Rank every bottom 8 teams recruitment

Adzbroncoz

Adzbroncoz

Sep 5, 2021
14
7
Broncos 7/10 - Have purchased a premiership winning general to take steer of a sinking ship and premiership winning second-rower. That’s about it but it should allow us to avoid the wooden spoon. Excited to see growth of Cobbo. Think we need more creativity in the backline. No.1 No.6 No.9 still no answers which is quite confusing
Bulldogs 9/10 - One of the best recruitment drives in recent memory. Have signed the next Brad Fittler in Matty Burton and have received premiership winning players. Burton is a much better long term investment than Reynolds and I think Gus will sign an experienced half like Pearce or Maloney to pair with him can genuinely compete for edge top 8 spot with the core they have now and new signings/juniours.
Tigers - 0/10 like legit no positives whatsoever
Titans - 7/10 astute signing in Liu for premiership experience IMO still a young squad
Storm - 8/10 have locked up Coates who will be like Inglis, Meaney who will be Hynes 2.0 and hard working forwards
Warriors - 5/10 nothing flash
Cowgirls - 0/10 got rorted by Townsend big time
Raiders - 0/10 face massive roster overhaul and on the decline
Roosters 4/10 not good enough to replace departing experience may take years to fix
 
you realise the Storm, Roosters and Titans all finished in the top 8, right?

p.s. how the **** do you give the Storm and 8/10. they lose JAC, Hynes and Fincane and replace them with Coates, Meaney. although they may look decent in the Storm's systems, that is a big step backwards
 
Foordy said:
you realise the Storm, Roosters and Titans all finished in the top 8, right?

p.s. how the **** do you give the Storm and 8/10. they lose JAC, Hynes and Fincane and replace them with Coates, Meaney. although they may look decent in the Storm's systems, that is a big step backwards
Click to expand...
Thats a great point they seem to be exploding since last saturday
 
On a serious note, I think we’ve done pretty well. We signed the best 2 buys available and didnt get tempted into throwing money at desperation signings. On top of that we added good experience and depth with Lee and James.

I think the best recruitment in the bottom 8 is the Sharks. Fitzgibbon will be a great coach and a draw card for future signings. They also somehow flogged Townsend and brought in Dale and Nicho to compliment some very promising young guys.
 
theshed said:
On a serious note, I think we’ve done pretty well. We signed the best 2 buys available and didnt get tempted into throwing money at desperation signings. On top of that we added good experience and depth with Lee and James.

I think the best recruitment in the bottom 8 is the Sharks. Fitzgibbon will be a great coach and a draw card for future signings. They also somehow flogged Townsend and brought in Dale and Nicho to compliment some very promising young guys.
Click to expand...
I think before gould joined the bulldogs those signings were a recipe for disaster. Now with gould there They may pull their head in for a year or 2, long enough to bring in some people that will change the culture and attitude. However, it is a definite band aid on an amputated leg approach. If things don't go their way straight away it will blow up even worse then a spoon.
 
Now for a more accurate list for all clubs.

The players picked up so far by club:

Panthers - Have lost Burton, Capewell, Naden and bought in no one really, regardless they are fine

Storm - Notable ins are Coates and Meaney and a few other bits and pieces. They lose Hynes, Addo-Carr, Finucane and Lee, plus a few other bits and pieces. They still have a gun side but their depth will e severely tested if they get injuries. Can Coates provide the threat Addo-Carr did?

Rabbitohs - They lose Gagai, Reynolds, Su'A, Mago and others and bring in Milford...maybe, if he isn't in jail (whoever thought anyone would wonder that!). They have been decimated by gun outs and no one really in. Milford and Walker, wowsers that will be...interesting.

Sea-Eagles - Lose Sironen and gain Bullemor. Bullemor is an excellent signing, we all know how much potential he has. They still have TTurbo and that is enough to be up there but not go the extra step. They need a strike centre and there aren't many of those around, particularly for a club with no cap space.

