Super Freak
International Captain
Forum Staff
- Jan 25, 2014
- 44,120
- 33,259
Sign Kevin Proctor? I'll show myself out.
Don’t know how that will work. Vaping is now an instant ban at Suncorp.
Sign Kevin Proctor? I'll show myself out.
Be good if he is so he can free up Tesi to move to centre next week.
What on earth would Tesi do from 14?Tesi is fullback or a 14 for mine, don't think he would handle the defensive reads needed to be a good centre, certainly not better than our other options
He also didn't do enough to take it from a fit TMM, then or now, only to fill the gap.I dont think Martin has lost his spot because he is leaving. I dont think we work like that. He lost his place through injury and Tesi for me just hasnt done enough to lose the shirt just yet.
Maybe but I think the club is making the right call by backing Walsh on 400k X3 years. Great deal IMO.I reckon TMM would've stayed if Broncos didn't low ball him.
I reckon TMM would've stayed if Broncos didn't low ball him.
We're funnelling it to him via fan requested memmo'sHad to. All the cash is going to Billy Walters.
I think KW's position is very sound and I get the reasoning and agree with you Porthoz. TMM is the better option but Newie isn't that far behind on balance but is staying. So, I'd reckon the plan would be, keep going with Newie until/if he slips up and has a gutless non catch horror game and then TMM to the rescue or Newie steadily improves.He also didn't do enough to take it from a fit TMM, then or now, only to fill the gap.
I have zero doubt we are a much more serious threat in the finals with TMM than with Tesi...
Perhaps Kevvie is playing it safe with TMM to ensure he comes back fully game fit. At least that's my hope.
I don't think so.......I reckon TMM would've stayed if Broncos didn't low ball him.
I think KW's position is very sound and I get the reasoning and agree with you Porthoz. TMM is the better option but Newie isn't that far behind on balance but is staying. So, I'd reckon the plan would be, keep going with Newie until/if he slips up and has a gutless non catch horror game and then TMM to the rescue or Newie steadily improves.
It is Niu, not Newie. Show some respect to our players like we all do with Reece Kenny.
I really hope Walsh lives up to expectations, but it will hurt if it goes backwards knowing we could very well be in a premiership window if we went with TMM.
in attack yes, but TMMs defensive qualities from what I have seen are still at another level, that said Walsh is playing in a shit team, I hope it works but it feels like we are putting soo much expectations on a kid who is still learning his craft.IMO, Walsh offers us the best attributes of Niu (running) and TMM (play making).
He'll give us a genuine second kicking option, although some work with Reynolds would be beneficial. we definitely need to get Mam a kicking game during the off season
either way some intensive sessions with Boyd during the off season would work wonders. (i'd also add Cobbo and Herbie to those sessions as our main backups)
Mam has been excellent this year though, If you compare him to Walker what he loses in his kicking game he gains in his running game, for how stupidly young and inexperienced he is, he looks pure future superstar material.i wish there was some way we could have kept TMM as well. why couldn't the warriors be interested in Niu instead... would have been happy to see a spine next year of
1. walsh
6. TMM
7. Rey
9. Walters
Mam will be likely be burnt out from this year and fall victim to the second year blues.