Round 24 Discussion

[JayPee]

Yeah, this is all true. I just think he isn't anywhere near as good as he was made out to be at the Roosters. He has a huge step and is fast. But other than that he isn't anything special.

Yeah I think his passing game is limited. Probably a better version of dugan without the size. I also don't get carried away with saying a bloke is playing poorly when he is in a shit team and also comparing players in different levels of team. Because alot of the time if you just swapped them you would reverse the opinion. It is hard to shine when you are surrounded by mugs. Similar argument around here going on with Ash Taylor atm.

 

[Sproj]

Has he signed for Canterbury?

 

[Organix]

Yeah I think his passing game is limited. Probably a better version of dugan without the size. I also don't get carried away with saying a bloke is playing poorly when he is in a shit team and also comparing players in different levels of team. Because alot of the time if you just swapped them you would reverse the opinion. It is hard to shine when you are surrounded by mugs. Similar argument around here going on with Ash Taylor atm.

Fair enough.

 

[Big Pete]

Similar argument around here going on with Ash Taylor atm.

On the other hand, it's easier to avoid criticism and ridicule in an environment where there are low expectations.

Taylor wouldn't magically be a better player if he played for Sydney or Cronulla. He'd probably offer them as much as Keary and Townsend, but the deficiencies would remain and it's just a question of whether you're able to accept them.

Most people would.

 

[Broncos Maestro]

Anyone praying for the Tigers to beat the Roosters?

 

[Alec]

Anyone praying for the Tigers to beat the Roosters?

Absolutely. Can't see it happening though

 

[ZTop]

I tipped Knights
Don't know why I did. But hell yes

 

[Morkel]

Anyone praying for the Tigers to beat the Roosters?

I try not to waste them. There is a quota you know.

 

[ZTop]

With people praising Addo-Carrs attack, I'm gunna give his defence a wrap

 

[ZTop]

5 penalties within 15 minutes, The end penalty count is going to be huge

 

[ZTop]

This wind is awesome

 

[tommy]

What a bs penalty that led to that try. Can't have the favourites losing to the wooden spooners now can we.

 

[Aldo]

Wish the refs would send one of these Melbourne pricks to the bin. Bunch of fucking grubs.

 

[dbomb91]

Brodie croft i would take over ash taylor

 

[Alec]

Brodie croft i would take over ash taylor

He's probably less talented, but would have also been a lot cheaper too.

 

[dbomb91]

He's probably less talented, but would have also been a lot cheaper too.

Atm i would say they are equal for skill imo
Though its a small sample size with croft aswell he plays in a system like the storm

 

[tommy]

Brodie croft i would take over ash taylor

Careful what you say mate. You'll get hanged by some around here for saying that.

 

[I bleed Maroon]

It'll never happen in a million years but would do backflips seeing Wests choke the chooks today