Eels - Lose Fergusen and a few others but no ins. They are a smokey for next season but they will regain Mahoney, that is pretty big.

Roosters - In is Watson, out is Cordner, Friend, Liu and the Morri twins. This team is getting older but they have some big regains in Watson, Keary, Collins, etc. Their regains will be big but they might be starting to age, will be interesting to see which kids / stars they 'convince' to come in over the offseason.

Knights - Ins are Gagai and Clune. I have no idea how they afforded Gagai, they have to be 'bending' their cap. Outs are Shibasaki, Green and Watson. They really need to be top 4 next year or it might all implode, Gagai is a huge in, they have threats at centre on both sides.

Titans - Liu and Turner come in but they need more in the spine, their youth approach may well backfire, I'd be bringing in Berrell from Wynnum-Manly. Their outs are Don, Peachey, Taylor, Rein and a few others. I dunno, their squad seems so unbalanced now, too much unproven youth, sound familiar?

Bottom 8:

Sharks - Ins are Hynes, Finucane, McInnes and outs are Dugan, Johnson, and Townsend. They have some top quality ins but the question really is, who organises at halfback? They will be VERY competitive and if they run with Trindall at 7, well they might well be a smokey next year. This is one side to really watch but another problem is, who is their backline strike? Is their forward pack better than run of the mill? Building nicely.

Dragons - Ins are Burgess, Mbye, Molo, Su'A and their outs are Beale, Clune, Dufty, McInness, Merrin, Norman, Vaughan and a few others. They couldn't ship Vaughan out quick enough when the chance came, this might have more of a fracturing effect than they thought. They have taken on a lot of big contracts that might bite them moving forward. This side seems to...boring. I don't know, Hook has made a Broncos-lite there and they will have an inspired patch once again and then probably fall away like usual.

Tigers - Ins Hastings and Gildart and outs are Leilua, Mbye, Packer and Walters. This side is awful, they have nothing exciting coming in, cannot attract big names and are in turmoil. 2022 spooners?

Warriors - Ins Johnson and Pene, outs are Ah Mau, Hiku, Maumalo, Turner and the big one Tuivasa-Sheck. This team has no decent ins really and have blown a lot of money on some average / downward trending players. They will compete for 8th and that's about it, they will be competitive, they always are but they just don't have enough star power to be more than also rans.

Raiders - Ins are no one but maybe Taylor. Outs are Havili, James, Lui, Scott?, Soliola and and Williams. This side is on a downward swing. They have a REALLY exciting fullback in Savage coming through and a decent spine but the key for them will be their number 7 and who gets it. They could end up contenders or spooners, so hard to get a read on going into '22.

Broncos - Ins are Reynolds, Capewell, Lee, Jensen, James, Pereira and Walters. Outs are Pangai Jr, Lodge, Asiata, Croft, Dearden, Milford, Glenn, Levi and Coates. Losing Coates hurts because he was seriously marketable but the emergence of Cobbo offsets that. Staggs will be like a new recruit on top of the big, big ins. The club has bought in quality players but even better quality blokes. The leadership void has been filled, an organising halfback has been signed and will captain on a not over the top wage. The improvement in the backend of the season coupled with the impressive development of the kids gives supporters PLENTY to be excited about for season '22. Smokeys to challenge for top 4 but more likely 5-8, anything less will be a failed season.

Cowboys - Ins are Hiku and Townsend. Outs are Molo, Jensen, Marsters, McGuire, Morgan and O'Neill. They have some good kids coming through but man, their roster underperforms badly and deadset, the coach has seriously underwhelmed, he looked clueless at times this season. Not sure where their improvement comes from, Payten looks like he might well be revolted against before '22 is done.

Bulldogs - They are the big recruiters with some big names BUT potentially could implode because they have some volatile types coming in and they are Vaughan, Pangai Jr, Burton (massive in), Addo-Carr, Dufty, King, Asiata and Naden. Outs are Elliott, Hopoate, Meaney, Napa, Lewis, Watene-Zelezniak. These are big ins, really big ins. These guys could transform them into contenders but they don't have much in the spine positions other than Burton who will be a superstar. The question is, can Barrett keep all of the idiots under control? There are several dropkicks and they are now all in the same side, this will be fun to watch grow or more likely, self-destruct.
 
