NEWS Judiciary: Live blog - Carrigan Four Week Suspension

Kaz

Kaz

State of Origin Captain
Mar 5, 2008
Threads
304
8,897
1,845
Sharks contact NRL after tackle overlooked.

Cronulla have sought an explanation from the NRL as to why South Sydney forward Tevita Tatola was not sanctioned for the hip-drop tackle that left Will Kennedy with a serious ankle injury.


Lets see what BS the NRL come up with.
 
Sproj

Sproj

International Captain
Forum Staff
Sep 6, 2013
Threads
293
37,754
41,111
Sharks contact NRL after tackle overlooked.

Cronulla have sought an explanation from the NRL as to why South Sydney forward Tevita Tatola was not sanctioned for the hip-drop tackle that left Will Kennedy with a serious ankle injury.


Lets see what BS the NRL come up with.

My guess is nothing at all.
 
Mr Fourex

Mr Fourex

State of Origin Captain
Apr 9, 2012
Threads
49
8,318
7,245
Our forwards last night looked a shadow of their former selves without Patty in the team.

It is plainly obvious that Pat is the leader of the forwards and drives them around the park accordingly.
 
broncos4life

broncos4life

International Captain
Forum Staff
Oct 5, 2011
Threads
207
22,809
21,440
Sharks contact NRL after tackle overlooked.

Cronulla have sought an explanation from the NRL as to why South Sydney forward Tevita Tatola was not sanctioned for the hip-drop tackle that left Will Kennedy with a serious ankle injury.


Lets see what BS the NRL come up with.
How do we say that it's because Tatola plays for a team we like without saying it is because Tatola plays for a team we like...
 
LittleDavey

LittleDavey

NRL Player
Mar 25, 2013
Threads
3
2,365
3,237
Sharks contact NRL after tackle overlooked.

Cronulla have sought an explanation from the NRL as to why South Sydney forward Tevita Tatola was not sanctioned for the hip-drop tackle that left Will Kennedy with a serious ankle injury.


Lets see what BS the NRL come up with.
I love how this is all over the media TODAY and not Sunday when Tatola wasn't charged. If there had've been a few days of uproar before Pat's date with the judiciary there's no way they could have simultaneously made an example of him AND cleared Tatola. Should have made Annersley explain it on Monday.

I don't know who to blame for this. Our club for not making a big song-and-dance? The NSW-centric media for ignoring it? The Sharks for not kicking up a stink?
 
Foordy

Foordy

International Captain
Mar 4, 2008
Threads
799
28,229
28,596
Sharks contact NRL after tackle overlooked.

Cronulla have sought an explanation from the NRL as to why South Sydney forward Tevita Tatola was not sanctioned for the hip-drop tackle that left Will Kennedy with a serious ankle injury.


Lets see what BS the NRL come up with.

whatever BS the NRL came up with confused Fitzgibbon, he said:


"It's getting difficult to understand," Sharks coach Craig Fitzgibbon said on Friday.

"I didn't understand the explanation but it is what it is. We move on.

"You really don't want to get stuck and dwell on what you can't control. All I can control is the team that's going to play this weekend.
"But we lose a good player and an important part of our team for an extended period and there's no charge."
 
L

Lockysillegitimatechild

NRL Captain
Apr 10, 2015
Threads
11
4,403
7,544
Strange the media hasn't gone on about the Brandon Smith tackle no less than 1 week after the media campaign to rub the hip drop out of the game and make an example out of anyone that does it.....

Well done nrl...

Could you imagine if a broncos player did a hip drop though lol....
 
Kimlo

Kimlo

International Captain
Senior Staff
Apr 26, 2008
Threads
466
32,032
28,690
Strange the media hasn't gone on about the Brandon Smith tackle no less than 1 week after the media campaign to rub the hip drop out of the game and make an example out of anyone that does it.....

Well done nrl...

Could you imagine if a broncos player did a hip drop though lol....
Smith's tackle was much, much worse.

I'm holding fire until I see what he's charged with this morning.
 
Kimlo

Kimlo

International Captain
Senior Staff
Apr 26, 2008
Threads
466
32,032
28,690
Strange the media hasn't gone on about the Brandon Smith tackle no less than 1 week after the media campaign to rub the hip drop out of the game and make an example out of anyone that does it.....

Well done nrl...

Could you imagine if a broncos player did a hip drop though lol....

Lolol.

Bellamy: “I just hope it gets judged on the tackle, not some of the hysteria that has gone on this week,” Bellamy said. “That is all we ask.

“If you go on one last week, but how many has there been? If there is one in however many games since the last one. “Pat Carrigan doesn’t go out on the field to break Hastings’ legs, they are an accident.”

“I don’t see it as a real big issue in the game, but I understand that it can injure people, but there hasn’t been a whole heap this year I don’t think. “I just hope it gets judged on that and not on it being in the news a lot this week.”

Parker:
“We watched it in full speed live, Brandon Smith is just making the tackle and he falls off the tackle and the fact Tino went on that out line dragged Brandon Smith along with him,” Parker said. “When you slow it all down to the enth degree like we do it doesn’t look great, but he’s just hanging on.

“If you don’t want to end up in that position then Brandon Smith has to let go of the tackle, otherwise what does he do, it’s a complete accident. “I don’t see it as a genuine hip drop like we saw with Pat Carrigan last week. If he’s not to end up in that position, he needs to let go which completely goes against everything we talk about in rugby league.

Ennis: “All the talk this week was two players holding the man up then that third tackler coming in and showing no duty of care, I don’t like the position that Tino gets in at the end but I’m not sure what else Brandon Smith could do there other than let go of the tackle,” Ennis said.

