POST GAME [Round 25, 2022] Broncos vs Dragons

[Sproj]

I haven't rewatched it, was a defender touching him?

Yep.

 

[Battler]

That was not a poor performance by any stretch from walters. He one of the best on ground tonight.

So we’re all sorted in the Hooking department for next season then?

I do agree that Walters has been ok this season, and probably our best option at nine atm, but that just highlights the issues we have at hooker.

 

[Morkel]

I can't agree with it, the Flegler one especially was the Hetherington situation all over again where a player gets absolutely folded and drastically changes his body position. I could accept a penalty, but a sin-bin in that situation is a joke.

Just like the Hetherington send off was a joke last year.

At least the MRC had enough common sense not to charge either of them.

I get it, but the stance has been that there are zero extenuating circumstances that can be used as an excuse. Incidental contact is still a penalty. Incidental contact with force is a binning.

Unless you play for a certain club of course.

 

[Big Pete]

I get it, but the stance has been that there are zero extenuating circumstances that can be used as an excuse. Incidental contact is still a penalty. Incidental contact with force is a binning.

Unless you play for a certain club of course.

They really need to review it.

There was obviously some mitigating factors there and while I can live with a penalty in that situation it's an interpretation that actively hurts their product. The game wants to promote big hits, but in situations like that they throw the book at the player. It's the Hetherington situation all over again where the guy trips into the shoulder and Kobe gets sent off.

Neither tackle was even worth a fine that really says it all.

 

[Manofoneway]

So we’re all sorted in the Hooking department for next season then?

I do agree that Walters has been ok this season, and probably our best option at nine atm, but that just highlights the issues we have at hooker.

Well we aren't but I don't know who they get. They don't have the cap space for a decent one and to be fair on billy, we get our moneys worth out of his minimum wage deal...

 

[Johnny92]

Maybe your mate Herbs is the real glue of the team.

He makes a massive difference, he's more important to the team then Kotoni.

 

[_wwong]

Yep.

So basically we should have lost 24-0

 

[Super Freak]

My avatar sums up our run home to the finals.

Pretty perfectly, actually. We're Gutho. Pereira is the finals.

 

[Sproj]

So basically we should have lost 24-0

Haha - yep.

 

[rnabokov]

I wonder if Reynolds was both injured and medicated. His game has been off for weeks now.
I also had this feeling that Patty was hiding something in his interview. I just have this sense of conflict within the team and coaching staff. Still can't get my head around the suddenness of the calamitous change from Rd 20.

 

[LittleDavey]

Literally like a switch was flicked.

Last year we built and there was some real green shoots towards the end of the year. This year we had a rough start but built into the season and finally were seeing some confidence. So, what happened. We can all see something has - you don't forget how to play a game you've been playing your entire life, in a week. You don't suddenly forget the structures and plays which have been working for you all season. You don't suddenly forget how to fucking tackle.

Something went wrong, and the club has to be aware of what that is. It has to be sorted immediately before pre-season.

 

[_wwong]

Literally like a switch was flicked.

Last year we built and there was some real green shoots towards the end of the year. This year we had a rough start but built into the season and finally were seeing some confidence. So, what happened. We can all see something has - you don't forget how to play a game you've been playing your entire life, in a week. You don't suddenly forget the structures and plays which have been working for you all season. You don't suddenly forget how to fucking tackle.

Something went wrong, and the club has to be aware of what that is. It has to be sorted immediately before pre-season.

After our best win against the eels something went sour. Teams usually build off that type of win but we fell off a cliff.

 

[I bleed Maroon]

Literally like a switch was flicked.

Last year we built and there was some real green shoots towards the end of the year. This year we had a rough start but built into the season and finally were seeing some confidence. So, what happened. We can all see something has - you don't forget how to play a game you've been playing your entire life, in a week. You don't suddenly forget the structures and plays which have been working for you all season. You don't suddenly forget how to fucking tackle.

Something went wrong, and the club has to be aware of what that is. It has to be sorted immediately before pre-season.

Lets just speculate for a moment, that the "bad eggs" within the squad are exactly who we think they are. One of them is a simple enough solution, he wants out so let him go (but don't fucking dare cover any of his contract). The other however is a problem. He's signed for another 3 years. If he really wants to intentionally stink it up and sow disorder in the playing group, we have no choice but to dump him to reggies for the rest of his deal.