Sproj said:
Now for a more accurate list for all clubs.

The players picked up so far by club:

Panthers - Have lost Burton, Capewell, Naden and bought in no one really, regardless they are fine

Storm - Notable ins are Coates and Meaney and a few other bits and pieces. They lose Hynes, Addo-Carr, Finucane and Lee, plus a few other bits and pieces. They still have a gun side but their depth will e severely tested if they get injuries. Can Coates provide the threat Addo-Carr did?

Rabbitohs - They lose Gagai, Reynolds, Su'A, Mago and others and bring in Milford...maybe, if he isn't in jail (whoever thought anyone would wonder that!). They have been decimated by gun outs and no one really in. Milford and Walker, wowsers that will be...interesting.

Sea-Eagles - Lose Sironen and gain Bullemor. Bullemor is an excellent signing, we all know how much potential he has. They still have TTurbo and that is enough to be up there but not go the extra step. They need a strike centre and there aren't many of those around, particularly for a club with no cap space.

Eels - Lose Fergusen and a few others but no ins. They are a smokey for next season but they will regain Mahoney, that is pretty big.

Roosters - In is Watson, out is Cordner, Friend, Liu and the Morri twins. This team is getting older but they have some big regains in Watson, Keary, Collins, etc. Their regains will be big but they might be starting to age, will be interesting to see which kids / stars they 'convince' to come in over the offseason.

Knights - Ins are Gagai and Clune. I have no idea how they afforded Gagai, they have to be 'bending' their cap. Outs are Shibasaki, Green and Watson. They really need to be top 4 next year or it might all implode, Gagai is a huge in, they have threats at centre on both sides.

Titans - Liu and Turner come in but they need more in the spine, their youth approach may well backfire, I'd be bringing in Berrell from Wynnum-Manly. Their outs are Don, Peachey, Taylor, Rein and a few others. I dunno, their squad seems so unbalanced now, too much unproven youth, sound familiar?

Bottom 8:

Sharks - Ins are Hynes, Finucane, McInnes and outs are Dugan, Johnson, and Townsend. They have some top quality ins but the question really is, who organises at halfback? They will be VERY competitive and if they run with Trindall at 7, well they might well be a smokey next year. This is one side to really watch but another problem is, who is their backline strike? Is their forward pack better than run of the mill? Building nicely.

Dragons - Ins are Burgess, Mbye, Molo, Su'A and their outs are Beale, Clune, Dufty, McInness, Merrin, Norman, Vaughan and a few others. They couldn't ship Vaughan out quick enough when the chance came, this might have more of a fracturing effect than they thought. They have taken on a lot of big contracts that might bite them moving forward. This side seems to...boring. I don't know, Hook has made a Broncos-lite there and they will have an inspired patch once again and then probably fall away like usual.

Tigers - Ins Hastings and Gildart and outs are Leilua, Mbye, Packer and Walters. This side is awful, they have nothing exciting coming in, cannot attract big names and are in turmoil. 2022 spooners?

Warriors - Ins Johnson and Pene, outs are Ah Mau, Hiku, Maumalo, Turner and the big one Tuivasa-Sheck. This team has no decent ins really and have blown a lot of money on some average / downward trending players. They will compete for 8th and that's about it, they will be competitive, they always are but they just don't have enough star power to be more than also rans.

Raiders - Ins are no one but maybe Taylor. Outs are Havili, James, Lui, Scott?, Soliola and and Williams. This side is on a downward swing. They have a REALLY exciting fullback in Savage coming through and a decent spine but the key for them will be their number 7 and who gets it. They could end up contenders or spooners, so hard to get a read on going into '22.