“Do we put that down to the duty of care? Is that where we’re going? Maybe we have to, where we’re eliminating players from getting in that position. “That was a real difficult one, he just ended up in that unfortunate position Brandon Smith and I’m not sure what else he could have done.”
 
Kaz

Kaz

State of Origin Captain
Mar 5, 2008
Threads
304
8,897
1,845
So over Parker & Ennis being so against us.

By the reports Parker was a complete arsehole to up & coming players when he was a senior player, no wonder Kevvie didn't want him.

Can someone elbow them in the throat & crush their laryngitis
 
Xzei

Xzei

NRL Player
Mar 13, 2017
Threads
1
2,984
4,534
tino lucky that the tackler up top didnt drive him back over smith or it could have been all sorts of pain
 
broncos4life

broncos4life

International Captain
Forum Staff
Oct 5, 2011
Threads
207
22,809
21,440

Lolol.

Bellamy: “I just hope it gets judged on the tackle, not some of the hysteria that has gone on this week,” Bellamy said. “That is all we ask.

“If you go on one last week, but how many has there been? If there is one in however many games since the last one. “Pat Carrigan doesn’t go out on the field to break Hastings’ legs, they are an accident.”

“I don’t see it as a real big issue in the game, but I understand that it can injure people, but there hasn’t been a whole heap this year I don’t think. “I just hope it gets judged on that and not on it being in the news a lot this week.”

Parker:
“We watched it in full speed live, Brandon Smith is just making the tackle and he falls off the tackle and the fact Tino went on that out line dragged Brandon Smith along with him,” Parker said. “When you slow it all down to the enth degree like we do it doesn’t look great, but he’s just hanging on.

“If you don’t want to end up in that position then Brandon Smith has to let go of the tackle, otherwise what does he do, it’s a complete accident. “I don’t see it as a genuine hip drop like we saw with Pat Carrigan last week. If he’s not to end up in that position, he needs to let go which completely goes against everything we talk about in rugby league.

Ennis: “All the talk this week was two players holding the man up then that third tackler coming in and showing no duty of care, I don’t like the position that Tino gets in at the end but I’m not sure what else Brandon Smith could do there other than let go of the tackle,” Ennis said.

“Do we put that down to the duty of care? Is that where we’re going? Maybe we have to, where we’re eliminating players from getting in that position. “That was a real difficult one, he just ended up in that unfortunate position Brandon Smith and I’m not sure what else he could have done.”
I honestly hate Parker, like more than I ever have hated Tallis. Both actively hate on the club that made them and they captained but you can understand Tallis reasons far more. Parker has basically done it for media clout and extra gobbies from his mate Ennis.

Fucking scumbag, should never be recognised by the club again. Although he ‘bleeds Bronco’ fucking spare me.
 
theshed

theshed

Just a Game
Aug 28, 2010
Threads
49
11,572
25,406
To be honest they are different. Although the mechanisms were basically the same, Smith was the first man to make contact - Patty came in with force when 2 players already had Hastings held up.

Patty should’ve just done enough to throw him off balance and put him down instead of essentially dropping his body weight on the back of the knees.

Smith went for the hips, swung and landed on the back of the knees and then the 2nd defender came in. Smith couldn’t have reasonably done more to avoid that without just not completing the tackle where as Patty, while still accidentalcould have shown more regard for safety.

I don’t think the difference is as severe as 4 games suspension v 0. Whether Patty should’ve got less or Smith more I’m uncertain but if I had to quantify it I would say Patty’s is about 2 games worse than whatever Smith got.

An analogy would be Smith aquaplaning into a person despite driving to the conditions while Patty did the same but was going 10km over the speed limit.
 
LittleDavey

LittleDavey

NRL Player
Mar 25, 2013
Threads
3
2,365
3,237
I do hope the club issues a very public "please explain" from the NRL, but I expect crickets.

Same for the talking heads in the media, they should be asking all sorts of questions but I predict they will touch on it and move on.

"Let's make an example out of this guy!! Yeah!! That'll show them!!" Aaaaaand nothing for the next bloke to do the same.
 

Tipping Ladder

  • ivanhungryjak
    120.00 pts

    ivanhungryjak

    • Correct picks
      120 out of 168
  • tommy
    120.00 pts

    tommy

    • Correct picks
      120 out of 168
  • Waynesaurus
    120.00 pts

    Waynesaurus

    • Correct picks
      120 out of 168
  • RolledOates
    118.00 pts

    RolledOates

    • Correct picks
      118 out of 168
  • Harry Sack
    117.00 pts

    Harry Sack

    • Correct picks
      117 out of 168

Forum statistics

Threads
19,503
Messages
1,253,380
Members
1,673
Latest member
Saalmeister09

Members online

  • NSW stables
  • LittleDavey
  • Waynesaurus
  • Harry Sack
  • Johnny92
  • lynx000
  • McHunt
  • 1910
  • Mr Fourex
  • Dee
  • Old Mate
  • pagey
  • Bollocks
  • Alec
  • Skathen
  • Battler
  • heartly87
  • Big Del
  • simplythebest
  • Mister Wright
... and 16 more.
Team P W L PD Pts
21 18 3 298 38
21 15 6 208 32
21 15 6 137 32
21 14 7 211 30
21 13 8 134 28
21 13 8 69 28
21 13 8 28 28
21 12 9 121 26
21 11 10 -31 24
21 9 12 -28 20
21 9 12 -132 20
21 6 15 -141 14
21 6 15 -213 14
21 6 15 -252 14
21 4 17 -196 10
21 4 17 -213 10
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.