Sin bin for slapping introduced

Super Freak

Super Freak

International Captain
Forum Staff
Jan 25, 2014
41,068
30,188
Players will risk being sent to the sin bin if they slap an opponent from this weekend.

The NRL Competition Committee said on Wednesday the recent trend of players slapping others, following the banning of the punch, was a poor look for the game.

As a result, referees will be encouraged to use the sin bin for open-handed slaps to the face.

“Slapping is not a good look for the game and I support any efforts to ensure that it is not a part of Rugby League,” Sydney Roosters Coach Trent Robinson said.

“The game has worked hard for a long time on its image for all people, but particularly for children and mothers, and this sends the right message to them.”

South Sydney coach Michael Maguire said the sin bin would be an effective way of deterring open handed slapping.

“We have seen instances of punching reduce significantly and we hope to now see a similar trend with slapping.”

Today’s meeting included Robinson, Maguire, Kangaroos Coach Mal Meninga, ARLC Chairman John Grant, Commissioner Wayne Pearce, NRL CEO Todd Greenberg, NRL Head of Football Brian Canavan, RLPA General Manager – Player Relations Clint Newton, former Jillaroos Captain Karyn Murphy, as well as Greg Inglis (alternate for Kangaroos Captain Cameron Smith).

Mr Canavan said players, coaches and officials were embarrassed by slapping incidents.

“Slapping may not always hurt physically but it is a poor look for the game and a bad example to juniors,” he said.

“Referees will now be empowered to deal with slapping incidents as they would with punches – by using the sin bin.”

Based on the current Laws and Interpretations, the Bunker can intervene in instances where a player should be sent to the sin bin.

The committee also recommended:

- The current process around concussion and Head Injury Assessments should remain while further analysis is undertaken on the issue;

- Not to introduce an 18th man to replace players forced out of a game through a head injury, although the game will continue to review interchange procedures;

- The Medical Advisory Panel should make any recommendation on whether independent doctors should be used for head injury incidents.

The Committee discussed player workload and balance as well as the continuing game trends following the reduction to eight interchanges.

The Committee was also given an update on the offside line technology and the Women’s Rugby League working group.

During a State of the Game update, the Committee was told that after 5 rounds:

- Average video referral (Bunker) decision times are currently tracking 8 percent faster than 2016 (59 seconds on average in 2017 compared to 64 seconds in 2016), while referral rates are significantly down on 2016 (2.80 per game in 2017, compared to 3.53 in 2016);

- Average game margins were currently tracking to be the closest since 2011, while the percentage of games decided by 6 points or less is up from 34% in 2016 to 38% in 2017 so far.

http://www.nrl.com/sin-bin-for-slapping-introduced/tabid/10874/newsid/105614/default.aspx
 
Horseheadsup

Horseheadsup

NRL Player
Mar 21, 2016
2,670
1,365
Players will risk being sent to the sin bin if they slap an opponent from this weekend.

The NRL Competition Committee said on Wednesday the recent trend of players slapping others, following the banning of the punch, was a poor look for the game.

As a result, referees will be encouraged to use the sin bin for open-handed slaps to the face.

“Slapping is not a good look for the game and I support any efforts to ensure that it is not a part of Rugby League,” Sydney Roosters Coach Trent Robinson said.

“The game has worked hard for a long time on its image for all people, but particularly for children and mothers, and this sends the right message to them.”

South Sydney coach Michael Maguire said the sin bin would be an effective way of deterring open handed slapping.

“We have seen instances of punching reduce significantly and we hope to now see a similar trend with slapping.”

Today’s meeting included Robinson, Maguire, Kangaroos Coach Mal Meninga, ARLC Chairman John Grant, Commissioner Wayne Pearce, NRL CEO Todd Greenberg, NRL Head of Football Brian Canavan, RLPA General Manager – Player Relations Clint Newton, former Jillaroos Captain Karyn Murphy, as well as Greg Inglis (alternate for Kangaroos Captain Cameron Smith).

Mr Canavan said players, coaches and officials were embarrassed by slapping incidents.

“Slapping may not always hurt physically but it is a poor look for the game and a bad example to juniors,” he said.

“Referees will now be empowered to deal with slapping incidents as they would with punches – by using the sin bin.”

Based on the current Laws and Interpretations, the Bunker can intervene in instances where a player should be sent to the sin bin.

The committee also recommended:

- The current process around concussion and Head Injury Assessments should remain while further analysis is undertaken on the issue;

- Not to introduce an 18th man to replace players forced out of a game through a head injury, although the game will continue to review interchange procedures;

- The Medical Advisory Panel should make any recommendation on whether independent doctors should be used for head injury incidents.

The Committee discussed player workload and balance as well as the continuing game trends following the reduction to eight interchanges.

The Committee was also given an update on the offside line technology and the Women’s Rugby League working group.

During a State of the Game update, the Committee was told that after 5 rounds:

- Average video referral (Bunker) decision times are currently tracking 8 percent faster than 2016 (59 seconds on average in 2017 compared to 64 seconds in 2016), while referral rates are significantly down on 2016 (2.80 per game in 2017, compared to 3.53 in 2016);

- Average game margins were currently tracking to be the closest since 2011, while the percentage of games decided by 6 points or less is up from 34% in 2016 to 38% in 2017 so far.

http://www.nrl.com/sin-bin-for-slapping-introduced/tabid/10874/newsid/105614/default.aspx
What about hair pulling? Bet Adam Blair's had a gutful of that.
 
tommy

tommy

International Rep
Jun 5, 2015
12,280
13,217
This is what they are having meetings about? Faark me!

I can think of a few slappers in the NRL.....Do they all get life bans?
 
