PRE-GAME Round 6 - Raiders vs Broncos

Discussion in 'Brisbane Broncos Talk' started by Foordy, Apr 11, 2019.

  1. Dash

    Dash NRL Player

    2,673
    1,722
    Brisbane
    And writing off something that happens repeatedly as just a coincidence is naive.
     
    Broncos Maestro, Tom and JAHHW like this.
  2. Dash

    Dash NRL Player

    2,673
    1,722
    Brisbane
    Unless he's on drugs, I don't see why they'd care.
     
    Duality likes this.
  3. Sproj

    Sproj

    14,202
    6,753
    Whether Boyd is trying and stuffing up or not trying and stuffing up is not really the important bit. The important bit is perception to his team, he is the captain after all.

    If your team as a whole is screwing everything up (which they are), how do you as captain rev them up when you are perceived to be a big part of that problem?

    Who is going to listen if your actions don’t look great and you say in the media everything is awesome?

    That makes young, impressionable kids (of which there are many) think their below average performances are also ok.
     
    Tom, Wild Horse and JAHHW like this.
  4. Sproj

    Sproj

    14,202
    6,753
    And inconvenient truth to this argument though is they got smashed by 40 last week, they too are inexperienced and therefore inconsistent. Not a great argument.
     
    Mister Wright, rnabokov and Morkel like this.
  5. Cult3

    Cult3 State of Origin Captain

    8,483
    5,304
    Yeah my bad, ASADA is just part of the agency, along with the National Integrity of Sport Unit (NISU) and the national sports integrity functions of Sport Australia that is now known as the National Sports Tribunal.

    “The new agency provides a one-stop shop for sports integrity, providing easier access for sport but will also enhance the effective coordination and dissemination of intelligence, we will no longer be looking at anti-doping in isolation ” - ASADA CEO David Sharpe

    Maybe ASADA can pass it up the chain of command?
     
    Last edited: Apr 16, 2019
  6. You didn't watch their game last weekend, did you?

    Also, he didn't exactly get instant results. He promoted Jeremy Marshall-King to starting hooker in Round 2 and they got beat 36-16.
     
  7. Foordy

    Foordy

    16,690
    7,569
    if by instant results you mean coming in last place ... then yeah he got instant results.

    the Bulldogs are the last team we should be copying off
     
    Morkel likes this.
  8. Morkel

    Morkel

    19,811
    15,944
    Boyd slipping over, or trying to take the intercept, on more than one occasion is definitely true. Claiming he is doing it deliberately, and avoiding tackles deliberately, is baseless and insulting, no matter how many times you want to normalise it by repeating it.

    If he was deliberately avoiding collisions, why would he be defending in the line so often? It's just a bizarre accusation.
     
    rnabokov, Foordy and Cult3 like this.
  9. Dash

    Dash NRL Player

    2,673
    1,722
    Brisbane
    He has taken the soft every time. In most cases I don't think it would have made a lick of difference, but he has chosen the easier option every single time.

    Darius made three whole tackles in the Dragons game. Clearly defending in the line isn't leading to a lot of collisions.
     
  10. Get off your high horse, we are in equal last place with the Dogs.
    They will be 2 wins up before our floundering mob.
     
    Last edited: Apr 16, 2019
    Accept and Kyall like this.
  11. Morkel

    Morkel

    19,811
    15,944
    No, you've perceived him to have taken the soft options on those occasions. Ignoring the times he does put his body on the line. Which he does.

    Selective stats much?
    * Storm - 8 tackles (Hughes 2)
    * Cowboys - 8 tackles (Kahu 6)
    * Dragons - 3 tackles (Widdop 13)
    * Roosters - 8 tackles (Tedesco 2)
    * Tigers - 7 tackles (Mmmbop 12)

    He's out-tackled his opposite 3 games out of 5, including everyone's hero Tedesco. But yeah, keep imagining what you want.
     
    Cult3 likes this.
  12. Dash

    Dash NRL Player

    2,673
    1,722
    Brisbane
    So 35 tackles for them vs 34 for Boyd? You're right, I withdraw my argument.
     
  13. It's really not a stretch re: going for intercepts, even if it isn't in the forefront of his head when he's doing it, it may even be a subconscious decision, if option A is attempt to tackle this 110kg forward running at me and option B is attempt the intercept, it's reasonable to assume someone with a long list of recent injuries and heading towards the end of their career may veer towards the one that is less likely to result in them getting pulverised.

    In regards to him "slipping over", I really don't know, realistically how many times have we seen that happen over the last 12 months from him? I would wager it's nearly double digits. Once again, my guess is that it's mental. When you factor in the torn achilles and multitude of hamstring & calf strains he's had over the last 4 years, it's pretty reasonable to deduct that he may be opting to "slip over" instead of trying to change direction in unison with the person he's trying to tackle because he's worried about leg injuries, which he's proven to be extremely susceptible to and which often occur (or re-occur in his case) when attempting to change directions at high speeds.

    Because when he defends in the line he has other players there to help and soften the blow, when it's just him on his lonesome at the back there's really no options apart from throw your body in front of the freight train, or don't.
     
  14. Sproj

    Sproj

    14,202
    6,753
    When you are dropping the ball, defending in the line and having less possession = more defense, of course his numbers SHOULD be higher. What you also can't read from statistics is the number of times he also gets caught out of position while defending in the line (at least they haven't been included here). There also probably isn't a statistics for dive-by slippings and arm flying either.

    So that bit about perceptions, they go a few ways.
     
    Tom and JAHHW like this.
  15. Foordy

    Foordy

    16,690
    7,569
    so your big plan to get us back on track is to copy a coach who finished 12th last year and is currently dead last (not to mention coming off a thrashing at the hands of a team that we only lost to in the last minute.)

    that's just brilliant.

    what we need to do is fix up our handling ... do that and we are 3 from 5 to start the season
     
  16. Rookie Alan

    Rookie Alan U18 Player

    29
    9
    Just saw Isaako at a car park next to me, was going to talk to him about his drop balls, then saw his partner with the little one, then said nothing......
     
    GKDonkey and Morkel like this.
  17. Alec

    Alec International Rep

    14,673
    5,749
    "Hey babe, pass me the baby"
    "....I don't think so, hon".
     
  18. Matheos

    Matheos BRL Player

    30
    27
    Sydney
    Why is any talk mentioned of the Bulldogs? It is a huge backhand to the current team that we are compared to them. A poor run to start the season does not define the club or the 30 players in our 2019 roster.
    We are miles ahead of the Bulldogs, they are a terrible example to replicate - poor salary cap management, lack of on-field quality, poor senior management, etc. They will be in the bottom four for a few years, guaranteed.
     
  19. Tom

    Tom State of Origin Rep

    5,186
    3,966
    The "slip" against MCK last week, it really was c-grade acting. b-grade at best.
     
    Broncos Maestro likes this.
  20. Foordy

    Foordy

    16,690
    7,569
    He was the only one even attempting to stop MCK ...

    first he put the pressure on to stop the FG attempt, which he did successfully, then had to scramble back to fullback since it seems 4 players decided that the best play was to let MCK run, instead of tackling the bastard.

    this season there have been plenty of things to have a go at Boyd for ... you don't need to go manufacturing shit.
     

Share This Page

Loading...