tommy
International Rep
- Jun 5, 2015
- 12,894
- 13,712
Maybe he just needs other genuine spine players in the proper position.
T
Thelmus
NRL Player
- Apr 19, 2016
- 1,778
- 2,318
If no one else is available, could seguaro play in the halves? He seems switched on in attack, has some pace and whilst soft in defence, is no worse than some others we put there.
I'm not sure how we prepared for this game but I think there is a consensus that whatever we did, DONT DO IT AGAIN!
I'm not sure how we prepared for this game but I think there is a consensus that whatever we did, DONT DO IT AGAIN!
Art Vandelay
QCup Player
- Jun 5, 2013
- 924
- 794
It does.
winslow_wong
International Captain
- May 27, 2013
- 23,666
- 22,491
Segeyaros strength is his speed out of dummy half. Please do not take his powers away from him.
Art Vandelay
QCup Player
- Jun 5, 2013
- 924
- 794
Seibold just said Turpin is probably going to stay at 7 for the rest of the year.
KnToad
NRL Player
- Apr 14, 2013
- 1,682
- 2,000
Yeh maybe but he should have secured the ball better and made sure of it.
If you watch the replay closely I noticed he was running it with the ball swaying in his arm and not really being held firmly.
It’s the small things that separate the guys who rarely drop or lose the ball under pressure and the next level down players who seem to come up with it most weeks.
I don’t hate him like some, I think his defense was really good but when he runs the ball I cringe
Super Freak
International Captain
Forum Staff
- Jan 25, 2014
- 44,119
- 33,257
If Shibasaki could just hold the fucking ball then I wouldn't mind having him in the team.
Defensively, he is quite solid. One thing I noticed tonight was his first contact was usually quite good. But his hands, they are a fucking let down.
Defensively, he is quite solid. One thing I noticed tonight was his first contact was usually quite good. But his hands, they are a fucking let down.
Horseheadsup
NRL Player
- Mar 21, 2016
- 2,674
- 1,369
Yeah, just heard that.
Art Vandelay
QCup Player
- Jun 5, 2013
- 924
- 794
His acceleration is insane. It's why it's best utilised from dummy half, when everyone is stationary. At half he would get the ball with everyone in motion which mutes that advantage too much. I don't even think his top speed is that good, he can just reach it over a shorter distance than anyone else on the field.
Broncapz
NRL Player
- May 1, 2016
- 2,981
- 7,002
Broncos didn't deserve the win....BUT Josh 'Gouge' McGuire deserved that LOSS
I bleed Maroon
International Rep
- Apr 17, 2013
- 15,861
- 20,677
That doesn't fill me with much confidence on the condition of Dearden and SOS. They must be pretty much done for the year.
R
Rookie Alan
QCup Player
- Apr 9, 2019
- 272
- 275
Tbh, this season qld all three teams really shit and don’t deserve the final, I still remember preseason everyone is looking forward to three teams making the top 8, now it’s the biggest joke!
I get it that Seibold doesn’t want to change any crew from the side losing to Storms, but this lucky win doesn’t prove anything, don’t care if it’s derby, it is dreadful!!!
1, Milford 7/10
He’s wearing no 1, but still carrying the whole team as our 6&7 are no half material, just based on that, I give him a 7.
2, Oates 5/10
He seems lost his appetite for try ever since Boyd switch the position, nothing really challenges his defense except one high ball and he didn’t fail, good for him, he’s a bit like Gagai now but he’s even worse than Gagai.
3, Staggs 6/10
One impressive stupid error after Milford’s good catch, works very hard, might need a bit luck.
18, Shitsucky 2/10
Butter hands! And that ***** up his plays!
5, Isaako 6.5/10
The miss penalty goal needs more practice
6, Boyd 4.5/10
Really eagaging with tackles, although only 1 run for 1m, that’s a bit funny. Maybe he’s practicing his center position for next game?
7, Turpin 7.5/10
Match winner! If he’s playing hooker, I’d give him 9/10, but he’s not a game organizer and he doesn’t have the half view. I’m still a bit nervous for some of his pass looks going forward.
8, Lodge 6/10
Clock in clock out
9, Macca 6/10
That one line break certainly light up, but his hooker position is definitely Turpin’s!
10, Haas 7/10
Control the feeling control the stupid errors!
11, Fifita 7/10
He’s totally different player from Lexi, the difference we call talent!
12, TPJ 6.5/10
Offload machine, and our top 1 back rower forward! Keep the aggression but drop the stupid error or penalties
13, Jofa 6/10
Clock in clock out
14, Segeyaro 6.5/10
Limited time but his appearance totally change the game.
15, Flegler 5/10
Very impressive stupid carry error! He had two last time when played Cowboys, I don’t know if his background is messing up with him or he’s a bit homesick.
