Fitzy
NRL Captain
- Sep 10, 2018
- 4,837
- 7,112
The point is that he had a good enough pass to play NRL when he was 17, it’s nothing new. He showed last night he was years off first grade. Yet there are people doing team lists for him to be in the side next week or saying he is better than Mozer.Far too many people in here patting themselves on the back by putting others opinions down.
It doesn't validate your opinion or make it right.
I let people go nuts with there Bukowski is better than Mozer rants 95% of the time, despite not even remotely agreeing with it. This is not some I told you so moment this is a can we have an actual discussion about what happened conversation. He will be 21 before seasons end.
I saw more concerns than positives and what I’m saying is that really should be the point of discussion here rather than people jizzing themselves over his pass that could have given a 90 year old man who hasn’t gotten his **** up in 3 decades a stiffy when he was 17. Which has already been well established on here.
He hasn’t really been progressing in q-cup this season (albeit early and Wynnum dreadful), his coach at stages hasn’t had faith in him in reserve grade as well. A nearly 21 year old hooker shouldn’t look that out of his depth in defence and thrown around like a bean bag if he gets caught with the ball. That unfortunately doesn’t come down to nerves. The dropped ball and a couple of twitchy movements off the line, yeah nerves, and I am not remotely concerned or judging his game based off of those things.
Luckily for Cameron he will know that he has stuff to address, and he can now go work on it. But you don’t make up that much of a deficiency in a couple weeks and honestly not in a couple months either. He was a long way off the level required in defence unfortunately. But better for him to know that now, cause that is not as glaringly as obvious a thing in reserve grade at all. Back end of next year start of 28 is really where I see him being at a level to re-introduce to first grade with some opportunities. He has got the taste now, it’s time to go back to work and get to a level that’s required in these areas. And a part of that development is for him simply just filling out and gaining size, 100%.
Madge has shown he doesn’t give two shits about how good your pass is if you cannot get the defence right. Paix is our number one hooker right now. He doesn’t have a running game and his ruck ID and pass is worse than probably all our hookers. Cory’s work rate and defence though is the best in our hooking stocks (Walters is up there as well but probably can’t do it for 80 like Paixy).
You look at hookers that got there opportunities young and or similar ages the last few years. Mozer, De Silva, Pattie, Beni Ioleu, about a year older when he debuted which changes things but even Ryley Smith. Do I think Bukowski compares to them despite playing more reserve grade and having potentially more skills than all of them when getting there chance? I don’t unfortunately and that’s a glaring truth he has to face and go and work and focus on some things. Theres not many hookers at this age getting first grade and there are very few capable of being the complete package. This is by no means a suggestion Bukowski is off track or is a bust. But relative to the blokes that have gotten there goes at his age he’s a bit off the pace.
I think Cam is in a similar position to Coby at the minute. Coby lives off his kicking game in the same way that Cam lives off his passing game. Better than a lot of blokes in first grade at those two things but there games beyond that aren’t up to it. I do believe that Cam has far more dimensions to his game than Coby did in fairness but they both do have one skill that is far and away better than anything else they offer at this point. These are both skills that create a lot of value for teams but that can’t just be it.
But this also becomes two fold in that if the poor bloke had to go out and put one or two more efforts like that in over the next few weeks the lot of you would be off him. I think we need to be a bit more realistic with him is all I’m saying. It may come off as critical but I’m not here to sugar coat. We all know his upside. No point pretending there wasn’t a lot of downside on show tonight and a lot to work on.