In defence of Steve Michaels
- Thread starter mjc
- Start date
- Mar 5, 2008
- 30,650
- 19,787
mjc said:
That would be because he has talent, obvious to all.
On the other hand, Steve Michaels is overrated and poor.
- Apr 26, 2008
- 34,578
- 35,551
[icon_lol1. [icon_lol1. That was a good laugh.mjc said:
That's completely irrelavent, wtf? LOL, so if people don't call for lockyer to be dropped every week for doing something wrong, then we can't call for any player to be dropped even though they are playing very poorly? [icon_lol1.
- Thread starter
- #45
Justin Hodges and Steve Michaels are very comparable.
Michaels doesnt pass to his winger just as Hodges doesnt pass to his winger, and Michaels has better stats.
I was giving examples of why I think there is a group mentality against Michaels that is unfair.
Michaels doesnt pass to his winger just as Hodges doesnt pass to his winger, and Michaels has better stats.
I was giving examples of why I think there is a group mentality against Michaels that is unfair.
GCBRONCO
International Captain
- Mar 4, 2008
- 22,920
- 21,378
Ari Gold is correct, theres no conspiracy against Michaels.
Stats can be misleading and relying on them to defend a player doesn't make it correct, take metres gained. One would assume that because Michaels has made more metres so far this season then Hodges (700 to 641) that Michaels has been more effective, but what it doesnt tell you is Hodges hasn't played 3 games this season nor that Hodges is averaging a higher rate of metres per game.
Stats can be misleading and relying on them to defend a player doesn't make it correct, take metres gained. One would assume that because Michaels has made more metres so far this season then Hodges (700 to 641) that Michaels has been more effective, but what it doesnt tell you is Hodges hasn't played 3 games this season nor that Hodges is averaging a higher rate of metres per game.
- Mar 5, 2008
- 30,650
- 19,787
mjc said:
Lol, you mean you lost the argument.
I think you'll find Michaels has been told by Henjack to hold the ball and not to pass after he had a few errors in the first few games... he'll get his passing license back soon.
And for the record, I don't know why he's getting bagged either, i don't think he's having a bad season at all and neither do the people who matter ie Ivan and Mal. Some people on here just have NFI
And for the record, I don't know why he's getting bagged either, i don't think he's having a bad season at all and neither do the people who matter ie Ivan and Mal. Some people on here just have NFI
rissi_gurl
NYC Player
- Mar 17, 2008
- 208
- 0
michaels is not that bad...hes just not that flash either
- Mar 5, 2008
- 30,650
- 19,787
m1c said:
Talking about yourself again i see.
Wow, people disagree with you. Live with it.
Michaels is average at best and I thought that before he had his knee problems. He has little to offer in attack other than a decent finish and defensively he is not overly smart or physically good. I hate the way he crabs across giving Winterstein little to no room to run if heaven forbid he actually passes to him.
Mjc is right (to a degree). I think its unfair how a certain group of people on this forum band together and shout down people who have any opinion (on any topic) which is different to theirs. Same thing happened in the Nick Kenny and Michaels thread.
Whilst i don't totally agree with either side on either thread. I do agree that Michaels must be doing something bloody right to still be in the squad. Yow Yeh was one of my top 2 picks to have a massive impact this year along with Mccullough (or however you spell it), in saying that I had no idea how valuable Glenn would be, and Yow Yeh can't get a look in.
If the people that make the decisions agreed with the popular opinion here, im sure Folau would be in Michaels' centre position by now.
Whilst i don't totally agree with either side on either thread. I do agree that Michaels must be doing something bloody right to still be in the squad. Yow Yeh was one of my top 2 picks to have a massive impact this year along with Mccullough (or however you spell it), in saying that I had no idea how valuable Glenn would be, and Yow Yeh can't get a look in.
If the people that make the decisions agreed with the popular opinion here, im sure Folau would be in Michaels' centre position by now.
