VOTE Should Cronk be considered for immortal status?

[Mustafur]

No it would cheapen the award, you don't want too many people from the same generation otherwise it comes a hall of fame.

Lockyer, Smith and maybe Thurston would be a yes, the rest are just not good enough.

 

[Super Freak]

But then 2018 happens, and Cronk and Smith find themselves on the opposite side of the field for the first time, and what happens?
The roosters dispatch the storm both years to take the premiership
Cronk took it to Smith and beat him
So that's an argument to have him in there ahead of Smith, but it's not definitive, just an argument

To be fair, 2018 was all Keary. Cronk literally did nothing.

It's actually 1-0 in between Cronk and Smith. But I don't think that's enough for him to overtake Smith.