Round 22 Discussion

[Super Freak]

If Panthers went right they would have scored.

 

[JayPee]

Panthers getting rorted here.

I can understand May's no try but that Peachey one was a dead set try. Eisenhuth wasn't impeded at all.

It was about the same as the one you were telling me was a no try last night. Don't get caught standing in the line

 

[Super Freak]

Peachey gets it this time.

That should have been his second.

 

[Super Freak]

It was about the same as the one you were telling me was a no try last night. Don't get caught standing in the line

Wasn't even close to being the same...

 

[JayPee]

Wasn't even close to being the same...

It was exactly the same lol a bloke that overruns the play and then gets caught in the way. How isn't it any different? Eisunhuth sells it the same way Austin did except he fell over. They both could have made the tackle. It's how it is if people want a black and white rule

 

[JayPee]

Why do people make Lolohea go into jungle ball? That is his strength. Just let him kick it. Putting pressure on him to make it into a scramble play is just silly

 

[Big Pete]

The first half has been Penrith to a tee. They've easily been the better side this afternoon, but their attention to detail and execution has let them down. To give away three penalties while in possession is just poor and they've given the Tigers a sniff they shouldn't have.

Penrith maybe infront, but they have to be mindful that one of their tries came off a Tigers mistake. Wests have actually created two tries, Penrith only one. I think Penrith will run away with it in the second half, but they need to show more commitment on the field.

 

[Lockysillegitimatechild]

I don't watch many Penrith games but Nathan Cleary is a talent and a half, classy passing game.... on a side note, if the tigers get within 10 points of the panthers it showcases what a mistake it was to sack Ivan Cleary for griffin

 

[badyon]

Lol Manly are gone.

Roosters scoring at will here.

That'll do me.

 

[Horseheadsup]

Poor defence panthers.

 

[Sproj]

Wow Brooks went through the field like there was no one on the field the hole was that big.

 

[Sproj]

Campbell- Gillard penalised for swinging his arms like a bird?

 

[Horseheadsup]

Wow Brooks went through the field like there was no one on the field the hole was that big.

I really don't think the Panthers are all that.

 

[Super Freak]

It was exactly the same lol a bloke that overruns the play and then gets caught in the way. How isn't it any different? Eisunhuth sells it the same way Austin did except he fell over. They both could have made the tackle. It's how it is if people want a black and white rule

Well for starters, Graham ran into Austin and initiates the contact and Ricky runs behind him..

Peachey doesn't run behind Wallace who doesn't make any contact with Eisenhuth, who actually had the chance to get Peachey had he focused on the tackle and not stuck the arm out to milk a penalty. Wallace wasn't actually directly in Eisenhuth's line.

If anything, Eisenhuth initiated the contact by sticking the arm out to make contact with Wallace.

Please tell me how they are the same.

 

[Big Pete]

Penrith have to put the Tigers away here...

 

[JayPee]

Well for starters, Graham ran into Austin and initiates the contact and Ricky runs behind him..

Peachey doesn't run behind Wallace who doesn't make any contact with Eisenhuth, who actually had the chance to get Peachey had he focused on the tackle and not stuck the arm out to milk a penalty. Wallace wasn't actually directly in Eisenhuth's line.

Please tell me how they are the same.

Lol he didn't initiate shit. He overran the ball and then just submitted and Austin ran into him to get the obstruction. Just how Wallace got into the line and just stood there. Which is the rule. Exactly the same. I am happy to give them both tries but they are exactly the same.

 

[Super Freak]

Lol he didn't initiate shit. He overran the ball and then just submitted and Austin ran into him to get the obstruction. Just how Wallace got into the line and just stood there. Which is the rule. Exactly the same. I am happy to give them both tries but they are exactly the same.

He didn't initiate the contact by running straight into Austin?

You need glasses mate.

 

[JayPee]

Wallace diving for a penalty. Nicely done