Lets talk hookers

The first perosn to touch the ball every set kinda hooker. We've got quiet the predicament atm, currently have Macca, Isaac Luke, Jake Turpin and Paix on our roster. You would think 4 is too many "specialist" hookers to go into a season with. Throw in young Hetherington as well if times get desperate.
I would argue that Turpin is probably number one and must stay and Paix is young and cheap and could be the future so he stays as well. That leaves a battle between macca and luke. I see them as probably neck and neck but I'd lean towards Luke as i imagine he's cheaper and his kicking game has been good lately. However maccas defence is better ane he has a bigger motor. Personally I'm leaning towards a Luke/Turpin hooker combo.
Given our poor attitude and defensive issues there's an argument that Macca is a must for the side. A left field option would be to start macca at lock for the first 25-30 mins to strengthen the middle and make up for the loss of impact by having a solid front row of Hass and Pangai/lodge and and also a big meter eating second rower. Bring Macca off after 30 and then the bench lock on for the final 50 and revert back to a typical forward pack? Pretty left field but worth a a thought?
When you include halves into the equation i don't think you can afford to have in your top 30: deardon, milford, sos, croft, gamble, Turpin, luke, paix, macca. Acknowledging we've had a shocker injury toll this year and used them all but do all those guys make the roster too hooker, half, 5/8 heavy?