POST GAME Round 14 - Storm vs Broncos

Discussion in 'Brisbane Broncos Talk' started by Foordy, Jun 10, 2018.

  1. Cult3

    Cult3 State of Origin Rep

    7,341
    4,087
    He literally has butter on his fingers
     
    Sproj, Number6, Morkel and 2 others like this.
  2. KFC grease.
     
  3. winslow_wong

    winslow_wong State of Origin Rep

    7,054
    3,412
    bris
    Maccas won't be happy he's eating at the competition
     
    PerthBrissy987 likes this.
    Milf gifted him his loyalty card
     
  4. Sproj

    Sproj

    12,195
    5,208
    Would it be fair to say that possibly Bennett got the 2015 credit that perhaps should have gone to Griffin? Hook was building something here and then got punted before it came to fruition. Look at what he has built at Penrith, the guy was a lot better than given credit for.
     
    roo-ted, Gaz, Porthoz and 1 other person like this.
  5. Wash your mouth out!

    The guy who played Hoffman at 5/8?
     
    Stix and mrslong like this.
  6. winslow_wong

    winslow_wong State of Origin Rep

    7,054
    3,412
    bris
    The guy who wanted a team of props and back rowers as centres
     
    Jason Simmons likes this.
  7. holdzy89

    holdzy89 NRL Player

    2,940
    1,511
    Weird situation - Broncos don't make the GF without Bennett, and Penrith aren't where they are now without Jabba. Hook fits in there somewhere.
     
  8. broncos4life

    broncos4life International Rep

    You are kidding right? I get that some people don’t like Bennett and that is fine but this is laughable. Gould is running the show and making the decisions at Penrith, not Griffin. The only thing Griffin deserves credit for is being spineless enough to be someone else’s puppet.

    We got to the grand final in 2015 on the back of some key additions based on Bennett’s arrival. Guys like Boyd and Blair and the changes in our playing style.

    Talk about looking at Griffin’s time here through rose coloured glasses.
     
    Last edited: Jun 14, 2018
  9. roo-ted

    roo-ted NRL Player

    1,088
    467
    I'd say some of the credit would have to go to both Wayne and Hook
     
    Harry Sack, JAHHW and Sproj like this.
  10. Morkel

    Morkel

    17,021
    12,744
    Hook put that team together, and the only reason he played Hoffman at five-eighth was because his Plan A (Milford) and Plan B (Kahu) both failed before Round 1.

    But correct, we don't make the GF without Blair & Boyd. Or Bennett.
     
    Last edited: Jun 14, 2018
  11. BroncsFan

    BroncsFan NRL Player

    1,438
    978
    I daresay hook would be very much on the nose for many Penrith supporters.

    - He has let a number of highly credentialed juniors leave (Moylan, Cartwright, Latu)
    - His team selections would frustrate many I'd imagine (Peachy playing off the bench, to playing 5/8, to playing 2nd row to playing centre (he's also been unable to get Peachy to pass the fcking ball to his winger or anyone for that matter), Merrin starting prop playing 40mins whereas in previous years he was their best forward playing 80mins at lock, Kikau dropped to the bench,) basically just an inability to maintain consistency with the team.
    - His use of the bench remains very suspect (Sione Katoa was playing 5-10mins a game as backup to PWall and he often has a forward on the bench playing 5-10mins a game, which distorts the playing time of the forwards)
    - The team totally shitting the bed last year and not backing up the performances of 2016
     
  12. roo-ted

    roo-ted NRL Player

    1,088
    467
    I'm sure they are furious about being second on the table. Moylan is shit and Cartwright is finding it hard to keep his spot for the GC, so it's not such a bad loss. He can't do much about Merrin being a fat tit. Kikau is on the bench for similar reasons TPJ is for us
     
  13. Why would they be angry at Hook though? Everyone knows he's only a puppet for Gould.
     
  14. BroncsFan

    BroncsFan NRL Player

    1,438
    978
    They're happy at the moment... but I know life long members who wanted nothing more than to see the back of him... and are still frustrated by his coaching decisions.

    There is a reason why many had Hook heading the list of first coach to be sacked.

    At the time the Moylan loss was huge and pissed off many supporters. Not sure where the Moylan is shit is coming from. As 5/8 he's going shit but I'd suggest he's a seriously good fullback.
     
  15. Sproj

    Sproj

    12,195
    5,208
    Yet he is a coach who has been willing to get rid of guys that needed to go despite what fans thought and has not been afraid to give young guys a go and drop veterans who haven’t performed, sounds like a good coach to me.
     
    roo-ted likes this.
  16. Reyter

    Reyter QCup Player

    252
    44
    Whether he was or not at the Broncos, one thing for certain is that he is a good coach now. That probably means I will get denounced as a Penrith supporter but that's ok.
     
  17. [​IMG]
     
    JAHHW likes this.
  18. Sproj

    Sproj

    12,195
    5,208
    The first half of your post makes a good point that I think most would (possibly reluctantly) agree with.

    The second part is unnecessary and serves only one of two purposes - incite inflammatory responses or play the victim card to incite more negativity toward you.

    Cut it out. We as staff don’t care if you feel someone else started it or not, you are letting this kind of pettiness into every single response and it’s wearing thin and completely detracts from any good points you may make.
     
    Foordy, Porthoz, lynx000 and 6 others like this.
    I think the biggest issue with Hook is the attachment he had to the squad. He coached the majority of them in the 20's I believe which is what made it so hard for him to cut them. It's not right, but there it is.

    Edit: When he was with the Broncos obviously
     
    Last edited: Jun 14, 2018
    Foordy likes this.

Share This Page

Loading...