CROSS FORUM NRL 2022 Round 15 Discussion

[Kimlo]

WTF

 

[Midean]

Wow, thats an amazing 10 minutes of footy by the Cowboys.

 

[Foordy]

Manly have fallen apart after the BS bunker call

 

[Fernando]

Holmes is so good to watch in space

 

[Dash]

Robson's try was fair. There's no such thing as having to run 10m, the referee just mis-spoke. Robson was more than 10m from the catch (and was "passive" anyway), and was put onside by Nanai catching the ball.

 

[NZWarriors.com]

[st_table="45%"][st_tr][st_td_row="2"]

[/st_td_row][st_td]drunk_monk - nzwarriors.com[/st_td][/st_tr][st_tr][st_td="0.7"]JOINED: .May 15, 2014
MESSAGES: 1,942
REACTIONS: 2,597[/st_td][/st_tr][/st_table]

---

Fucking what a banger of a finish.

10 minutes to go and down by 14. Cowboys didn't look like they were gonna score then BAM BAM BAM.

---

 

[Foordy]

speaking of shit refs ... there was a farcical situation in the Cowboys game where Sutton called for a Cowboys Captains challenge then had to reverse himself because the Cowboys captain Chad Townsend didn't actually call for or want a captains challenge

‘That is not how it works’: Townsend blows up as referee left red faced by captain’s challenge

‘Not how it works’: Townsend fumes as referee left red-faced by captain’s challenge

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[tommy]

speaking of shit refs ... there was a farcical situation in the Cowboys game where Sutton called for a Cowboys Captains challenge then had to reverse himself because the Cowboys captain Chad Townsend didn't actually call for or want a captains challenge

‘That is not how it works’: Townsend blows up as referee left red faced by captain’s challenge

‘Not how it works’: Townsend fumes as referee left red-faced by captain’s challenge

www.foxsports.com.au

Hardly farcical, the link you posted explains it pretty clearly.

 

[Super Freak]

Robson's try was fair. There's no such thing as having to run 10m, the referee just mis-spoke. Robson was more than 10m from the catch (and was "passive" anyway), and was put onside by Nanai catching the ball.

Remember when Gillett was pinged for being offside in Game 3 2015 and Inglis had to go 10 metres before he was able to get involved?

Nanai catching the ball doesn't put Robson onside. Only way that does is if Nanai was the one that kicked the ball. There have been a lot of tries denied over the years when an offside player receives a pass from a player that caught the ball despite being more than 10 metres away from when the ball was caught.

Players are only passive if they don't have an influence on the game. He scored the try.

It was a rubbish call.

 

[Dash]

Remember when Gillett was pinged for being offside in Game 3 2015 and Inglis had to go 10 metres before he was able to get involved?

Nanai catching the ball doesn't put Robson onside. There have been a lot of tries denied over the years when an offside player receives a pass from a player that caught the ball.

Players are only passive if they don't have an influence on the game. He scored the try.

It was a rubbish call.

Robson was outside 10m anyway, so he was onside.

 

[Super Freak]

Robson was outside 10m anyway, so he was onside.

So was Gillett. It doesn't matter, he's still offside. You can't encroach within 10 metres of the play from an offside position, but you're still offside even if you are.

 

[Foordy]

Robson was outside 10m anyway, so he was onside.

but in front of the kicker ... and only the kicker can run him back on side.

being outside the 10m would only have come into it if Manly had got the ball

 

[Super Freak]

Hardly farcical, the link you posted explains it pretty clearly.

It still kind of is. Surely the ref refers to the captain before making the call. It's not like he doesn't know who the captain is, he speaks to them before the game.

It wasn't a good look.

 

[tommy]

It still kind of is. Surely the ref refers to the captain before making the call. It's not like he doesn't know who the captain is, he speaks to them before the game.

It wasn't a good look.

Read the article. He thought Tom Dearden was Townsend.

 

[Dash]

but in front of the kicker ... and only the kicker can run him back on side.

being outside the 10m would only have come into it if Manly had got the ball

They have always ruled it that way. If you are 10m from the 'contest' and your team regathers the ball you can join in the play.

 

[Dash]

Also here's the kicker (Red) running him onside (Green).

 

[Super Freak]

Read the article. He thought Tom Dearden was Townsend.

Yeah I know, I watched the game.

Not sure how that makes it less farcical.

 

[tommy]

Yeah I know, I watched the game.

Not sure how that makes it less farcical.

Farcical
adjective

relating to or resembling farce, especially because of absurd or ridiculous aspects.
"he considered the whole idea farcical"


are you sure you aren’t being:

hysterical
adjective
1.
affected by or deriving from wildly uncontrolled emotion.
"Janet became hysterical and began screaming"