Walters looked better in the trials without Reynolds there. For whatever reason, the Walters and Reynolds combination isn't quite working. Walters is just lacking a bit of creativity, and besides some ok individual moments with ball in hand, he isn't offering too much in attack for his outside players.
I think he still deserves a spot in the team so I would be putting Walters back to hooker, and giving Gamble a go at five-eighth. I'm not sure if Gamble will gel well with Reynolds either, but maybe he could offer a bit more creativity in attack. His energy and enthusiasm might also lift us too.
Though, out of all our halves options (aside from Mam), I want Te Maire Martin to play alongside Reynolds. This is completely based off the player he once was before his injury/retirement. I have no idea what he's form is like anymore, and if he even is a genuine chance to make an NRL comeback. But if he was an actual chance to play first grade, I think he would compliment Reynolds pretty well. He would offer us some spark in attack and might be able to create some more point scoring opportunities than what we are getting from Walters right now.
Is anyone able to provide an update on Martin and where his form is at?