Morkel

Morkel

International Captain
Contributor
Jan 25, 2013
25,329
29,149
Average game margins the closest since 2011.

Can't imagine how that's happened.
 
CaptainHook

CaptainHook

NRL Player
Jun 17, 2013
2,990
1,303
Average game margins the closest since 2011.

Can't imagine how that's happened.

Hey leave it alone - it makes for great TV!

We've had grown men slapping each other for 4 years now since they outlawed punching.

What a sad fucking joke this once great game has become.
 
GCBRONCO

GCBRONCO

International Captain
Mar 4, 2008
21,278
19,485
So slapping is a sin bin offence, but the million other physical offences that are much more dangerous rarely ever draw anything other then a penalty(mind you penalising the bracing "shoulder charges" are a joke). Meanwhile they actually reject a good idea in allowing an eighteenth man in case of a head injury.
 
CaptainHook

CaptainHook

NRL Player
Jun 17, 2013
2,990
1,303
So slapping is a sin bin offence, but the million other physical offences that are much more dangerous rarely ever draw anything other then a penalty(mind you penalising the bracing "shoulder charges" are a joke). Meanwhile they actually reject a good idea in allowing an eighteenth man in case of a head injury.

Yeah it makes no sense.

They've beefed up concussion rules but they haven't cracked down on tackles that can give players a concussion.

It's like this slapping rule. Slapping only increased because punching was outlawed. All this will accomplish is a rise in grubby shit like facials, niggling in the play the ball etc... for a few years and then we'll put a sin bin in place for all that.

Referees should have the power to sin bin and send off all forms of foul play and contrary conduct - which I'm pretty sure they already do in the rule book.

Honestly, who is in charge of the NRL? Monkeys? A fucking brain dead sloth could run a competition more effectively.
 
B

bb_gun

NRL Player
Contributor
Apr 23, 2013
2,795
1,637
I wonder how many Queenslanders vs New South Welshman have given the old face slap since punching was outlawed?

@Morkel is this another tinfoil hat moment?
 
tommy

tommy

International Rep
Jun 5, 2015
12,280
13,217
Sorry about the title but another decade from now this is what our game is going to look like.
 
Broncoman

Broncoman

State of Origin Rep
Oct 9, 2011
7,691
1,118
This pc rubbish is really just turning the game into glorified touch footy. Both codes of Rugby in this country are run so badly no wonder people are disengaging. Taking out biff, shoulder charge etc just is softening the game and taking out intimidators.
 
Horseheadsup

Horseheadsup

NRL Player
Mar 21, 2016
2,670
1,365
This pc rubbish is really just turning the game into glorified touch footy. Both codes of Rugby in this country are run so badly no wonder people are disengaging. Taking out biff, shoulder charge etc just is softening the game and taking out intimidators.
Do you remember Maguire belting Allgood for the high shot on Peter Wallace. Then the Ref sent Allgood to the sin bin instead. Hilarious.
 
Broncoman

Broncoman

State of Origin Rep
Oct 9, 2011
7,691
1,118
Do you remember Maguire belting Allgood for the high shot on Peter Wallace. Then the Ref sent Allgood to the sin bin instead. Hilarious.

No I don't remember that, can you give me a link?
 
Morkel

Morkel

International Captain
Contributor
Jan 25, 2013
25,329
29,149
Sorry about the title but another decade from now this is what our game is going to look like.


Ironically, looks like that grubby little weed, Keary.

This pc rubbish is really just turning the game into glorified touch footy. Both codes of Rugby in this country are run so badly no wonder people are disengaging. Taking out biff, shoulder charge etc just is softening the game and taking out intimidators.

I don't agree. There is nothing tough about a slap, a forearm to the face of a tackled player that's pinned, or a sneaky elbow or knee when falling on someone. That's just cowardly shit. It's not a bad look because it's too violent, it's a bad look because it advocates bad sportsmanship and championing cheap niggle over genuine effort.

Penalise the **** out of it until we're left with players who want to win games by tackling hard and running hard. Give me a Tonie Carroll any day over a Beau Scott.

I wonder how many Queenslanders vs New South Welshman have given the old face slap since punching was outlawed?

@Morkel is this another tinfoil hat moment?

Scoff if you will. But answer me this - since I've worn it, have they been able to read my mind?

GIF-Amused-dis-gonna-be-good-knowing-popcorn-smug.-Indiana-Jones-watch-watching-GIF.gif
 
CaptainHook

CaptainHook

NRL Player
Jun 17, 2013
2,990
1,303
I wonder how many Queenslanders vs New South Welshman have given the old face slap since punching was outlawed?

@Morkel is this another tinfoil hat moment?

I think @Morkel brings up a lot of good points. He certainly gives you food for thought.

Tell me something, if it's all above board and there's nothing to see here tell me why the bunker are only allowed to rule on field goals during golden point?

I read that the other day. They can't check for offside, late tackles etc...is this the NRL admitting that the referees put the whistle away in extra time? Is it an admission that only the dirtiest grubbiest team wins? No one bothers getting back the 10 etc.

The timing of this slapping ban is interesting coming off the Sharks-Storm game. It was the biggest grub-a-thon of the last 10 years. You could almost see the bean counters going 'Shit! This crap is not good television! We need tries dammit! Condition red! Condition RED!!!"
 
CaptainHook

CaptainHook

NRL Player
Jun 17, 2013
2,990
1,303
Do you remember Maguire belting Allgood for the high shot on Peter Wallace. Then the Ref sent Allgood to the sin bin instead. Hilarious.

Haha I was thinking of that the other day. I couldn't remember if McGuire stayed on the field or not. That is a crack up.
 

Active Now

  • Cavalo
  • Fozz
  • Bucking Beads
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.