Broncos - Ins are Reynolds, Capewell, Lee, Jensen, James, Pereira and Walters. Outs are Pangai Jr, Lodge, Asiata, Croft, Dearden, Milford, Glenn, Levi and Coates. Losing Coates hurts because he was seriously marketable but the emergence of Cobbo offsets that. Staggs will be like a new recruit on top of the big, big ins. The club has bought in quality players but even better quality blokes. The leadership void has been filled, an organising halfback has been signed and will captain on a not over the top wage. The improvement in the backend of the season coupled with the impressive development of the kids gives supporters PLENTY to be excited about for season '22. Smokeys to challenge for top 4 but more likely 5-8, anything less will be a failed season.

Cowboys - Ins are Hiku and Townsend. Outs are Molo, Jensen, Marsters, McGuire, Morgan and O'Neill. They have some good kids coming through but man, their roster underperforms badly and deadset, the coach has seriously underwhelmed, he looked clueless at times this season. Not sure where their improvement comes from, Payten looks like he might well be revolted against before '22 is done.

Bulldogs - They are the big recruiters with some big names BUT potentially could implode because they have some volatile types coming in and they are Vaughan, Pangai Jr, Burton (massive in), Addo-Carr, Dufty, King, Asiata and Naden. Outs are Elliott, Hopoate, Meaney, Napa, Lewis, Watene-Zelezniak. These are big ins, really big ins. These guys could transform them into contenders but they don't have much in the spine positions other than Burton who will be a superstar. The question is, can Barrett keep all of the idiots under control? There are several dropkicks and they are now all in the same side, this will be fun to watch grow or more likely, self-destruct.
Click to expand...
Vaughan, dufty, TPJ and nadan oh my! They may pull their socks up, for a while, but the limited senior players/leaders in the squad (Josh jackson is all that comes to mind) would concern me.

People may say JAC is a senior player but again, I dont see a leader off the field. This is a bloke that broke early covid rules to go shooting with mates without a gun license.

Any success they get i think will be short lived.
 
The Broncos have to be an 8/10.. done well from a position of less than normal strength.

Not clear how much of an error not going stronger for Hynes will be? Hard to know how they view the internal talent.

Broncs look to be heading up the ladder next year, I mean it's hard not to frankly. Still well short of a top 4 roster until they can develop.. or buy a full spine.

Bulldogs have gone hard with the dollars, still question marks over the culture and the coach.

Titans.. I don't see how you can have a player like Fifita on 1M+ and have any sort of balance in the squad. Might need a new calculator.

Cowboys.... Not happening for them it looks like.

Storm.. A large net loss... Surely they have to slide down the ladder next year, here's to hoping!

Roosters.. Don't really care.. Losing the Morris twins who were playing for peanuts is probably going to hurt though. Walker still must be a few seasons behind ARey and Clearly also.
 
Taylor has reportedly been offered a train and trial deal with the Warriors
 
I don’t think the sharks’ recruitment wil be all that great in practice. Hynes looked far worse at 6 for the storm than he did at fb, how will he adapt to being in the halves in a side that has struggled for direction? Fin was getting injured and concussed far too often towards the end of this season.
 
So on the basis of all of that it would appear:

Spooner candidates: Tigers, Cowboys, Raiders.

8 to 12: Bulldogs, Sharks, St George, Warriors, Broncos, Newcastle, Titans, Raiders

5 to 8: Roosters, Storm, Eels, Souths, Manly , Sharks, Broncos, Newcastle, Titans

1 to 4: Penrith, Storm, Manly, Eels

If Melbourne do continue to slide and Penrith stay relatively injury free I can see Penrith going back to back next year.
 
There has also been talk of a Fogarty hodgson swap on the cards
 
New Posts

Unread

Watch

YouTube
0 0 618
1:22:11
NSWRL Round 8, 1991 - Brisbane Broncos vs Eastern Suburbs Roosters
View full media list »

Active Now

  • Gaz
  • KickHaas
  • Morkel
  • Maddy
  • theshed
  • Sproj
  • 1910
Total: 114 (members: 9, guests: 105)
Robots: 339
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.