just basing that on number of NRL games because Dogs weren’t that great today.

They beat the Jets with a comeback and a controversial try and played alright.
Aren't you the guy who claimed a defeat of the Devils was a defeat of an "NRL side" because of the number of ex-NRL players they had? You can't pick & choose where your logic applies.
 

1910

State of Origin Rep
7,141
3,806
Aren't you the guy who claimed a defeat of the Devils was a defeat of an "NRL side" because of the number of ex-NRL players they had? You can't pick & choose where your logic applies.
Devils would be lucky to have one NRL game. Not too sure what you mean there. Makes no sense.

In fact whole post makes no sense.

My point was assuming the Bulldogs will beat the Dolphins by 20 as he claimed just because they have NRL players isn’t right.

Pride were $5,50 to beat Penrith in 2014 and Pride won and that was nothing but a NRL head count by the bookies.

As I said Bulldogs only just won yesterday so it’s not like they won their Final by 60.

So yeah Bulldogs can have 500 NRL games but if Redcliffe aren’t stupid over the next 48 hours they can win.

It’s 2/2 in the four games and every year we hear the NSW team has 600 NRL games so they’ll win by 50.
 
Last edited:

Morkel

International Captain
20,416
16,649
Devils would be lucky to have one NRL game. Not too sure what you mean there. Makes no sense.

In fact whole post makes no sense.

My point was assuming the Bulldogs will beat the Dolphins by 20 as he claimed just because they have NRL players isn’t right.

Pride were $5,50 to beat Penrith in 2014 and Pride won and that was nothing but a NRL head count by the bookies.

As I said Bulldogs only just won yesterday so it’s not like they won their Final by 60.

So yeah Bulldogs can have 500 NRL games but if Redcliffe aren’t stupid over the next 48 hours they can win.

It’s 2/2 in the four games and every year we hear the NSW team has 600 NRL games so they’ll win by 50.
I’m talking about a couple of years ago when you were celebrating a Jets win over, in your words, “an NRL team”. Simply because of the number of NRL depth or has-been players. Maybe it was the Pride. Whoever is the team that takes the Cowboys depth.
 

1910

State of Origin Rep
7,141
3,806
I’m talking about a couple of years ago when you were celebrating a Jets win over, in your words, “an NRL team”. Simply because of the number of NRL depth or has-been players. Maybe it was the Pride. Whoever is the team that takes the Cowboys depth.
Jets beat the Blackhawks and the Blackhawks had 500 NRL games.

I still don’t see the relevance to me thinking the Dogs aren’t locked in for a big win.

Dolphins has 70 NRL games yesterday and Easts 411. Easts lost.
 
Last edited:

Morkel

International Captain
20,416
16,649
Jets beat the Blackhawks and the Blackhawks had 500 NRL games.

I still don’t see the relevance to me thinking the Dogs aren’t locked in for a big win.

Dolphins has 70 NRL games yesterday and Easts 411. Easts lost.
So... you accused a poster of ignorance for rating a team because of how many NRL games between them (even though you don’t actually know if that’s the main reason. Yet you used that exact same qualification to talk up a Jets’ victory? Sounds a bit hypocritical to me.
 

1910

State of Origin Rep
7,141
3,806
So... you accused a poster of ignorance for rating a team because of how many NRL games between them (even though you don’t actually know if that’s the main reason. Yet you used that exact same qualification to talk up a Jets’ victory? Sounds a bit hypocritical to me.
I fail to see how you arrive at that. It’s fairly simple.

NRL games don’t equal 20 point win. But if Dolphins do win it’s still a great win over all those NRL players when they only have 70.

Those two thoughts aren’t even close to contradicting each other.

Or

Can Smith doesn’t equal automatic win by 20 but if Roosters win it’s a great win over a team with Cam Smith.
 

1910

State of Origin Rep
7,141
3,806
Redcliffe Dolphins v Canturbury Bulldogs at ANZ Stadium on Sunday, September 30 - 3.40pm
Watch live on Channel 9
Redcliffe Dolphins
1. Trai Fuller 2. Josh Beehag 3. Kotoni Staggs 4. Tom Opacic 5. Jeremy Hawkins 6. Bryce Donovan 7. Cameron Cullen (C) 16. Nathan Watts 9. Jake Turpin 10. Sam Anderson 14. Myles Taueli 11. Toby Rudolf 13. Jamil Hopoate 8. Nick Slyney 12. Aaron Whitchurch 15. James Taylor 17. Hugh Pratt 19. Scott Schulte 22. Tom Geraghty
Coach: Adam Mogg
Canterbury Bankstown Bulldogs
1. Mason Cerruto 2. Joshua Bergamin 3. Morgan Harper 4. John Olive 5. Jayden Okunbor 6. Josh Cleeland 7. Fa'amanu Brown 8. Renouf To'omaga 9. Zac Woolford 10. Francis Tualau 11. Ofahiki Ogden 12. Rhyse Martin (c) 13. Greg Eastwood 14. Bronson Garlick 15. Lachlan Burr 16. Jack Nelson 17. Chris Smith 19. Zac Cardassilaris 20. Brandon Wakeham 21. Jesse Martin 22. D'Rhys Miller
Coach: Steve Georgallis
 

1910

State of Origin Rep
7,141
3,806
Canavan to admin at Newcastle.
Woolfe from Blackhawks to Newcastle.
MOTM in the Colts GF Watene to Newcastle.
 

johnny plath

QCup Player
266
182
Apart from Ryse Martin, and an ageing Greg Eastwood, the Bulldogs NRL players are in the main bit part fill ins, much like most of the Redcliffe NRL players. To me I don't see much difference in quality, but I feel like the NSW clubs get an advantage by being the same club as their NRL team. This means that their systems are consistent, and players I guess in theory spend a lot more time working together. On the other hand the QRL are feeders with a mix of NRL players spread, so the NRL player pre-seasons are separate to their Intrust cup team, and players spend the majority of the week with their NRL club and generally only turn up at Intrust for the captains run.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create free account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Login or Register

Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Register now

Twitter

Top