PRE-GAME Round 12 - Broncos vs Sharks

Can i play devils advocate for a sec; why is Fifita allowed to come back?

He is no longer our future; we should be playing someone who is instead..?

The kids mentally soft, he now becomes a magnet for more fan-fuelled hate with every loss..?
Because he signed a 3yr deal not 10. And if he turns out to be as good as what most people think, we will want him back.
Or you can act like a 3 year old and never see him again.
 
Because he signed a 3yr deal not 10. And if he turns out to be as good as what most people think, we will want him back.
Or you can act like a 3 year old and never see him again.

Why would we want him back? The team needs him now, his mates need him now. If we are better in 3 years why should we welcome him back, what does that say to the players that stayed and helped out the club?
 
I dunno, how do you feel about Hodges?
This is the perfect example.

I hated the idea of Hodges coming back, absolutely hated it.
Then he became the heart and soul of the team post Lockyer. But he had to earn it, and earn it he did.

Thus, same treatment for Fifita I think; dropped to reserve grade even if he’s fit or not, and even if there is a reserve grade comp or not.

If he gets to the other side and the grass isn’t greener, he will come back and try extra hard to deliver. If he doesn’t, well he wasn’t supposed to be here anyway.
 
Bennett would banish Fifita as he did to Hodgo when he signed with the Roosters. The team needs 100% commitment now but Seibold is trying to save his own career so he'll play him.
 
If we have any sense of self-worth, David should not play again this year. There is no point. This year is a complete right off, and we are depriving players of valuable first-grade experience that no matter how poor the results, will serve them well next year. I don't even care if we lose every game for the rest of the year. I want to see which players are putting in.
As a fan seeing Dave run around in the club's colours again will make me angry, not at him, but at the club.
Move forward, and don't play him. It worked for Hodges, and the whole time he was away he just wanted to come home.
As a fan I will gain no joy in seeing Fifita contributing to us winning games this year. If we play him, we are saying we value you (even though you've left us) more than we do our future. No way.
Like I said I'm not angry at Dave (who could turn that down) I'm annoyed at the club. I want them to show some backbone and confidence.
 
Why would we want him back? The team needs him now, his mates need him now. If we are better in 3 years why should we welcome him back, what does that say to the players that stayed and helped out the club?

You'd like the Walkers their rule is you can leave for money at Dolphins but you're never welcome back. They built a culture of improvement and we aren't going to improve you and then you leave for money. They stuck to it and had players want to come back and they said no you're great but you can't come back.
 
Can i play devils advocate for a sec; why is Fifita allowed to come back?

He is no longer our future; we should be playing someone who is instead..?

The kids mentally soft, he now becomes a magnet for more fan-fuelled hate with every loss..?
He's playing because Fat Tony said the Broncos can still reach the finals, at least mathematically. If it's possible he will field his strongest team. When we can no longer do so Fifita will have time off, he may even have knee 'soreness'. It's a possibility that DB will get a few weeks off too but he'll likely play the final game. He may even play all nine, who knows?
 
So what team are we expecting?

1. Boyd
2. Farnworth
3. Kennar (Arthars if fit)
4. Staggs
5. Coates
6. Croft
7. Dearden
8. Flegler
9. Turpin
10. Haas
11. Pangai Jr
12. Fifita
13. Carrigan

14. Paix
15. Te'o
16. Ofahengaue
17. Kennedy (Lodge if fit)

Something like that. I don't see Luke pushing out Paix to be honest, if he does, Seibold has officially lost the fucking plot.
 
I don't see Luke pushing out Paix to be honest, if he does, Seibold has officially lost the fucking plot.
Seibold loves his own signings. Won't be shocked if Luke plays.

Edit: Just saw this on foxsports early team picks
Tips: The Broncos are scheduled to welcome back star back-rower and Titans signing David Fifita from a knee injury in Round 12. With Anthony Milford struggling with a knee injury, Darius Boyd trained at fullback on Monday. Jake Turpin (leg) and Issac Luke (suspension) are also scheduled to return, with Cory Paix set to miss out after some admirable performances in a struggling side. Matt Lodge faces a longer spell out after tearing a meniscus.
 
Last edited:
I actually don't hate the idea of Boyd moving to fullback. He looks to be a little bit more confident in his own body then he was last year at fullback, maybe - just maybe, he will make some try saving tackles.
 
You'd like the Walkers their rule is you can leave for money at Dolphins but you're never welcome back. They built a culture of improvement and we aren't going to improve you and then you leave for money. They stuck to it and had players want to come back and they said no you're great but you can't come back.

This is what we need to do.
 
You'd like the Walkers their rule is you can leave for money at Dolphins but you're never welcome back. They built a culture of improvement and we aren't going to improve you and then you leave for money. They stuck to it and had players want to come back and they said no you're great but you can't come back.
Is there a particular reason why they’ve never been considered? I’d assume we would have a fair crack at getting Sam walker as well.
 
I actually don't hate the idea of Boyd moving to fullback. He looks to be a little bit more confident in his own body then he was last year at fullback, maybe - just maybe, he will make some try saving tackles.

I’d be pretty excited if Boyd puts the winger over with the sweep play. Just for old times sake when we actually scored points.
 

Unread

Active Now

  • Broncosgirl
  • Justwin
  • Locky24
  • Xzei
  • broncsgoat
  • sooticus
  • Financeguy
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.