Minute Silence

Nashy

Nashy

Immortal
Senior Staff
Mar 5, 2008
52,959
32,763
Unlike most people, I have no issue with those wankers making noise during the minute silence for Ron Clarke, a guy I didn't know existed until yesterday.

I don't understand this moment silence in sporting events. I get it, have a moment to reflect, then get on with the match.

I believe it is too much to ask of that many people to sit there for 60 seconds, before a game like that, plenty of them would have been pissed already, and 99% would have just wanted things to get under way.

I think the 10 - 15 seconds where it was silent is more than enough.
 
Super Freak

Super Freak

International Captain
Forum Staff
Jan 25, 2014
42,102
31,240
Maybe they should change it.

Instead of staying silent for one minute, you applaud for one minute.

Or would that be insensitive?
 
Morkel

Morkel

International Captain
Contributor
Jan 25, 2013
25,420
29,386
Unlike most people, I have no issue with those wankers making noise during the minute silence for Ron Clarke, a guy I didn't know existed until yesterday.

I don't understand this moment silence in sporting events. I get it, have a moment to reflect, then get on with the match.

I believe it is too much to ask of that many people to sit there for 60 seconds, before a game like that, plenty of them would have been pissed already, and 99% would have just wanted things to get under way.

I think the 10 - 15 seconds where it was silent is more than enough.

That's the whole point IMO. If you want to only do something that is no effort, what's the point? Making it a minute makes it so that the effort of going (even just slightly) out of your way shows a modicum of respect.
 
Kaz

Kaz

State of Origin Captain
Mar 5, 2008
9,668
3,193
Unlike most people, I have no issue with those wankers making noise during the minute silence for Ron Clarke


Whether you have heard of the person or not, people should show some respect.
 
S

subsbligh

NRL Captain
Mar 16, 2008
3,270
857
Just STFU for a minute you idiot.

It's not funny, it doesn't make you an Aussie larakin, it's just ignorant and shows you've got no class or respect for your elders.

Oh look, Diesel got pissed at the footy and yelled during the minutes silence haw haw that guys epic man. Who the ****'s this old **** on the big screen anyway... QLDDDEERR.
 
Nashy

Nashy

Immortal
Senior Staff
Mar 5, 2008
52,959
32,763
Excuse me? Don't you speak to me like that when I'm putting my opinion forward.
 
Nashy

Nashy

Immortal
Senior Staff
Mar 5, 2008
52,959
32,763
That's the whole point IMO. If you want to only do something that is no effort, what's the point? Making it a minute makes it so that the effort of going (even just slightly) out of your way shows a modicum of respect.

That's fair enough. But it seemed quite a long time compared to what a moment silence usually is when it comes to the sporting arena. I guess I'm just not overly concerned that they wanted to get on with things.

In no way does that say I condone it, or would do it myself. I'm surprised anyone could do it, knowing those around them would look down to them and judge them for being dickbags.

Whether you have heard of the person or not, people should show some respect.

I agree. I'm just trying to give a reason as to why they did it.
 
Charmamba

Charmamba

Life is a Fantasy League
Jan 9, 2011
8,348
952
You can't hype the crowd right up and then expect them to switch and shut up, let them cheer for the guy and show their respect for his life with joy and passion.
 
Alec

Alec

International Rep
Mar 4, 2008
19,336
12,384
I know no one has heard of this guy and it's not the best time to do it in (or the best place. Victoria, am I right Australia?). But just don't make noise for 1 minute, bottle up that excitement and then explode once it's over.
 
Ari Gold

Ari Gold

Master Baiter
Contributor
Mar 13, 2008
6,522
2,807
Excuse me? Don't you speak to me like that when I'm putting my opinion forward.

Could be wrong but I thought subslight's post was a rant aimed at the people who yelled at the game, not you.

On topic, I think a minute's silence is respectful when it's to mark a tragic event like the Lindt Cafe bombings but in general I think for sportsmen and women a round of applause is much more fitting. It's what you do when they achieve great sporting feats, and that's kind of what their life was, a magnificent achievement in sport.
 
noisetheory

noisetheory

NRL Captain
Mar 31, 2008
4,084
1,079
does anyone know if the noise came from in the stands, or were they out the back at the bar and didnt realise the minute silence was on? the sound was kind of echo'y, it sounded like the mics pic'd up some people out the back.

i dunno, just looking at benefit of the doubt here.

if you intentionally make noise during a 1 min silence you're a deadset moron and that is that. even if you don't know the guy. does it matter? are you seriously saying you CANNOT stay quiet for ONE MINUTE? get over yourselves.
 
Last edited:
Black Philip

Black Philip

State of Origin Captain
Contributor
Mar 5, 2008
9,600
1,303
A minutes silence at any event with pissed up bogans is a bad idea.

On topic, I think a minute's silence is respectful when it's to mark a tragic event like the Lindt Cafe bombings but in general I think for sportsmen and women a round of applause is much more fitting. It's what you do when they achieve great sporting feats, and that's kind of what their life was, a magnificent achievement in sport.

I agree with this, it's a great idea. We should be celebrating their life, not mourning.
 
noisetheory

noisetheory

NRL Captain
Mar 31, 2008
4,084
1,079
^ i do agree with a minute of noise when its celebrating someones achievements/etc
 
vertigo

vertigo

State of Origin Rep
Mar 2, 2010
6,281
4,344
You have to either be a complete deadshit or pissed off your face to yell out during these kinds of things, to throw away whatever dignity, self respect, respect of others around you just to be heard when everyone else is showing respect to a dead man shows a completely lack of emotional intelligence.

If you ever hear someone near you do it, push them off their seat and get them kicked out for being a drunk bogan.
 
Last edited:
Fozz

Fozz

International Captain
Senior Staff
Mar 4, 2008
26,759
16,666
It's a minute out of your life to shut up and pay tribute to the life of a person. Just shut up.

That being said, organisers should keep the type of event in mind. Not sure why Ron Clarke needed to be honoured at rugby league game unless it was on the GC.
 

Unread

Active Now

  • Bucking Beads
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.