Yeah, this is a concern I have. We banked heavily on youth in 2019 and 2020 and failed miserably. We got some older heads in this year and it helped get where we are now.
Going back to the youth because they are exciting could be a step back again.
Yeah it is a legit concern. That said, we seem to be starting to get things more balanced and within that, there are always going to be some calculated risks.
In the forwards, where you really need some older heads, consistent players to serve as glue, we now have 8. Jensen 11. Capewell and 13 Carrigan (this is excluding Haas as he likely won't be here). These guys now serve as the glue between your other young 'uns coming in.
I would argue Flegs is starting to hit consistency now too and Hetherington is pretty impressive as well for one so inexperienced. So you can fill in around these pieces with the young guys. Then you have Paix as well who prior to injury, was really going well. He has served a strong apprenticeship in Q Cup to be ready to go now.
The issue I see is the spine is still very, very raw. I really feel Paix is far more important moving forward than we probably realise. If he can continue to be consistent and improve as well, him and Reynolds become the key planks in the spine that allow you to have Mam and Walsh in there as well while they both develop and learn consistency.
In the backline, having Herbie and Oates means you can bank on strong performances from your left side (strong side) week in, week out. It allows you to have a massive risk / reward but inconsistent right side. Take Oates out, you really only have Herbie as your bankable backline player and that is a massive risk. So to me, moving in to next year, Oates is an important retention and Paix probably our most important in taking a step up.