Jack Bird Discussion

Jack Bird’s signing will either deliver a title or derail Brisbane’s premiership ambition

Peter Badel, The Courier-Mail


JACK Bird’s signing with Brisbane has the potential to either deliver a Broncos premiership _ or derail the playmaking chemistry of a glamour club hungry for another title.

That is the boom-or-bust scenario that faces Brisbane coach Wayne Bennett after Bird today advised Cronulla teammates he will be a Bronco next season.

There will be no middle ground with Bird’s signing. With marquee recruits, there never is.

The Broncos will pay Bird $2.1 million over three seasons and during that time they will expect top-dollar performances from a player who is arguably the most dynamic ballrunner in the code.

Judged as an individual, Bird shapes as a magnificent signing for Brisbane. He ticks all the boxes. Young. Tough. Talented. Ferocious. Versatile. At the tender age of 22, he has played State of Origin and won a premiership. It is no fluke. Bird brings an extra dimension to any football team he represents.

But individual brilliance alone does not win premierships. Champion teams exceed the sum of their parts and the challenge for Bennett is extracting the best of Bird within the overall structure of the Broncos squad.

The million-dollar question is where Bennett ultimately plays Bird _ and how the decision is received by Broncos players.

Bird has told Cronulla insiders he has been promised the five-eighth spot.

That would mean Anthony Milford _ Brisbane’s wonder boy _ gets stripped of his cherished Broncos No. 6 jumper and forced, most likely, to play halfback.

Bennett insists he has given no guarantees to Bird. He believes Bird can play four positions _ fullback, centre, five-eighth and lock _ and will settle on his position in the fullness of time.
Anthony Milford could be shifted to accommodate Jack Bird. Pic Jono Searle.

Many will disagree with this view but a Bird-Milford scrumbase alliance is fraught with danger. Both are instinctive ballrunners who thrive on broken-play situations. Neither Bird nor Milford are military-style game-managers who think a play ahead like Cooper Cronk.

Behind the scenes, Broncos insiders know this about Milford. They know that while Ben Hunt plans and calls each play, it buys time for Milford to get his head around when to inject himself and when to service his outside men.

If Bennett shifts Milford away from five-eighth, he risks alienating his best attacking player.
If he picks Bird at lock, outside the halves, Bennett risks a difficult discussion with his new recruit.
It is a delicate balancing act and Bennett will need every scintilla of his 40 years of coaching nous to get the formula right.

At the Sharks, he is hugely respected for his raw talent but is also regarded as an aloof, highly-charged character who tests the one-in, all-in mentality of the modern-day NRL club.

Sharks players find it intriguing that Bird is allowed to sometimes miss recovery sessions. He lives in Wollongong. Instead, the team physio is sent to his home to give Bird a massage.


A fortnight ago, as Sharks veteran Chris Heighington prepared for his 300th NRL match, the Sharks organised a special team dinner. Club legend Andrew Ettingshausen was called to present his milestone jersey. Special messages from his teammates were played on a big screen.

Bird failed to turn up. Several Sharks players were filthy. Others shrugged it off as, ‘That’s Jack’.
If there is one certainty about life at the Broncos, it is that their group sing from the same hymn sheet. There is no place for outsiders or agitators at Red Hill. As their motto goes, emblazoned on the external wall of Brisbane’s gymnasium, they are only ever as strong as their weakest.

Bennett is the greatest coach of all-time and he doesn’t waste his time signing duds. Jack Bird can be absolutely brilliant, but the super coach may have to iron out a few speed bumps to make it all work.

http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport...n/news-story/79ffafdafb5c4c670e1894907ae50e99
 
That actually makes more sense.

Still, I find it hard to believe that's their highest ever offer..

I would be very intrigued if they weren't paying Maloney atleast that much money and gallen too
 
Have I ever told you guys that I love brown paper bags?

Because I do, they're a great invention and have many uses.
 
We don't know how long their offer was for though. If we offered $2.1 mill ($700k a season), and they were $350k short (over the same period), that works out to $600k/yr. If they offered a 5 year deal though, that's $3 million. It could well have been their "highest ever financial offer", but wasn't the most per year for a player.
 
Have I ever told you guys that I love brown paper bags?

Because I do, they're a great invention and have many uses.

I love it when butthurt w*nkers who support other clubs accuse us of this. The elephant in the room however is, if we are so effective at this, why don't we just buy premiership after premiership?

Watching their predictable and faux outraged behaviour is delicious.
 
Wouldn't any situation next year possibly derail our playmaking chemistry? We are losing our halfback.
 
http://www.sharks.com.au/news/2017/04/13/club_statement_jack_.html

They are trying their best to make it sound like we are paying him ridiculous coin.

it also sounds like a load of shit about their offer to Bird being the highest in their history considering they reportedly would have been paying Barba 800k a year before they sacked him

It says secure a current player- Barba wasn't a current player. I can easily believe that it would be their biggest offer- all offers from now to big players are going to be new bench marks.
 
I love it when butthurt w*nkers who support other clubs accuse us of this. The elephant in the room however is, if we are so effective at this, why don't we just buy premiership after premiership?

Watching their predictable and faux outraged behaviour is delicious.
well, the thoroughbreds aren't really a thing anymore like they used to be, so there is that possible reason...
 
It says secure a current player- Barba wasn't a current player. I can easily believe that it would be their biggest offer- all offers from now to big players are going to be new bench marks.

he was a current player when the re-signed him
 
What this mean potentially for the young up and comers?

We can't fit all of Su'a, Fai, Hipgrave, Arrow, Haas, Joffa, Etc in.

Who do we let go and who do we keep?

For me, I'd rank the three most important as:

1. Haas
2. Su'a
3. Fai

I think Joffa will be lost and one or two more.

its still early and whispers are flying, but news around suggests joffa may end up in parra, fai will potentially go as well in search of game time, arrow is tossing up an extension or permanent gig elsewhere. biggest impact i see is ese'ese and carrigan. these 2 are the real future but i think we will lose both. we have paid big money for haas in front of our own kids which hurts. storm are watching carrigan very closely. and plenty of clubs are looking at ese'ese.
if the numbers are correct bird will chew up 8% of our cap and if milford sings for an estimated $900k that is nearly 20% of our cap there. this is very un bronco like.
 
Sydney players going to the Broncs generally suck.

If he took less than the sharks offer to go to them it's the usual cheating Donkey shit

From LU.

This doesn't make any sense.
 
Yawn.... I broke this news on here on Saturday which is the day he signed the contract. The moment Bennett contacted him, he was in as he greatly admires the man. All that was needed was a contract which is now in place. Excellent signing, possibly the best recruitment in Bronco history.
 
Yawn.... I broke this news on here on Saturday which is the day he signed the contract. The moment Bennett contacted him, he was in as he greatly admires the man. All that was needed was a contract which is now in place. Excellent signing, possibly the best recruitment in Bronco history.

lets not go overboard here.

Quality player and i'm always happy for the club to sign quality players. i just hope Bennett didn't promise him any specific position (It's not like him to do that). and Bird is happy to play where the team needs him ... even if that means center
 

Active Now

  • I bleed Maroon
  • Brocko
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.