That's the question isn't it Porthoz, can the Broncos do worse than Hoffman?
I believe there is a gap between what Hoffman brings to the table and absolute rock bottom and I really don't want to see a player fill that gap. At the end of the day, Josh is just holding up the fort until Kahu arrives and another option presents itself. Nicholls represents an alternative but he's going to take some time to adjust and like you, I don't want to see him thrown straight into the deep end without at least spending a few sessions with his team mates.
Like jarro though, I fail to see what value Nicholls offers outside of this season. He could be a depth option but I would have hoped by then that either Paia'Aua, Taylor or Jayden Nikorima would be ready to be called on first.
I really do wish him well and hope that he puts his hand up and we see 6. Nicholls 7. Hunt, but not if Darren isn't ready.
Marouba - Judging from the highlights he just had his best game of the season against Norths but that isn't saying a lot. On form, he's been lucky to play ISC.