VOTE Should the club roll the dice on Tevita Pangai Jr again?

[Broncosgirl]

He's got the brains of one too.

Exactly.

 

[Broncosgirl]

Lol. Who could forget when he advised parents not to make their children do something they don't want to do because this is what happens in the end. lol.

 

[McHunt]

Only if he's willing to drop the SBW/Mundine cohort he calls mates. 1 year cheap deal.

Well neither of those are happening.

I don't know how the NRL would calculate his fair value, given he resigned. It would stink if it looks like the Broncos got him to break his contract and then picked him up the following year for a song. I would have my auditors all over that.

Understanding mid-season player moves

Daniel Anderson explains how the player transfer market works and why players switch team mid-season.

www.nrl.com

 

[Xzei]

Well neither of those are happening.

I don't know how the NRL would calculate his fair value, given he resigned. It would stink if it looks like the Broncos got him to break his contract and then picked him up the following year for a song. I would have my auditors all over that.

Understanding mid-season player moves

Daniel Anderson explains how the player transfer market works and why players switch team mid-season.

www.nrl.com

My understanding is that it would only be for 16 weeks even at his previous contract value that would only just be over 200k for that time

 

[Dash]

He's not even remotely good enough to bother with.

 

[Sproj]

It is probably good to have a positive and negative list. I’ll start:

Positives:
- Can win a game if he feels like it
- Potentially helps fill a weak spot on our list
- Should be only a short term deal

Negatives:
- Has a history of being toxic
- Does not own his own mistakes
- Is temperamental
- When he comes will likely lack match fitness

Feel free to keep building

 

[Xzei]

It is probably good to have a positive and negative list. I’ll start:

Positives:
- Can win a game if he feels like it
- Potentially helps fill a weak spot on our list
- Should be only a short term deal

Negatives:
- Has a history of being toxic
- Does not own his own mistakes
- Is temperamental
- When he comes will likely lack match fitness

Feel free to keep building

The match fitness i dont think will be an issue isnt he looking to play qcup?

 

[BroncsFan]

It is probably good to have a positive and negative list. I’ll start:

Positives:
- Can win a game if he feels like it
- Potentially helps fill a weak spot on our list
- Should be only a short term deal

Negatives:
- Has a history of being toxic
- Does not own his own mistakes
- Is temperamental
- When he comes will likely lack match fitness

Feel free to keep building

- Can win a game if he feels like it - If this were true he'd still be playing for dogs... he hasn't won a game since the cows game because of his impact on Lolo... and that's arguable, because I'm not even sure if the win can be primarily attributed to him

- Potentially helps fill a weak spot on our list - If this is suggesting that he can play 2nd row, then I would disagree completely. Dogs bought him for the price they paid, because they intended on playing him 80mins on an edge... you don't pay someone $800k to play 40mins off the bench... Ciraldo tried this several times and he was an absolute liability in defence and he had to cut it short. He might be able to dominate on the attacking side of the ball on an edge, but he cannot handle the defensive side at all

 

[Mr Fourex]

 

[tommy]

Obviously his boxing trainer has levelled with him and told him to stick to league after running the eye overhim.

Must be hard to start a boxing career when you are already punch drunk

 

[KateBroncos1812]

No From Me he adds nothing special

 

[winslow_wong]

Only if he signs for minimum wage

 

[mitch222]

This sums it up
Close the thread

 

[Kaz]

No way,· Nope, Nah , Absolutely not, No thanks, No.

 

[Johnny92]

After the first trial I'd reward a train and trial guy like Patston instead if he goes well in the next trials. Cheaper for longer and more reliable.

 

[Sproj]

After the first trial I'd reward a train and trial guy like Patston instead if he goes well in the next trials. Cheaper for longer and more reliable.

Yeah you would assume that this second shot is saying to him, play like you did in game 1 or better and you are in the squad.

 

[Nashy]

It is probably good to have a positive and negative list. I’ll start:

Positives:
- Can win a game if he feels like it
- Potentially helps fill a weak spot on our list
- Should be only a short term deal

Negatives:
- Has a history of being toxic
- Does not own his own mistakes
- Is temperamental
- When he comes will likely lack match fitness

Feel free to keep building

You might as well do a team list with him in the team too I guess. Go on, you know you wanna.

 

[Sproj]

You might as well do a team list with him in the team too I guess. Go on, you know you wanna.

Cannot disappoint the fans:

1. Walsh
2. Oates
3. Staggs
4. Cobbo
5. Arthars
6. Mam
7. Reynolds
8. Baker
9. Walters
10. Haas
11. Piakura
12. Riki
13. Carrigan

14. Smoothy
15. Hetherington
16. Willison
17. Pangai Jr