Once again, more wasted cap space because of piss poor attitude. How hard is it to get a figurehead within the coaching staff who is simply there to rope these wankers massive egos in? Does Gordon Ramsey follow League by any chance?

 

[rnabokov]

After our best win against the eels something went sour. Teams usually build off that type of win but we fell off a cliff.

Well, I revisited our games from Rd. 20. What I saw was our inability to match it with the speed and aggression of the top sides, some really shitty defensive reads under pressure at critical moments by Niu, Mam, Staggs and others, and then the resilience we had built up over this season sagged, more and more as more and more went wrong and then ......... pfft. No confidence, we just gave up.

We are so far behind the 8 ball adapting to the speed, intensity and ferocity of the footie the top sides play consistently well - disciplined and players super fit. That is the challenge I see before us for 2023. A good hooker might help as well.

 

[Johnny92]

Lets just speculate for a moment, that the "bad eggs" within the squad are exactly who we think they are. One of them is a simple enough solution, he wants out so let him go (but don't fucking dare cover any of his contract). The other however is a problem. He's signed for another 3 years. If he really wants to intentionally stink it up and sow disorder in the playing group, we have no choice but to dump him to reggies for the rest of his deal.

Once again, more wasted cap space because of piss poor attitude. How hard is it to get a figurehead within the coaching staff who is simply there to rope these wankers massive egos in? Does Gordon Ramsey follow League by any chance?

Both Blokes a off field incident is always on the cards for them.. both have form and on their last chance with the club you'd think.

 

[Huge]

As this thread is focused on the last game I'm just going to comment about it in isolation.

I believe KW just doesn't support the notion that forwards, especially front rowers if selected should be fully utilised.

I'm gobsmacked by the sheer madness of leaving a prop ( any bench prop ) sitting idly by for almost the entire game.

Eight minutes in to the game we lose Flegler. That straight away tells you that our remaining four forwards have to do extra to cover. Essentially it's now five on four.

I've always seen the game as starting with the forward battle and we were now undermanned. To me it means I now really need the bench forwards to put in a bit longer and my starting prop, Haas not as long a stint.

Haas has always been played too long but it became critical to spell him, not extend his time to cover the extra workload!!

I think that KW butchered the run home. Round 20 onwards was terrible after we won, somewhat against expectation in rounds 17 and 18. Round 19 was a strong win with the bench props getting 30 minutes each. I thought that was better and was optimistic KW would continue to use his gorillas correctly.

Palasia got 30 minutes. Netted 40 lousy metres. RK, 8 minutes. **** me dead that is so dumb. Why bother picking a prop at all, why not anyone from the crowd instead?

Nah. 8 minutes is a big enough contribution.

 

[McHunt]

He makes a massive difference, he's more important to the team then Kotoni.

Unless you're playing outside him. Oates' try scoring rampage went up another gear after Herbie got injured. He scored 4 doubles in five games immediately after Herbie went out.

 

[Sproj]

As this thread is focused on the last game I'm just going to comment about it in isolation.

I believe KW just doesn't support the notion that forwards, especially front rowers if selected should be fully utilised.

I'm gobsmacked by the sheer madness of leaving a prop ( any bench prop ) sitting idly by for almost the entire game.

Eight minutes in to the game we lose Flegler. That straight away tells you that our remaining four forwards have to do extra to cover. Essentially it's now five on four.

I've always seen the game as starting with the forward battle and we were now undermanned. To me it means I now really need the bench forwards to put in a bit longer and my starting prop, Haas not as long a stint.

Haas has always been played too long but it became critical to spell him, not extend his time to cover the extra workload!!

I think that KW butchered the run home. Round 20 onwards was terrible after we won, somewhat against expectation in rounds 17 and 18. Round 19 was a strong win with the bench props getting 30 minutes each. I thought that was better and was optimistic KW would continue to use his gorillas correctly.

Palasia got 30 minutes. Netted 40 lousy metres. RK, 8 minutes. **** me dead that is so dumb. Why bother picking a prop at all, why not anyone from the crowd instead?

Nah. 8 minutes is a big enough contribution.

Yep, his bench use is a massive issue. He started the season awfully in that regard. Mid-season he seemed to be doing ok and then after origin, the stupid bench use rears itself again. I don't get it. I can understand a team / player going backwards due to fatigue, etc but how does a coach go backward?