16, Kennedy 5/10
10 mins, nothing fancy nothing stupid
17, Carrigan 5/10
Slight bit more mins than Flegler, but three errors!
I get it that Seibold doesn’t want to change any crew from the side losing to Storms, but this lucky win doesn’t prove anything, don’t care if it’s derby, it is dreadful!!!
1, Milford 7/10
He’s wearing no 1, but still carrying the whole team as our 6&7 are no half material, just based on that, I give him a 7.
2, Oates 5/10
He seems lost his appetite for try ever since Boyd switch the position, nothing really challenges his defense except one high ball and he didn’t fail, good for him, he’s a bit like Gagai now but he’s even worse than Gagai.
3, Staggs 6/10
One impressive stupid error after Milford’s good catch, works very hard, might need a bit luck.
18, Shitsucky 2/10
Butter hands! And that ***** up his plays!
5, Isaako 6.5/10
The miss penalty goal needs more practice
6, Boyd 4.5/10
Really eagaging with tackles, although only 1 run for 1m, that’s a bit funny. Maybe he’s practicing his center position for next game?
7, Turpin 7.5/10
Match winner! If he’s playing hooker, I’d give him 9/10, but he’s not a game organizer and he doesn’t have the half view. I’m still a bit nervous for some of his pass looks going forward.
8, Lodge 6/10
Clock in clock out
9, Macca 6/10
That one line break certainly light up, but his hooker position is definitely Turpin’s!
10, Haas 7/10
Control the feeling control the stupid errors!
11, Fifita 7/10
He’s totally different player from Lexi, the difference we call talent!
12, TPJ 6.5/10
Offload machine, and our top 1 back rower forward! Keep the aggression but drop the stupid error or penalties
13, Jofa 6/10
Clock in clock out
14, Segeyaro 6.5/10
Limited time but his appearance totally change the game.
15, Flegler 5/10
Very impressive stupid carry error! He had two last time when played Cowboys, I don’t know if his background is messing up with him or he’s a bit homesick.
16, Kennedy 5/10
10 mins, nothing fancy nothing stupid
17, Carrigan 5/10
Slight bit more mins than Flegler, but three errors!
Art Vandelay
QCup Player
- Jun 5, 2013
- 924
- 794
It means McCullough will be starting hooker for at least half of 2020. If he finishes the season without getting dropped his work ethic in the off-season will mean he starts the season at 9 and the grace period restarts.
KnToad
NRL Player
- Apr 14, 2013
- 1,682
- 2,000
I do agree it was a dodgy call and they got lucky. Am I the only one who thought that you could argue Shiba got a smack across the chops in the stripping motion that could have been deemed high?
It didn’t even rate a mention at the time.
Fernando
NRL Captain
- Jun 6, 2015
- 4,103
- 4,479
The spine is such a mess that this is looking more like a write off than a rebuilding year. You’d think during rebuild you’d be getting the spine set for the following year but we don’t know what it’ll be. Could well feature Mccullough and Boyd.
W
WASSHHH
Guest
- Aug 24, 2017
- 4,083
- 10,248
Seems most have already said what needs to be said. Cringeworthy, makes you almost want to scratch your own eyes out stuff from both teams.
But outside the obvious, my question is; why, for 2 weeks straight, has Milford, in our first attacking set, put up a towering bomb that the fullback / winger has either wanted nothing to do with or dropped it cold, only to then not do it again for the remaining 70 odd minutes?
The fact Boyd cannot and will not kick means the defence knows, without a doubt, to rush Turpin as you can almost bet your house on him kicking on the last.
It seems obvious, but we really need another kicking option, and Milford is there, so I don’t know why he can’t at least do more - especially as he has such a lethal bomb.
But outside the obvious, my question is; why, for 2 weeks straight, has Milford, in our first attacking set, put up a towering bomb that the fullback / winger has either wanted nothing to do with or dropped it cold, only to then not do it again for the remaining 70 odd minutes?
The fact Boyd cannot and will not kick means the defence knows, without a doubt, to rush Turpin as you can almost bet your house on him kicking on the last.
It seems obvious, but we really need another kicking option, and Milford is there, so I don’t know why he can’t at least do more - especially as he has such a lethal bomb.
Xzei
State of Origin Rep
- Mar 13, 2017
- 6,787
- 10,493
Only good thing to take from that game was cowboy tears.
NSW stables
NRL Player
- May 3, 2019
- 2,607
- 6,989
I dont get it. We threw inside balls to fifita twice. Once he scores and the other he looked like he almost broke the line and had an arm free. That Guy is a fucking weapon and we hardly use him. I wouldnt blame him if he went to melbourne, that would definitely utilise him better than we do.
